Why Merrick Garland Was a Brilliant Tactical Move When he

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Bhawks
Why Merrick Garland Was a Brilliant Tactical Move
When he wants to play the game, President Obama has game.


I like the argument from the GOP that 'the people should have a say in who the next SCOTUS judge should be', overlooking the inconvenient fact that Obama was reelected by a 5 M vote margin...51%-47%. Love the irony of that '47%'! So what about the 'people' who voted for Obama, no say?

Quote:
Obama's vote total was the second most votes received in the history of presidential elections and the most ever for a reelected president. Obama owns the all-time record for votes in a single election as well in 2008.


And the electoral vote margin doesn't matter either?

381px-Cartogram%E2%80%942012_Electoral_Vote.svg.png

landscape-1458147224-barryobame.jpg

BY CHARLES P. PIERCE
MAR 16, 2016

Quote:
Of course, the president could've nominated Lin-Manuel Miranda, Zombie Louis Brandeis, Oliver Wendell Whitebread, or Trigger and got the same reaction.

"My view is we should not be confirming somebody during this presidential election cycle. I mean, we're already well into the presidential campaign, it's the last year of the Obama presidency. I think it would be better to have the people play a role here, you know, give the people a voice in this by saying, 'OK, let's make this a part of this presidential campaign. I think that's the better thing for the country right now. If you did it this year, it would be ugly."

And that was reasonable, moderate Rob Portman of Ohio, spouting gibberish. Wait until some of the real stars of the carny midway get going. Wait until the outlying precincts check in.

The Senate Judiciary Committee is just chockful of wingnutty goodness; Tailgunner Ted Cruz and Mike Lee, the konztitooshunal skolar from Utah, are both members. Lee took to the Twitter machine to explain why he'll be taking the summer off from doing one of his only jobs.

And, of course, the Republican presidential frontrunner, who wouldn't know Merrick Garland if he sat in his lap, and doesn't know enough about constitutional government to feed to the fish, had some thought-like sentiments he'd like to share.

"I think the next president should make the pick, and I think they shouldn't go forward, and I believe I'm pretty much in line with what the Republicans are saying."

Why? Because he's Trump and you're not, loser.

They're in a tough spot. Merrick Garland is an almost universally respected jurist who no less than Orrin Hatch has praised fulsomely on a number of different occasions. In fact, it can be argued that the president flipped the script on Hatch. Oh, Merrick Garland is somebody for whom you could vote? Cool beans, O.H. I happen to have Merrick Garland right here.

Mr. Obama demanded a fair hearing for Judge Garland and said that refusing to even consider his nomination would provoke "an endless cycle of more tit for tat" that would undermine the democratic process for years to come. "I simply ask Republicans in the Senate to give him a fair hearing, and then an up or down vote," Mr. Obama said. "If you don't, then it will not only be an abdication of the Senate's constitutional duty, it will indicate a process for nominating and confirming judges that is beyond repair."

So it's a masterpiece of trolling from a guy who's become very, very good at that. I understand the frustration of the president's progressive supporters at the idea of a 60-ish white guy replacing a 70-ish dead white guy on the Supreme Court. (I would've preferred Jane Kelly from the Eighth Circuit, who already had heads exploding.) I'm sure there were several dozen more diverse, and clearly no-more-fcks-to-give, choices he could've made.

But Garland's work as a supervising DOJ attorney in the Oklahoma City bombing case intrigues me, and it is likely to light up the far distant precincts of wingnuttia as well.

At the very least, he's aware of the wildness loose in the country. He seems moderate and judicious and very unlikely to stray too far out of bounds from what this president and his supporters think a Supreme Court justice should be.

His opinions on the appellate rights of criminal defendants could use some work, but he's not likely to join with the likes of Samuel Alito to take an ax to things like the Miranda decision. He's not a law'n'order guy. Tom Goldstein of the invaluable SCOTUSBlog put together a solid compendium of Garland's record the last time his name arose to fill a vacancy on the Court, when Garland was passed over in favor of Justice Elena Kagan.

All of which is, for the moment, anyway, moot. This is a purely tactical move, and it's an awfully good one. Right now, Republican senators are saying that they won't even take one-on-one meetings with the guy, let alone give him a committee vote, let alone give him a confirmation vote in the Senate.

This was precisely the reaction the president was hoping for, although he didn't exactly have to be Nostradamus to make this play. But I want to know more about this comic book collection.

"[SCOTUS nominee Merrick Garland] put himself through Harvard Law School by working as a tutor, by stocking shoes in a shoe store, and in what is always a painful moment for any young man, by selling his comic book collection," Obama said. "It's tough. [I've] been there."

Hey, at least Garland cashed in. My mother threw all of mine out when I went away to college. I coulda been somebody. I coulda had class. I coulda had a cool robe and a lifetime job.
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

CVS Study: GLP-1 Drugs Effective But Costly

Updated Category News Views 119

Can GLP-1s Deliver Value at Their Current Price? Alright, folks, here's a real-world gut check from CVS Health. They crunched some numbers using Aetna's anonymized claims data, and the results are eye-opening. These GLP-1s are showing promising health outcomes—lower hospital visits, better clinical results, yada yada. But when it comes to savings, they ain't quite...

Continue Reading
Uber Data Breach: Class Action Investigation Begins

Updated Category News Views 283

When Tech Meets Trouble: Uber's Data Breach Picture this: the hum of Uber rides weaving through your city, drivers none the wiser that personal info has been pried from the vaults thanks to their tech partner, Fireworks AI. Uber, folks, is in hot water once again. This isn’t just another tech hiccup; it's a legal whirlwind brewing up courtesy of Edelson Lechtzin LLP, a...

Continue Reading
Beef 'O' Brady's Expands Into Tuscaloosa Market

Updated Category News Views 203

A New Player in Town: Beef 'O' Brady's Lands in Tuscaloosa Listen up, sports fans and pub grub lovers of Tuscaloosa! Beef 'O' Brady's just kicked down the doors and expanded its reach, opening a location smack on McFarland Boulevard. The place threw open its doors on October 26 and is set to make waves in the local scene, driven by the dedicated hands of Mitul Patel and...

Continue Reading
JOYEE N01 Debuts Globally with First 2,000 Deliveries

Updated Category News Views 284

JOYYE N01 Breaks into the Global Market Now, here we go, folks—a Chinese car with ambitions bigger than the Sahara. On October 28, the JOYEE N01 rolled off the assembly line and into the international scene with a lot of fanfare at FAW's Yancheng Branch. Mark my words, this isn't just another model trying to strut into the global auto arena. This event delivered the...

Continue Reading
InstaHeat 35K: FOGATTI Offers Upgraded RV Furnace Control

Updated Category News Views 343

Winter RV Trips Just Got Cozier There's nothing quite like hitting the open road in an RV during the winter months. But let's face it, nobody wants to return to a cabin that's as frigid as the great outdoors. Here's where FOGATTI steps up its game with the InstaHeat Ultra 35K RV Furnace. They’ve tinkered with the thermostat to iron out more precise control, just in time...

Continue Reading
IDEAYA's IDE101: A New Front in Cancer Battle

Updated Category News Views 212

IDEAYA's Bold Move in Precision Medicine IDEAYA Biosciences, no stranger to the frontlines of cancer treatment, is gunning for a breakthrough with their latest pick, IDE101. They're jumping into the ring with a potential first-in-class inhibitor targeting CDKN2A-deficiency—a notorious player in the solid tumor game. They're not just mixing things up for the sake of it;...

Continue Reading
Employment Law Suit Hits ABC: Alleged Wage Violations

Updated Category News Views 129

ABC Under Fire for Labor Code Violations You know it's a rocky road when a company like American Broadcasting Companies, Inc. lands itself in hot water with accusations riding high on labor law violations. People yapping about lunch breaks? Well, that’s the ball game here. Meal and Rest Break Controversies According to a recent lawsuit filed by Blumenthal Nordrehaug...

Continue Reading
WHO and RCSI Bahrain Join Forces on Health Initiatives

Updated Category News Views 406

Forging a Healthier Pathway In a world where healthcare challenges rise faster than my blood pressure during a stock market crash, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI) – Medical University of Bahrain have inked a deal to tackle these issues head-on. The memorandum of understanding (MoU) signed on November 15, 2026,...

Continue Reading
D-Wave Quantum Hit with Securities Fraud Lawsuit

Updated Category News Views 325

A Legal Quagmire for D-Wave Quantum Investors Securities fraud lawsuits are like light in a dark alley—you need them when the truth's been stashed out of sight, but they illuminate the dirty and damp parts of investment strategies nobody wants to talk about. Right now, D-Wave Quantum Inc. is smack dab in the middle of such litigious action. If you had the misfortune of...

Continue Reading
Investors Gear Up for Lennar Class Action Lawsuit

Updated Category News Views 251

High Stakes and Hard Hits for Lennar Stockholders There’s rarely a dull moment in the world of Wall Street, and Lennar Corporation (NYSE: LEN) is proving that rule right now. As a whiff of scandal wafts through the air, the famed homebuilder and its bigwigs are staring down the barrel of a formidable class action lawsuit. The question is, just how deep do the alleged...

Continue Reading
s?page=2">More News Articles