Quote:White working-class Democrats won’t be fleeing the party to vote for Donald Trump.
By Jamelle Bouie
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politi..._myth.html
Donald Trump is wily, unpredictable, unprincipled, and opportunistic. And for some observers, this makes him a formidable prospect in a general election. “To be successful as a Republican candidate you have to be the equivalent of a neutron bomb,” said Republican strategist Steve Schmidt to the Washington Post. “He’s a neutron bomb. Donald Trump has been disruptive in the way Uber has been disruptive in the taxi industry.”
“I think there’s a lot of Reagan Democrats waiting to vote for him,” said Chris Matthews during a January broadcast of his MSNBC show Hardball. “I think Pennsylvania might well be in play if he’s the nominee because he’s unpredictable.”
Because Trump isn’t a doctrinaire conservative—because he appeals on emotion and not policy—the theory is that he can win white working-class Democrats and other disaffected voters in the Democratic coalition. Trump, incidentally, agrees. “I have a chance of winning New York. You know, you look at these politicians [and] they always talk about the six states—you’ve got to win this one, that one. You have to win Ohio, you have to win Florida,” he said last month. ”I can change the game because I really have a chance of New York, I’m going to win Virginia. I’m going to win Michigan, as an example.”
But there’s a big problem with this theory, which also underlies a cottage industry of fan fiction about the presidential election: There’s no evidence. At this stage of the election, there is nothing that points to any Democratic support or enthusiasm for Trump. Instead, it’s just the opposite. Trump is deeply unpopular with Democratic voters. Even white ones.
According to the Reuters tracking poll, which follows responses over time to measure changes in support or opinion, more than 73 percent of whites who voted for President Obama in the last presidential election hold a negative opinion of Trump, versus 27 percent who hold a favorable opinion.
It’s difficult to do a direct comparison, but this is in line with Mitt Romney’s standing among white self-identified liberals in the September before the 2012 election.
Better is an apples-to-apples comparison between Trump and his nearest rival, Ted Cruz. Whites who voted for Obama like Cruz—a doctrinaire conservative ideologue—about as much as they like Trump, 28 percent favorable to 72 percent unfavorable.
What about working-class whites? As it stands, the real estate mogul breaks even among whites with a high school degree (a rough measure of “working class”), 52 percent favorable to 48 percent unfavorable.
Among those who voted for Obama, this drops to 27 percent favorable to 73 percent unfavorable, tying Cruz on both scores. Trump, in other words, is about as liked among working-class Democratic whites as the least-popular Republican politician left in the field.
This is in line with a focus group of white working-class voters conducted by Working America, an affiliate of the AFL-CIO, which canvassed neighborhoods outside of Cleveland and Pittsburgh. Ninety percent of respondents voted in 2012, and among “decided” Democrats, 25 percent backed Trump. But when you counted all Democrats—those without a candidate choice as well as those with one—just 11 percent backed Trump.
None of this should be shocking. Missing in the discussion of working-class whites and the Democratic Party is the degree to which Democrats have already lost much of the white working class.
Just 36 percent of whites without college degrees voted for Obama in 2012, when he won the election by a 4-point margin in the popular vote, picking up 26 states (and the District of Columbia) and 330 electoral college votes.
Democrats don’t need to win working-class whites or even to come close—they just need to stem their losses. And even that’s less acute than it’s been.
A growing Hispanic and Asian electorate, along with steady black voting, has tilted the electoral board a little more in the Democrats’ favor, giving them a greater cushion with white voters.
On the other side, without an influx of minority voters—which isn’t happening—Republicans need supermajorities of all white voters to win, even in Rust Belt states where Trump allegedly has his greatest appeal.
And as Greg Sargent points out for the Washington Post, this is a huge reach. To win Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Ohio on the strength of working-class whites, Trump would have to beat Romney’s totals by an average of 12 points, assuming he doesn’t lose any college-educated whites or see worse performance with nonwhites.
If you broaden the analysis to all whites, Trump has to improve on Romney by an average of 8 points—a difficult challenge, even before you consider the Democratic campaign against him.
The basic truth is that Donald Trump is one of the most unpopular figures in national politics. He’s disliked (or despised) by a large majority of Americans.
This isn’t because the public doesn’t know him. With nearly $2 billion in free coverage from news networks—dwarfing Hillary Clinton’s $746 million—the public knows him well. And they don’t like what they see.
Far from scrambling political alliances in his favor, Trump may be the key to further gains for Democrats, from solidifying an advantage with Hispanics to making inroads with college-educated whites.
If Trump upends the fall presidential race, it likely won’t be because he’s gamed the system or discovered a new, unprecedented path to a majority. It will be because, like Ozymandias’ creature, he united a divided electorate against him, in a broad effort to save the country from its worse impulses.
White working-class Democrats won’t be fleeing the party
Top 10 Most Recent News Articles
AI Gives CPA Firms a New Advisory Staffing Math Today
Month-end just got a lot less comfortable for firms living on the clock. Netsurit and Southwestern Talent are pitching the Virtual CFO Platform as a way for CPA firms to turn machine-led analysis into advisory work without first building a costly bench of specialists. That is not a cute workflow tweak. It goes straight at the labor model that has kept plenty of accounting...
Continue Reading
Premier Energy's €850M Debt Bet on Evryo Nears Close
A Bridge Loan Gives Way to a Real Commitment Eight hundred and fifty million euros is not the sort of number a company tosses around for decoration. Premier Energy has secured a five-year senior facilities agreement to fund its planned acquisition of Evryo Group, including electricity distribution subsidiary Distribu?ie Energie Oltenia S.A., and to refinance roughly...
Continue Reading
Sokin’s UAE License Turns Expansion Into Real Payments Plumbing
Dubai expansion headlines are cheap; regulated local money movement is not. That is why Sokin’s newly approved Dubai Financial Services Authority license deserves more than the usual fintech applause line. The company has paired that approval with AED accounts, local payment rails, a One Za’abeel office and a plan to double its UAE staff over the next year. None of...
Continue Reading
Vuzix Bets on Lightweight Color Glasses for OEM Partners
Forty grams is where this story gets interesting, because faces are ruthless product testers. People will tolerate plenty of clever technology right up until it pinches, looks goofy, leaks light, or makes them feel like they are wearing a science project. Vuzix is trying to clear that hurdle with Ultralite Color, a full-color AI eyewear reference platform built for OEM...
Continue Reading
Telit Cinterion Tests Its Defense Connectivity Pitch
Defense connectivity is a messy business, and Telit Cinterion is leaning straight into the mess at NATO Edge 2026 in Izmir, Turkey. From November 17 through 19, the company is using Booth L86 to show how several wireless links can live inside one mission-focused setup. That may sound like standard trade-show wallpaper, but the underlying problem is very real: military and...
Continue Reading
Vector's Peptide Pact Needs Proof Before Any Payday
A famous orthopedic name can open doors, but it cannot manufacture clinical evidence. That is the plain reality behind Vector Science and Therapeutics' new collaboration with the Andrews Research & Education Foundation. Dr. James Andrews carries enormous credibility in sports medicine, earned across more than five decades of work. For Vector, that association matters. For...
Continue Reading
Ivanti's AI Push Rests on Data, Control and Results
Enterprise AI has a nasty habit of sounding brilliant right up until it meets a messy fleet of laptops, phones, patches and permissions. Ivanti’s latest product push is aimed squarely at that unglamorous collision point: giving AI systems governed access to the operational data inside Ivanti Neurons, then keeping humans and pre-set permissions in charge of what happens...
Continue Reading
Pacific Surfliner Faces Thanksgiving Capacity Test
Thanksgiving traffic on Southern California freeways is its own yearly punishment, and the Pacific Surfliner is making a sensible pitch: leave the car parked and let the coast roll past the window. For travelers, that can be a real relief. For anyone watching public transportation, this is also a useful little stress test of whether a busy state-supported rail corridor...
Continue Reading
COPD Support Program Targets a Costly Care Gap Today
Breathing trouble gets shrugged off far too easily, and that casual mistake has consequences. World COPD Day puts chronic obstructive pulmonary disease back in view, with the American Lung Association emphasizing a free Lung Health Navigator program for people living with COPD, their caregivers and families. This is not flashy medicine or a miracle-cure pitch. It is...
Continue Reading
Seeking Alpha Premium Review: Data Meets Human Judgment
A spreadsheet can spot a cracked windshield, but it cannot tell you where the truck is headed. That is the useful, slightly irritating truth behind Seeking Alpha Premium’s 2026 pitch: it puts an enormous amount of stock-research machinery in one place, yet the investor still has to do the driving. Software Experts has highlighted the service in its review of...
Continue ReadingTop 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles
Survey Reveals Enterprises Unready for Rising AI Power Needs
Understanding the Readiness Gap in AI Power Demand Recent research sheds light on a concerning trend among enterprises regarding their preparedness to meet the escalating power demands posed by artificial intelligence (AI). Conducted by SambaNova, this survey demonstrates that while many leaders acknowledge the urgent need for energy management in AI, only a fraction...
Continue Reading
Ellevio Reports Solid Gains in H1 Despite Cash Flow Dip
In a world where the electricity flows must keep pace with surging demands and regulatory labyrinths, Ellevio AB is not just hanging in there; it's pushing forward with gusto. They've just released their Half-year Report for 2026, and the numbers show a steady pulse amidst the evolving Swedish energy market conditions. With key stakeholders like OMERS Infrastructure and...
Continue Reading
Dan Orlando Releases Captivating New Music Video for Fans
Dan Orlando's Artistic Journey Shines in New Video Musician Dan Orlando has just released his newest music video, 'Music In My Head.' This marks an important step in his artistic journey, showcasing his growth and dedication to producing music that resonates across various styles. A Heartfelt Connection with His Audience The video for 'Music In My Head' highlights...
Continue Reading
Revolutionizing API Testing with Parasoft's Agentic AI
Parasoft Enhances API Testing with Agentic AI Parasoft, a global leader in AI-driven software testing solutions, has unveiled its latest innovation: the Agentic AI approach. This groundbreaking feature aims to transform API testing, making it more efficient and effective for software development teams. By integrating intelligent, outcome-based scenario testing, Parasoft...
Continue Reading
PPL Corporation's Growth Continues: Q1 Insights Unpacked
PPL Corporation Reports Impressive First Quarter Earnings PPL Corporation (NYSE: PPL) has posted remarkable financial results for the first quarter, demonstrating solid performance and strategic execution. The company's reported earnings per share (EPS) for the quarter stands at $0.56, a significant increase compared to $0.42 in the previous year. Notably, ongoing...
Continue Reading