$1.5-Billion False Advertising Trial Against Corn Refiners

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
$1.5-Billion False Advertising Trial Against Corn Refiners Association Begins in Los Angeles Federal Court

LOS ANGELES, Nov. 02, 2015 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- After several years of hearings, a federal jury trial is set to begin tomorrow in the $1.5 billion false advertising case brought by sugar growers against the Corn Refiners Association (CRA) and their members, Archer Daniels Midland Company (NYSE: ADM ), Cargill Inc, Tate & Lyle (LON:TATE), Ingredion Inc (NYSE: INGR ) and others. 

“This lawsuit is about false advertising, pure and simple. This case may change the way food is made in America. The lawsuit aims to stop the corn processors' false advertising so that families know the truth about the food they buy,” said Mark Lanier, lead attorney for the sugar growers. “The lawsuit alleges that the CRA engaged in a blatantly false campaign to promote high-fructose corn syrup (HFCS) as “corn sugar,” while describing it as “natural” and “nutritionally the same as sugar.”

“At the center of the lawsuit is the $130-million “Sweet Surprise” print, online and television advertising campaign by the CRA, which falsely touted HFCS as natural and equivalent to sugar.  During the trial, the jury will be able to assess critical evidence about HFCS and the conduct of its marketers. While reviewing more than 700,000 pages of confidential documents during discovery, it was revealed that some of the defendants tried to conceal information from the public about HFCS and debated the wisdom of making the “natural” case to consumers,” said Lanier. We will show the jury that they were sneaky and dishonest and secretly colluded with the CRA and urged them to seek a name change for HFCS to corn sugar, which the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) ultimately rejected.” 

“We intend to prove to a jury that the defendants’ claims that HFCS is a ‘natural’ product equivalent to real sugar are knowingly false. In fact, the evidence will show that there are signed affidavits attesting to an exactly opposite conclusion.  In 1997, as part of an effort to expand the production and consumption of HFCS in Mexico, the defendants claimed that production of HFCS would not conflict with the Mexican sugar production. In fact, the defendants submitted documents to the Mexican government declaring that HFCS is not natural but is, instead, a fabricated product requiring advanced technology. Indeed, they declared that HFCS is derived from cornstarch that has been subjected to two molecular level transformations. In a supporting affidavit, the defendants told the Mexican government ‘HFCS is a unique food ingredient that is the result of extensive scientific research and development,’ ” stated Lanier.

 “Among other things, the 2008 CRA ad campaign told consumers that ‘sugar is sugar’ and that ‘your body cannot tell the difference between sugar and high-fructose corn syrup.’  The misleading ad campaign caused price erosion and lost profits stemming from the artificially reduced demand for sugar caused by defendants’ false and misleading Sweet Surprise campaign. The sugar farmers brought this lawsuit when it became clear that efforts were underway to steal the good will of the “sugar” brand that has been safely used by our families for centuries," concluded Lanier. 

Case Background

The trial that will be heard in front of U.S. District Court Judge Consuelo Marshall has far-reaching implications for the food industry and American consumers.  The sugar industry’s lawsuit is primarily based on Section 43 of the 1946 Lanham Act, which prohibits false or misleading advertising. The underlying lawsuit, Western Sugar Cooperative v. Archer-Daniels-Midland, Co ., was filed in April 2011 by a group of sugar farmers to stop the corn processors’ advertising. In May 2012, the Food and Drug Administration rejected a petition by the CRA to change the common name for HFCS to “corn sugar”  saying that corn sugar is a term used for dextrose for more than 30 years.  

The FDA stated that “the use of the term ‘sugar’ to describe HFCS, a product that is a syrup, would not accurately identify or describe the basic nature of the food or its characterizing properties.”  The FDA also said the name change could “pose a public health concern” to persons with fructose intolerance or malabsorption. The sugar companies complaint states, “Defendants’ resort to such literally false and misleading statements harms consumers, harms the farmers and makers of real sugar (sucrose), and harms any dialogue based on the truth.”  

Judge Marshall ruled on an earlier motion that the sugar farmers have presented evidence demonstrating “a reasonable probability of success on their argument that the statements (made by the corn processors) are false.”

Broadcast Quality Video

Video downloadable at: http://bit.ly/1XzQAYJ

  • Two sound bites from lead attorney Mark Lanier framing his opening trial arguments
  • B-roll of Los Angeles Federal Court exteriors
  • B-roll of shoppers reading package labels
  • B-roll of soda can vending machines 
  • B-roll of tight shots of various soda cans showing they contain high fructose corn syrup or other artificial sweeteners but none contain actual sugar 

Additional Video

Video downloadable at: http://bit.ly/1HfDlpd

  • Sound bite from the controversial HFCS TV ad campaign
  • Sugar farmer
  • HFCS
  • Consumer talking about the case

 

Contacts: Eric Rose 805-624-9572 eric@ekapr.com Dan Blackburn 323-665-6571 danielmb6@gmail.com Johnny Cargill 713-659-5200 Johnny.Cargill@LanierLawFirm.com

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Thunes Boosts Bhutan Remittances with Instant Payments

Updated Category News Views 216

Thunes' Network Expands to Bhutan: A Game Changer I'll say one thing clear—Thunes isn't messing around. They've just opened the gates for real-time payouts to Bhutan, and it's going to be a game-changer for those living abroad who want to send money back home. Look, for years, Non-Resident Bhutanese have been diving into hoops just to get their bucks across borders....

Continue Reading
Akeso's Gumokimab Wins NMPA Approval for AS Treatment

Updated Category News Views 25

Gumokimab Approved: A New Dawn in AS Treatment Yeah, the biotech world shifts gears today as Akeso's gumokimab received the green light from China's National Medical Products Administration (NMPA). This approval for treating ankylosing spondylitis, or AS, isn't just another checkbox for Akeso; it's a game-changer in tackling this chronic inflammatory disease. Why should...

Continue Reading
Portillo's Faces Class Action: Investor Losses at Stake

Updated Category News Views 328

Investor Tensions Rise as Portillo's Inc. Lawsuit Unfolds Investment ain't all sunshine and rainbows, and if you've been holding Portillo's Inc. (NASDAQ: PTLO) stocks between September 19, 2023, and May 4, 2026, you might find yourself caught in a storm front. We're talking shareholder class action lawsuit, folks, thanks to some allegedly misguided management moves. This...

Continue Reading
Viking Ventures: Impacts of VK2735 on Obesity Examined

Updated Category News Views 292

Viking Therapeutics Reveal Surprising Data on VK2735 The latest from Viking Therapeutics' camp is giving obesity some serious food for thought, with new data making waves at the ObesityWeek® 2026 meeting. Their investigational dual agonist, VK2735, seems to be shaking things up, as early phase clinical data shows an impressive 74% of participants managed to improve at...

Continue Reading
Hanwha Power Seals Second FSRU Conversion Deal

Updated Category News Views 106

Riding the FSRU Wave with Hanwha Power Alright, we've got Hanwha Power step-dancing onto the LNG stage with its second splash into the FSRU (Floating Storage and Regasification Unit) conversion gig. Partnering up with Energos Infrastructure, these guys are making serious waves in the energy market by transforming what's pretty much a regular ship into a floating gas...

Continue Reading
Local Voices to Shape Mekong's Story in New Alliance

Updated Category News Views 231

Unpacking the New Storytelling Strategy Right off the bat, let's make it clear—this isn't just another run-of-the-mill environmental project announcement. When the National Geographic Society teams up with ThaiBev to empower Southeast Asian storytellers, they're not just waving around the usual conservation banner. Instead, they're betting on local voices to lead the...

Continue Reading
Guangdong's APEC Trade: Deep Ties, Big Stakes

Updated Category News Views 138

A New Chapter in Guangdong's Economic Story Swing by the bustling streets of Shenzhen, and you'll catch more than a whiff of change in the air. With China gearing up to host the APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting for the third time, Guangdong is under the magnifying glass. But it's not just the international attention landing on the province that’s worth the chatter —...

Continue Reading
Fapon's MEDICA 2026 Bid: Game-Changer or Same Old?

Updated Category News Views 0

Fapon's Ambitious Pitch at MEDICA: A Real Deal? MEDICA 2026 sees Fapon stepping up, laden with flashy promises and hardened expertise. Set up in Düsseldorf, these folks are pushing their Local Manufacturing Solutions harder than a door-to-door vacuum seller. The main pitch? Bolstering local IVD production with their comprehensive tech transfer services. How many outfits...

Continue Reading
KINGRVER Boosts RV Comfort with New Water Heater Lineup

Updated Category News Views 349

An Upgrade for the Open Road In the land of RV living, comfort is king—or in this case, KINGRVER. Dropping affordable upgrades for water heaters into the world of RVs, KINGRVER's CT6 lineup is like a warm hug on a chilly campsite morning. Whether you've pulled up to a wooded retreat or parked under the vast desert sky, having dependable hot water shouldn't be a gamble....

Continue Reading
Net Zero Efforts to Cost Europe €60B Annually by 2050

Updated Category News Views 0

Hefty Prices Loom Over Net Zero Commitments Well, strap in for a wallet buster, folks. Europe's largest players are staring down the barrel of a colossal €60 billion annual bill to clean up their carbon mess by 2050. That's the ticker in Senken's latest report, 'Pace of Change 2026.' Talks like these remind me there's no such thing as a free lunch, especially when...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

GM Partners with Barclays to Enhance Credit Card Offerings

Updated Category News Views 71

General Motors and Barclays Sign a Strategic Partnership General Motors (NYSE: GM) and Barclays have recently announced a significant long-term partnership that focuses on credit card services. This strategic agreement reflects both companies' commitment to enhancing customer experience and providing innovative financial solutions. Benefits of the New Credit Card...

Continue Reading
Enbridge Inc. Declares 3% Increase in Quarterly Dividend

Updated Category News Views 126

Enbridge Inc. Increases Quarterly Dividend by 3% Enbridge Inc. (TSX: ENB) has made a significant announcement regarding its quarterly dividend. The company declared a quarterly dividend of $0.9425 per common share, signaling a 3% increase from previous rates. This notable hike reflects Enbridge's commitment to shareholder value and marks the thirtieth consecutive year of...

Continue Reading
Jefferies Advises Caution on Biotech-Related CRO Investments

Updated Category News Views 545

CROs Confront Challenges as Biotech Market Slows In a recent analysis, Jefferies is advising investors to rethink their investments in contract research organizations (CROs), particularly those focused on biotech and early-stage research. This caution comes as the demand in the biotech sector has noticeably declined. Financial Struggles Affects Companies Jefferies has...

Continue Reading
Remarkable Cost Savings with QUELIMMUNE for Pediatric AKI

Updated Category News Views 137

Significant Economic Impact of QUELIMMUNE Therapy SeaStar Medical Holding Corporation (Nasdaq: ICU), a pioneering healthcare company, has recently published a health economic analysis that underscores the substantial financial benefits of its QUELIMMUNE therapy for pediatric patients suffering from Acute Kidney Injury (AKI). The analysis highlights an estimated average...

Continue Reading
SKF Invites Fans to Revitalize Tattoos with Brand Update

Updated Category News Views 228

SKF Invites Fans to Revitalize Tattoos with Brand Update SKF has taken an impactful step to modernize its brand identity, showcasing a fresh and dynamic look aimed at connecting with its audience more effectively. This update marks the company's first significant change to its logo since its inception in 1908, highlighting the dedication to innovation while respecting its...

Continue Reading