The George W. Bush refugees As migrants pour into

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Jun 2, 2016 at 4:50 PM

Quote:

The George W. Bush refugees

As migrants pour into Europe, Americans must bear the blame.

By Andrew Bacevich
| 9/18/15, 1:54 PM CET

Quote:

That Saddam was a brutal tyrant is a given. We need not mourn his departure. Yet while he ruled he at least kept a lid on things. Bush blew off that lid, naively expecting liberal democracy or at least deference to American authority to emerge.

Instead, “liberating” Iraq produced conditions conducive to the violent radicalism today threatening to envelop the region.

The Islamic State offers but one manifestation of this phenomenon. Were it not for Bush’s invasion of Iraq, ISIL would not exist — that’s a fact. Responsibility for precipitating the rise of this vile movement rests squarely with Washington.

‘‘If you break it, you own it.” Colin Powell’s Pottery Barn Rule, warning George W. Bush of the consequences of invading Iraq, turned out to be dead wrong.

Make that half wrong. Bush broke it — “it” being a swath of the greater Middle East. But the U.S. adamantly refuses to accept anything like ownership of the consequences stemming from Bush’s recklessly misguided act.

Not least among those consequences is the crisis that finds refugees fleeing Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan and other parts of the Islamic world in search of asylum in the West. The European nations most directly affected have greeted this wave with more hostility than hospitality — Germany, for a time, at least offering a notable exception.

For its part, the U.S. has responded with pronounced indifference. In a gesture of undisguised tokenism, the Obama administration has announced it will admit a grand total of 10,000 Syrians — one-eightieth the number that Germany has agreed to accept this year alone.

No doubt proximity plays a part in explaining the contrast between German and U.S. attitudes. Viewed from Wichita or Walla Walla, the plight of those who hand themselves over to human traffickers in hopes of crossing the Mediterranean plays out at a great distance. Syria is what Neville Chamberlain would have described as a faraway country of which Americans know nothing (and care less). And Iraq and Afghanistan are faraway countries that most Americans have come to regret knowing.

Such attitudes may be understandable. They are also unconscionable.

* * *
To attribute the refugee crisis to any single cause would be misleading. A laundry list has contributed: historical and sectarian divisions within the region; the legacy of European colonialism; the absence of anything even approximating enlightened local leadership able to satisfy the aspirations of people tired of corruption, economic stagnation, and authoritarian rule; the appeal — inexplicable to Westerners — of violent Islamic radicalism. All play a role.

Yet when it comes to why this fragile structure collapsed just now we can point to a single explanation — the cascading after-effects of a decision made by Bush during the spring of 2002 to embrace a doctrine of preventative war.

The previous autumn, U.S. forces toppled the government of Afghanistan, punishing the Taliban for giving sanctuary to those who plotted the 9/11 attacks. Bush effectively abandoned Afghanistan to its fate and set out to topple another regime, one that had no involvement whatsoever in 9/11.

For Bush, going after Saddam Hussein’s Iraq formed part of a larger strategy. He and his lieutenants fancied that destroying the old order in the greater Middle East would position the U.S. to create a more amenable new order. Back in 1991, after a previous Iraq encounter, Bush’s father had glimpsed a “new world order.” Now a decade later, the son set out to transform the father’s vision into reality.

The administration called this its Freedom Agenda, which would begin in Iraq but find further application throughout the greater Middle East. Coercion rather than persuasion held the key to its implementation, its plausibility resting on unstoppable military power. For Bush’s inner circle, including Dick Cheney, Condoleezza Rice, Donald Rumsfeld and Paul Wolfowitz (but not Powell), victory was foreordained.

They miscalculated. The unsettled (but largely ignored) condition of Afghanistan after the fall of the Taliban already hinted at the extent of that miscalculation. The chaos that descended upon Iraq as a direct result of the U.S. invasion affirmed it. The Freedom Agenda made it as far as Baghdad and there it died.

That Saddam was a brutal tyrant is a given. We need not mourn his departure. Yet while he ruled he at least kept a lid on things. Bush blew off that lid, naively expecting liberal democracy or at least deference to American authority to emerge. Instead, “liberating” Iraq produced conditions conducive to the violent radicalism today threatening to envelop the region.

The Islamic State offers but one manifestation of this phenomenon. Were it not for Bush’s invasion of Iraq, ISIL would not exist — that’s a fact. Responsibility for precipitating the rise of this vile movement rests squarely with Washington.

So rather than cluck over the reluctance of Greeks, Serbs, Hungarians and others to open their borders to those fleeing from the mess the U.S. played such a large part in creating, Americans would do better to engage in acts of contrition.

On the 10th anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, former president Bush visited New Orleans, implicitly acknowledging that his administration’s response to that disaster just might have fallen a bit short. It was a handsome gesture. A similar gesture is in order toward the masses fleeing the region he set out to remake.

It’s never too late to say you’re sorry

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Job Market Shifts: Adaptation vs. Fairness Dilemma

The Chameleon Effect in Today's Job Market Walk into any open-space office these days, and you'll see faces plastered with composed, work-ready smiles—faces that might not look so familiar outside those walls. The modern workplace has draped its cloak over individual personalities, with the mighty pressure to 'fit in' often forcing a change in how folks present...

MCatalysis Secures $5M to Disrupt Fuel Cost Dynamics

Funding Fuels Innovation MCatalysis has just secured a hefty $5 million in seed funding to throw down with the big dogs in energy production. This isn't your regular backyard science project; this company is serious about changing the game with a tech-driven approach that could undercut current fuel prices. HL Energy Ventures and Oxford Science Enterprises are backing...

LeoLabs and SciTec Partner for $93.7M Space Force Deal

LeoLabs and SciTec Join Forces for Space Dominance The space race ain't just about rockets blasting off anymore. It's about making sure we've got eyes everywhere, even on the back of our heads, so to speak. Enter LeoLabs teaming up with SciTec to help the U.S. Space Force upgrade their radar systems to something out of a sci-fi flick, armed with a $93.7 million contract...

Cap Juluca: Caribbean Luxury Redefined on Maundays Bay

The Tranquil Call of Maundays Bay Find me dipping my toes in the sands of Maundays Bay come October 10, 2026, and you'll understand why this slice of Anguilla stakes its claim to being the best beach on the globe. Cap Juluca, that crown jewel of Caribbean luxury, swings open its doors once more, promising indulgence framed by turquoise waters and the soft whisper of white...

EFSI Shareholders on Alert Amid M&A Deal Scrutiny

Eagle Financial Services Under the Microscope A buzz is picking up in the world of mergers and acquisitions, and this time, it's Eagle Financial Services, Inc. (NASDAQ: EFSI) caught in the crosshairs. What's the chatter all about? Well, it looks like Juan Monteverde and his crew over at Monteverde & Associates PC have set their sights on Eagle's proposed sale to John...

CUBEX Lights Up Veterinary Care with Mini Essential

Inventory Woes? Meet Mini Essential If you’ve ever worked in or around veterinary hospitals, you know the old-school headaches of managing controlled substances. Picture this: piles of paper logs, end-of-shift recounting, and inevitable discrepancies that rear their ugly heads long after closing time. Enter CUBEX, shaking things up with their latest launch, Mini...

Midlife ADHD in Women: New Challenges and Solutions

ADHD Evolution in Women's Midlife They say change is the only constant, and boy, does that ring true for women navigating the turbulent seas of ADHD as they hit 40 and beyond. According to Germaine Swanson, the ADHD landscape changes dramatically in midlife, especially for women. We're talking about a mix of hormonal shifts, increasing life demands, and changes in brain...

Global Communication Works Opens SignlLabs™ AI Licensing

AI Signaling Moves Beyond GCW's Own Clients Remember when we first looked at GCW's SignlLabs and the idea of helping brands show up inside ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Copilot and Perplexity? Well, Global Communication Works is taking the next step. Instead of keeping its AI Signaling playbook inside the agency walls, GCW is now opening SignlLabs up for licensing

RARE Foundation Rebrands, Focus Still Strong

Unveiling the RARE Foundation's New Identity In the stock market, you ride waves of change, and let me tell you, it ain't just stocks and bonds that change names and faces. Case in point: The EveryLife Foundation for Rare Diseases has spiffed up as the RARE Foundation. New name, new logo, the whole enchilada. This isn't just a cosmetic touch-up, though. It's about...

Sacrifice Unending: 9/11's Lingering Health Toll

The Unseen Toll of 9/11 on the Firefighter Community Two and a half decades since that fateful morning of September 11, 2001, we're staring at a grim reality. The heroic souls of the New York City Fire Department (FDNY)—those who ran toward peril when others ran away—are still paying the price. Incredibly, more than 400 FDNY members have succumbed to World Trade...