Dated, but at least as accurate/pertinent as when it was

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Bhawks Bhawks #4901
Dated, but at least as accurate/pertinent as when it was written last Aug.

Quote:
The downside of being an American demagogue is that your big head inevitably bangs against a low ceiling. There are only so many voters who will pull the lever for a Maximum Leader type.

George Wallace, perhaps the greatest of American demagogues, scored only 13.5 percent of the vote in his independent run in the 1968 presidential election. And that’s the year the streets were on fire, the nation was at war and inflation was kicking in.


Quote:
Donald Trump, American Demagogue

And the press corps that just doesn’t get him.

By Jack Shafer
August 10, 2015


Demagogues like Donald Trump exhaust the patience of the political press corps because reporters fundamentally misunderstand the candidates' appeal.

Reporters like to think that logic and reason hold sway, so they believe a demagogue can be easily disarmed by exposing his crimes against logic, his pandering to the uninformed and his manipulative emotionalism. They’re entirely wrong—as the last month of The Donald’s unlikely rise to the top of the Republican presidential heap has demonstrated day after day.

Late last month, after Trump disparaged the war record of Sen. John McCain, the political class began composing the real-estate developer’s campaign obituary. Washington Post Chief Correspondent Dan Balz, inheritor of David Broder’s status as the high priest of conventional wisdom, landed on Trump’s back with a July 20 piece titled (in the print edition) “The downfall of The Donald? Attack on McCain may be Trump’s Waterloo.”

Balz speculated that Trump had finally “crossed” a line that would likely marginalize him and his campaign. He gathered quotations from other Republicans—many anonymous, of course—to define that line-crossing. One called the description of McCain “lethal” to Trump’s prospects.

Another predicted “a complete cratering” of support for Trump, and still another foresaw him marginalized as a “niche candidate.” “The fact that he has no filter is what some voters find appealing, but it’s that lack of a filter that could doom his presidential campaign,” GOP pollster Neil Newhouse told Balz.

Like any journalistic priest, Balz performed some ledger balancing by citing Republicans who weren’t ready to write Trump’s political obituary. After all, even end-timers allow that God might change his appointment for the final days. But the thrust of Balz’s piece was unmistakable—Trump had finally gone too far to be taken seriously.

Balz’s intuition was widely shared. “This is the beginning of the end of Donald Trump,” fellow presidential candidate Lindsey Graham promptly told CNN. The incident marked a likely “inflection point” for the Trump campaign, reported the New York Times, as Nate Cohn wrote, “His support will erode as the tone of coverage shifts from publicizing his anti-establishment and anti-immigration views.” “The Beginning of the End of Trump,” stated Washington Post opinion writer Jonathan Capehart. “Is This the Tipping Point for Donald Trump?” asked the headline at NBC News.

Yet Trump has survived the McCain incident to transgress again and again, up to and through the Fox News Channel debate. The very thing that was supposed to slay him is only making him stronger, yet the press has yet to correct its mistake.

Speaking on Fox after the debate, pundit Charles Krauthammer said, “The real story is the collapse of Trump in this debate.” Two days after the debate, National Journal asked, “Is this the End of Donald Trump?” and MSNBC offered, “ ‘The Beginning of the End’: Inside Trump’s RedState Meltdown.” Today, the Guardian reported, “GOP Frontrunner’s Jab at Megyn Kelly May Be Beginning of End.”

The press can’t get Trump right because they have so little experience reporting on demagogues. Reporters believe that if they lay out a demagogue’s contradictions, quote people who cringe at what he has said or compile lists of his despicable utterance, that the demagogue will sink under his own weight.

Nuh-uh. The modern American demagogue—I’m thinking Huey Long, Father Charles Coughlin, Strom Thurmond, Joseph McCarthy, George Wallace, and Pat Buchanan—is more resilient than that.

Or I should say that the demagogues’ faithful cannot not be easily persuaded to abandon their leader once they adopt him. If anything, establishment attacks on a demagogue only stiffen the loyalties of his subjects, proving to them that he is telling truth to power.

The demagogue’s formula, which can vary, tends to simplify all politics and policy to single irrefutable talking points. In Trump’s case, he reliably heralds himself as a “smart” man who can solve problems the “stupid” people of Washington can’t by the pure force of his own will.

For Trump’s core followers (“demagoguettes”?), it matters little that he has demonstrated no consistency on the issues, as my Politico colleague Timothy Noah wrote last month. Trump’s core followers ignore the press corps’ attempt to alert them to his “eclectic, improvisational and often contradictory” policy preferences.

Single-payer advocate a couple of campaign cycles ago, hater of Obamacare now. A hawk when giving speeches, he rarely endorses military intervention. He flip-flops on trade. Assuming that they notice, this doesn’t bother Trump supporters because they trust their man’s common sense and patriotism to do the right thing.

If he promises to be uncompromising today, they will forgive him for compromising tomorrow because, you know, things change.

The standard American demagogue relies on anger and resentment to attract supporters. But Trump’s fury is too comic to stir the masses. He makes angry faces but he’s almost never really mad. Instead, to cultivate the disaffected he pins his banner to his standing as a political outsider, as a champ who can’t be beaten. Trump’s loose mouth—a liability attached to any another candidate—becomes an asset for him. “ Finally! A candidate who speaks his mind without filters!” you can almost hear his supporters say, even if most of what he speaks is rubbish.

The ambiguity of the Trump message—his promises to make America great again, to show the Chinese and the Russians and the Mexicans that we mean business—goes down like lite beer. “I play to people’s fantasies,” he wrote in 1987 Trump: The Art of the Deal. “A little hyperbole never hurts. People want to believe that something is the biggest and the greatest and the most spectacular.”

“I call it truthful hyperbole. It’s an innocent form of exaggeration—and a very effective form of promotion,” Trump continued.

The downside of being an American demagogue is that your big head inevitably bangs against a low ceiling. There are only so many voters who will pull the lever for a Maximum Leader type.

George Wallace, perhaps the greatest of American demagogues, scored only 13.5 percent of the vote in his independent run in the 1968 presidential election. And that’s the year the streets were on fire, the nation was at war and inflation was kicking in.

Sustained demagoguery requires a meaty, divisive issue—like Communism, school busing or a good old-fashioned culture war—to thrive. But even when those conditions exist, the American demagogue usually has to struggle to maintain a conspicuous place in the public eye.

Once he’s blasted off, the American demagogue often takes years him to lose orbital velocity and slowly crash to earth. The American demagogue’s followers grow despondent at his failure to achieve real power, and that slows him down. Smarter politicians find a way to co-opt his message, as Richard Nixon did George Wallace’s (with a little help from Arthur Bremer’s bullets), and that slows him further. If you give Trump enough time, oh my friends in the press, all of your predictions will come true.

Read more: http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2015/0...z42wDmEmV9
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

InstaHeat 35K: FOGATTI Offers Upgraded RV Furnace Control

Updated Category News Views 343

Winter RV Trips Just Got Cozier There's nothing quite like hitting the open road in an RV during the winter months. But let's face it, nobody wants to return to a cabin that's as frigid as the great outdoors. Here's where FOGATTI steps up its game with the InstaHeat Ultra 35K RV Furnace. They’ve tinkered with the thermostat to iron out more precise control, just in time...

Continue Reading
Shenzhen's Vision Unveiled: APEC 2026 Promo Debut

Updated Category News Views 466

Shenzhen's Spotlight Moment at APEC 2026 When Shenzhen announced its promotional video for the 2026 APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting, it wasn't just about standard tourism glitz. This was a show of force, a bold step onto the main stage of global politics and economics. The video's launch wasn’t merely an audio-visual delight—it staked a claim in shaping the future...

Continue Reading
IDEAYA's IDE101: A New Front in Cancer Battle

Updated Category News Views 223

IDEAYA's Bold Move in Precision Medicine IDEAYA Biosciences, no stranger to the frontlines of cancer treatment, is gunning for a breakthrough with their latest pick, IDE101. They're jumping into the ring with a potential first-in-class inhibitor targeting CDKN2A-deficiency—a notorious player in the solid tumor game. They're not just mixing things up for the sake of it;...

Continue Reading
Ambrosia Biosciences Unveils Promising Nonclinical Metabolic Data

Updated Category News Views 335

Ambrosia's Latest Nonclinical Revelations Ambrosia Biosciences has just thrown out some major bait at ObesityWeek® 2026. The highlight? New nonclinical data profiles for two of their understudy small molecule programs—AMB-895 and AMB-131. It may sound niche, but in this sector, promising data spins heads. Their GLP-1 receptor agonist, AMB-895, and GIP receptor...

Continue Reading
Investors Gear Up for Lennar Class Action Lawsuit

Updated Category News Views 251

High Stakes and Hard Hits for Lennar Stockholders There’s rarely a dull moment in the world of Wall Street, and Lennar Corporation (NYSE: LEN) is proving that rule right now. As a whiff of scandal wafts through the air, the famed homebuilder and its bigwigs are staring down the barrel of a formidable class action lawsuit. The question is, just how deep do the alleged...

Continue Reading
Novo's CagriSema Trials Show Promising Weight Loss

Updated Category News Views 241

Decoding CagriSema's Promise Let me tell you, when those corporate folks from Novo Nordisk announce something big like their investigational drug CagriSema at ObesityWeek® 2026, it’s time to take notice. This isn’t just your average press release about some new weight loss fad. We’re talking about a phase 3 REDEFINE 1 trial that opens up a treasure chest of data...

Continue Reading
WHO and RCSI Bahrain Join Forces on Health Initiatives

Updated Category News Views 416

Forging a Healthier Pathway In a world where healthcare challenges rise faster than my blood pressure during a stock market crash, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the Royal College of Surgeons in Ireland (RCSI) – Medical University of Bahrain have inked a deal to tackle these issues head-on. The memorandum of understanding (MoU) signed on November 15, 2026,...

Continue Reading
Employment Law Suit Hits ABC: Alleged Wage Violations

Updated Category News Views 129

ABC Under Fire for Labor Code Violations You know it's a rocky road when a company like American Broadcasting Companies, Inc. lands itself in hot water with accusations riding high on labor law violations. People yapping about lunch breaks? Well, that’s the ball game here. Meal and Rest Break Controversies According to a recent lawsuit filed by Blumenthal Nordrehaug...

Continue Reading
Beef 'O' Brady's Expands Into Tuscaloosa Market

Updated Category News Views 246

A New Player in Town: Beef 'O' Brady's Lands in Tuscaloosa Listen up, sports fans and pub grub lovers of Tuscaloosa! Beef 'O' Brady's just kicked down the doors and expanded its reach, opening a location smack on McFarland Boulevard. The place threw open its doors on October 26 and is set to make waves in the local scene, driven by the dedicated hands of Mitul Patel and...

Continue Reading
Princess Cruises Launches New Era at Celebration Key

Updated Category News Views 185

Never thought I'd see the day when a cruise ship docking would stir such excitement, but here we are. The Star Princess has made its grand debut at Celebration Key, the latest jewel in Princess Cruises' crown. And they're going all out with Bahamian flair—something about a Junkanoo band and beach art that would make even the crustiest sailor crack a smile. Inaugural Fun...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Albion KAY VCT PLC's Strong Half-Year Performance Review

Updated Category News Views 95

Overview of Albion KAY VCT PLC Albion KAY VCT PLC plays a critical role in the investment landscape. The Company has recently published its Half-yearly Financial Report, which has garnered significant interest from both shareholders and potential investors. This report provides an in-depth look at the Company’s operations and financial condition over the six months...

Continue Reading
BlackRock Inc. Acknowledges Significant Stake in Syensqo

Updated Category News Views 160

Participation Notification by BlackRock Inc. In a recent communication, BlackRock Inc. has informed Syensqo of their increase in voting rights ownership, surpassing the critical threshold of 3%. This change is attributed to recent acquisitions or disposals of voting securities, which is in line with European transparency regulations. Details of the Notification The...

Continue Reading
Black Kite Unveils Innovative Global AI Risk Assessment Nexus

Updated Category News Views 204

Black Kite Launches Groundbreaking AI Assessment Framework Black Kite's GA³™ framework addresses a significant void in current global assurance frameworks. It creates a comprehensive standard that adapts to the ever-changing AI threat landscape. Importance of AI Risk Management Frameworks As cyber threats evolve, organizations face challenges in third-party risk...

Continue Reading
Purdue University Leads All-Boilermaker Mission with Virgin Galactic

Updated Category News Views 255

Purdue University Embarks on a Landmark Space Mission Building upon its rich legacy in space exploration, Purdue University is poised to undertake a remarkable journey — an all-Boilermaker crew will participate in a Virgin Galactic suborbital spaceflight known as Purdue 1. Set to launch in the near future, this mission opens up new avenues for academic exploration in...

Continue Reading
LP Building Solutions Provides Update on Q3 2024 Earnings Call

Updated Category News Views 77

LP Building Solutions Reveals Q3 2024 Earnings Call Details LP Building Solutions (NYSE: LPX), a prominent player in the building materials sector, has officially announced the schedule for its earnings conference call, set for an upcoming Tuesday. This anticipated event will highlight the financial results for the third quarter of 2024. Important Conference Call...

Continue Reading