Todays WSJ: The FCC Imposes Netflix’s Broadband

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (4) Message Board
SilentPartner
Todays WSJ:

The FCC Imposes Netflix’s Broadband Policy
And the winner is Big Cable, not consumers seeking faster Internet speeds.
ENLARGE
PHOTO: GETTY IMAGES

By HOLMAN W. JENKINS, JR.
Sept. 1, 2015 7:24 p.m. ET
24 COMMENTS
TV stocks had a cow a few weeks ago when Disney’s CEO announced that ESPN was losing subscribers due to cord-cutting. Surely if ESPN was threatened the jig was up. Live sports were supposed to be the salvation of the existing TV bundle.

For one reason, though, the market’s fear may be exaggerated. A great deal more bandwidth will be needed, and where it will come from isn’t clear. An otherwise inauspicious Obama economy has delivered a better-than-doubling of average wired Internet speeds in America. But as disparate voices pointed out in a late July House subcommittee hearing, what paid for a lot of this bandwidth was the old cable bundle.

The big four cable incumbents, led by Comcast and Time Warner Cable, still earn princely returns on their past investments. But that hasn’t been true of telecom “overbuilders” (who invade cable’s turf) like AT&T and Verizon, and it will get harder for all as profits disappear from the TV half of the equation.

Google, for a supposed disrupter, bringing one-gigabit fiber as harbinger of our unlimited bandwidth future, has talked a lot lately about the importance of old-fashioned TV to drive the take-up of its vaunted Google Fiber service. Customers just aren’t interested in superfast broadband unless it comes with a cable-like television bundle, which Google has to supply at a loss.

As analyst Craig Moffett of the firm MoffettNathanson explained to Congress, “video will become unprofitable and broadband will be left to carry the entire burden of incremental deployment.”

Which brings us to Netflix. More than one-third of today’s expensively rolled-out bandwidth already is consumed in peak hours by a single company, whose customers represent a tiny minority—about 1.2%—of Internet users. Richard Bennett of High Tech Forum calculates: “If 12 percent of the Internet user population is streaming at prime time, the traffic load goes up to 340% of today’s level; and if it rises to 60%, the load goes up to 1700%.” And suppose users want super-high resolution 4k TV, which requires four times as much bandwidth as today’s hi-def?

Make no mistake: The bandwidth used by Netflix is paid for. But it’s paid for inefficiently, by spreading the cost over all broadband subscribers. In the airline industry, if backpackers and grannies had to pay for the frequent connections, last-minute seat availability and other features demanded by business travelers, there would be fewer planes, fewer flights, less connectivity, less travel for everyone—which is a fair model of the future that utility regulation will now create for broadband users.

Unfortunately the entire confused and inane thrust of federal Internet policy lately has been to sustain the Netflix distortion. Even collecting token amounts, as Comcast did, for expanding direct peering to receive the Netflix deluge apparently now will be verboten. And forget about the elegant fix of usage-based pricing, i.e., charging each customer according to his demand on the infrastructure. It’s clearly a nonstarter with regulators and activists.

For whatever bizarre and unthinking reason, the Federal Communications Commission under Tom Wheeler has decided its measure of success will be consumer uptake of over-the-top TV—which, to be sure, would be slowed if its true economic cost were borne by users.

So what does this mean? The oomph behind a regulated Internet isn’t coming from the net-neutrality philosophes. It’s coming from Netflix and its attachment to a particular pricing model for broadband. Indeed, Netflix CEO Reed Hastings said during an earnings call in April that his ideal is a single regulated monopolist serving each home. He’s going to get his wish—and it will be cable.

By the way, we are not stating a Netflix conspiracy theory. Netflix itself probably is bemused and still trying to make sense of how the politics have been developing. But the fact is, regulators are trying like crazy to make the necessary broadband seem like a free lunch to Netflix customers—a short-termism that necessarily undermines the incentive of others to compete with cable’s already-paid-for infrastructure.

And it’s happening: It can be seen in the slow fading of the telco broadband challenge from Verizon and AT&T, those profitless “overbuilders.” It can be seen in the decline of satellite television. It can be seen in cable’s considerable success in reducing “churn” as consumers increasingly find no near-substitute for cable broadband.

No wonder MoffettNathanson and Wells Fargo’s Marci Ryvicker both recently came out with unexpected “buys” on the top cable incumbents despite unbundling pressures.

The cable guys resisted Obama regulation because that’s what cable guys do, but they can be expected to make their peace with a Netflix-FCC agenda that reinforces their incumbency. Meanwhile, in a year or two, expect to notice that the broadband speed increases aren’t coming quite as reliably as they once did.

Nanotech Entertainment Inc. (NTEK) Stock Research Links

NTEK Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Bank Hapoalim's Q3 2026: Steady Growth Amid Challenges

Updated Category News Views 0

Digging Deep into Hapoalim's Recent Results Now ain't this a turn of events? Bank Hapoalim rolls out its numbers for Q3 2026, and while there's no confetti dropping from the ceiling, the numbers are telling their own story. Net profit comes to a solid NIS 2,364 million, but we're looking at a landscape that's not all rose-tinted today. The bank's managed to pull off...

Continue Reading
Pony.ai & Toyota Launch 1,000 Gen-7 Robotaxis in China

Updated Category News Views 110

Revving Up the Autonomous Ride Revolution Not every day you see two giants, Pony.ai and Toyota, join forces to shake up the way folks get from A to B. But here we are — they’ve fired up their engines in Guangzhou, unleashing their Gen-7 bZ4X Robotaxis for commercial use. And let me tell you, this is no shot in the dark. With plans to dot about 1,000 of these...

Continue Reading
HONOR Leads in China, Eyes Middle East Market

Updated Category News Views 23

A Force to be Reckoned With Talk about making waves—HONOR's got the bragging rights now. Sitting pretty at the top among Android smartphone brands in China ain't no small feat. We're looking at a snazzy 12.04% market share for October 2026, all thanks to selling a cool 2.573 million units. The kicker? This ain't even their full potential. They're hustling hard in the...

Continue Reading
CVS Study: GLP-1 Drugs Effective But Costly

Updated Category News Views 258

Can GLP-1s Deliver Value at Their Current Price? Alright, folks, here's a real-world gut check from CVS Health. They crunched some numbers using Aetna's anonymized claims data, and the results are eye-opening. These GLP-1s are showing promising health outcomes—lower hospital visits, better clinical results, yada yada. But when it comes to savings, they ain't quite...

Continue Reading
Sulzer Rebuilds Petrocedeño Tower: A Milestone in Oil Revival

Updated Category News Views 102

Venezuela's Oil Infrastructure Gets a Crucial Boost No one said reviving a near-busted oil facility in Venezuela would be a walk in the park. But that's just what North American Blue Energy Partners (NABEP) is doing, handing the reins to Sulzer to rebuild a busted crude tower at the Petrocedeño upgrader. This ain't just another run-of-the-mill repair job; this is the...

Continue Reading
Net Zero Efforts to Cost Europe €60B Annually by 2050

Updated Category News Views 38

Hefty Prices Loom Over Net Zero Commitments Well, strap in for a wallet buster, folks. Europe's largest players are staring down the barrel of a colossal €60 billion annual bill to clean up their carbon mess by 2050. That's the ticker in Senken's latest report, 'Pace of Change 2026.' Talks like these remind me there's no such thing as a free lunch, especially when...

Continue Reading
Evotec’s $2.9M Grant Advances Drug Safety Tech

Updated Category News Views 63

Revitalizing Drug Development with Human Stem Cells Evotec's latest win—a crisp $2.9 million grant from the Gates Foundation—is like a shot of adrenaline for drug safety innovation. This isn't just another drop in the bucket; it's a solid boost toward improving how we screen potential drugs for fetal risks before they're tossed into the costly whirlpool of clinical...

Continue Reading
D-Wave Quantum Hit with Securities Fraud Lawsuit

Updated Category News Views 380

A Legal Quagmire for D-Wave Quantum Investors Securities fraud lawsuits are like light in a dark alley—you need them when the truth's been stashed out of sight, but they illuminate the dirty and damp parts of investment strategies nobody wants to talk about. Right now, D-Wave Quantum Inc. is smack dab in the middle of such litigious action. If you had the misfortune of...

Continue Reading
NestWorks' C500: Shaking Up CNC at Formnext 2026

Updated Category News Views 41

NestWorks C500: A Game Changer for Makers Folks, gather 'round, because NestWorks is turning heads with their C500 desktop CNC machine. As it lands firmly on TIME’s Best Inventions of 2026 list, this ain't just another gadget adorning a workshop—all eyes are on it at Formnext 2026. From November 17–20, Frankfurt is the stage where NestWorks plans to showcase how...

Continue Reading
Hanwha Power Seals Second FSRU Conversion Deal

Updated Category News Views 106

Riding the FSRU Wave with Hanwha Power Alright, we've got Hanwha Power step-dancing onto the LNG stage with its second splash into the FSRU (Floating Storage and Regasification Unit) conversion gig. Partnering up with Energos Infrastructure, these guys are making serious waves in the energy market by transforming what's pretty much a regular ship into a floating gas...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Investigation Into Guess?, Inc.: Are Fiduciary Duties at Risk?

Updated Category News Views 121

Introduction to the Investigation Recently, a significant issue has arisen concerning Guess?, Inc. (NYSE: GES) and its handling of a pending merger with Authentic Brands Group LLC. This acquisition deal, valued at $16.75 per share, has prompted a legal investigation to determine whether the company's board of directors and top executives may have breached their fiduciary...

Continue Reading
Count Down to Class Action: Important News for GO Investors

Updated Category News Views 281

Important Deadline for Grocery Outlet Holding Corp. Investors As the deadline for the class action lawsuit approaches for Grocery Outlet Holding Corp. (NASDAQ: GO), investors are urged to pay close attention. The law firm Kessler Topaz Meltzer & Check, LLP has announced that investors who purchased or acquired Grocery Outlet securities from November 7, 2023, to May 7,...

Continue Reading
Discover KLIMB Jr.: The Latest in Pet Training Innovation

Updated Category News Views 239

Introducing the KLIMB Jr. by Blue-9 Pet Products Blue-9 Pet Products has made a remarkable stride in pet care with the introduction of the KLIMB Jr., a compact and versatile training platform for dogs and cats. This innovative product serves as a perfect tool for pet owners aiming to enhance their pets’ training and daily enrichment activities. A Tailored Solution for...

Continue Reading
Elsevier, Lancet Awards Highlight Community Health Impact

Updated Category News Views 62

Pioneering Health Awards Make Waves Amidst our swirling universe of breakthroughs and challenges, three research teams just snagged the spotlight. Recognized by the Elsevier Foundation and The Lancet in their first-ever Evidence to Impact Awards. These folks aren't just scribbling in labs—they're rolling up their sleeves and getting those much-needed health solutions...

Continue Reading
k-ID's Kai SDK: Age-Adaptive Design Revolution

Updated Category News Views 139

New Horizons for Developers Today, if you're building an app, you're just as likely to be wrangling with legal regulations as you are writing code. That's where k-ID’s new SDK, Kai, comes into play—it's not just another tool in the shed, it’s the whole toolbox for dealing with age-specific app requirements everywhere. The Changing App Landscape Why does this matter?...

Continue Reading