Unfortunately, iHub won that lawsuit since the case with

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Sir_Francelote intelligentPMC #10185
Unfortunately, iHub won that lawsuit since the case with Mina Mar was dismissed with prejudice.

For the Record - Past Litigation Involving Investors Hub

Return to Summary

Investorshub.com, Inc., et al., vs. Mina Mar Group, Inc., et. al. (January 2011) (United States)

United States District Court, Northern District of Florida
Case No. 4:11-CV-00009-RH-WCS

Summary: This lawsuit was filed by iHub in United States Federal Court, requesting the court to grant iHub declaratory relief by invalidating a default judgment Mina Mar obtained in a Canadian court. iHub did not defend the Canadian lawsuit.

Outcome: Final Judgment in favor of iHub on 6/20/2011 in the first United States federal court judgment ever issued under The SPEECH Act. The U.S. District Court found that:

Canadian law does not provide as much protection of speech as the First Amendement, federal law, and Florida law; and
Canadian law does not provide the protections provided by the Communications Decency Act
Key excerpt from the judgment:

22. The Court hereby declares that the Foreign Defamation Judgment in the matter of Mina Mar Group, Inc., et al. v. Investorshub.com, et al., Court File No. CV-08-364413-0000, Ontario Superior Court of Justice, is not enforceable in the United States pursuant to the SPEECH Act, 28 U.S.C. §§ 4101-4105, and any orders entered in connection therewith are invalid and unenforceable in the United States.
Comments: iHub had previously sought a similar order in January, 2009, prior to enactment of both the Florida libel tourism law and the federal SPEECH Act. The U.S. Federal court declined to assume jurisdiction over the foreign parties and dismissed the case without prejudice - meaning the court did not rule on the merits of the case. It was scenarios such as this that prompted legislation of anti-libel tourism statutes in several states including Florida (July 2009), followed by the federal SPEECH Act (August 2010). After the enactment of these important laws, iHub was successful in having the Canadian judgment and all related orders declared unenforceable in the United States. The Mina Mar parties originally attempted to defend the action; after being presented with a draft Rule 11 motion which sought sanctions for the incorrect facts and false allegations contained their answer, they filed amended answers removing all of the false statements and all of their affirmative defenses. Subsequently, Mina Mar agreed to a Stipulated Judgment in favor of iHub, and waived enforcement of their default Canadian judgment worldwide and all Canadian proceedings were withdrawn.

In the Media

RCFP: SPEECH Act celebrates one year anniversary, as its influence spreads overseas
The SPEECH Act isn’t a huge change in the law because American courts traditionally avoid enforcing unconstitutional judgments, Wimmer said. It hasn’t sharply decreased the number of foreign suits, but it is starting to make plaintiffs in other countries realize that American courts won’t enforce decisions that are inconsistent with U.S. libel law, he said.

That’s the effect the SPEECH Act had in InvestorsHub.com v. Mina Mar, in the Northern District of Florida.

Mina Mar is a Canadian company that claimed statements on InvestorsHub’s online message board defamed it. Unlike in the United States, a Canadian plaintiff does not have to show that the defendant made the defamatory statement with actual malice.

Mina Mar won in Canada and filed suit in Florida to collect a $100,000 judgment. But, after InvestorsHub cited the SPEECH Act in its complaint for declaratory relief in January, Mina Mar quickly abandoned its efforts to get the money.

“The act is very powerful in its clarity because very shortly after we moved for declaratory relief, the defendant here pretty much conceded that it was going to lose,” said attorney Deanna Shullman, who represented InvestorsHub.

Even without the SPEECH Act, InvestorsHub likely would have won because Florida is one of the few states that offer statutory protection against libel tourism.

Letters Blogatory: Case of the Day: InvestorsHub.com v. Mina Mar Group
Media Insurance Blog - US SPEECH Act is bad news for libel tourism
Los Anageles Daily Journal - Libel Tourism trip gets cut short
In InvestorsHub.com, Inc. v. Mina Mar Group, Inc., 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 87566 (N.D. Fla. June 20, 2011), a Canadian company surrendered its claims in a stipulated final judgment, acknowledging that its Canadian defamation judgment against a U.S. company was not enforceable in Florida because Canadian law does not provide as much protection of speech as the First Amendment and Florida law.

Source:

Nanotech Entertainment Inc. (NTEK) Stock Research Links

NTEK Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

WYBOT's New Robots Push Hands-Free Pool Care in Lyon

Updated Category News Views 77

A pool robot climbing out of the water to dock itself is the sort of demo that makes people stop mid-aisle at a trade show. WYBOT brought precisely that kind of attention-grabber to Piscine Global Lyon 2026, running November 17–20 at Eurexpo Lyon. The company is showing a broader lineup, but the M3 Pro is plainly the headline act: WYBOT calls it the world's first...

Continue Reading
Sysco's Northern California Labor Deal Gets Bigger

Updated Category News Views 135

One hundred forty-four drivers may not rattle a giant food distributor by themselves, but labor agreements have a habit of growing legs. Sysco's Northern California and Nevada regional contract has added members from Teamsters Locals 386 and 431, bringing its coverage above 1,100 workers. For investors watching Sysco, this is less about one afternoon's headline and more...

Continue Reading
Cooperate Marketing Lands 318th on Deloitte Fast 500

Updated Category News Views 30

A 199% revenue jump over three years will get my attention before any shiny award logo does. Cooperate Marketing says it grew that much from 2022 through 2025, enough to place No. 318 on Deloitte's 2026 Technology Fast 500 list. For a privately held Chicago marketing-technology outfit, that is a legitimate operating milestone, not just another ribbon to pin on the company...

Continue Reading
Cold-Season Cleaning Advice Has a Practical Catch!

Updated Category News Views 53

Remote Controls Are Nobody’s First Suspect A television remote can make the rounds all evening and never see a cloth, which is precisely why Maid Brigade’s cold-and-flu-season reminder lands as common sense rather than revelation. The Scottsdale cleaning company is telling households to look past the usual kitchen counter and bathroom sink routine. Fair enough. People...

Continue Reading
Dimora's MegaSorb Review Sharpens Wound Care Choices

Updated Category News Views 105

Wound care is one of those corners of healthcare where flashy language runs into real-life consequences fast. Dimora Medical’s newly announced collaboration with podiatric physician Dr. Ebonie Vincent-Sleet brings a professional voice to its MegaSorb silicone foam dressing line, specifically a 4×4-inch product reviewed for its intended place in care. That is useful...

Continue Reading
Snowrise Targets the Blind Spots in CPG Sales Data

Updated Category News Views 163

A sales total can look healthy while the floorboards are quietly rotting underneath it. That is the uncomfortable CPG problem Snowrise is aiming at: brands know what moved last quarter, but often cannot identify which stores, channels, communities, or promotions actually created the result. Plenty of management teams still steer by topline revenue, net distribution gains,...

Continue Reading
Layne’s Jacksonville Debut Tests East Texas Expansion

Updated Category News Views 57

Jacksonville is not some flashy coastal launch, and that is precisely why this Layne’s Chicken Fingers opening matters. A new chicken tender shop at 1217 S. Jackson St. will not move public markets, because this is a franchise-growth story rather than a ticker story. But it does offer a clean look at whether Layne’s can turn its Texas roots into a durable multi-market...

Continue Reading
HiTHIUM's 8-Hour Storage Pitch Faces Real Grid Tests

Updated Category News Views 113

Eight hours of stored electricity is where the sales brochure meets the ugly parts of the grid. HiTHIUM arrived at RE+ 2026 in Las Vegas, held November 17 through 19, with a broad storage pitch: systems ranging from two to eight hours, lithium-ion and sodium-ion chemistry, plus the software and validation work needed to make a battery plant behave when the local grid gets...

Continue Reading
Dario’s Second Women’s Health Win Tests Expansion Case

Updated Category News Views 89

Midlife care just became the newest proving ground for DarioHealth’s sales pitch. The company says The Minnesota Star Tribune has expanded its existing relationship to include Dario Women™, a program for employees navigating perimenopause and menopause. Eligible employees are expected to gain access in January 2027. For NASDAQ:DRIO, this is not some grand revenue...

Continue Reading
Sungrow Puts Storage Safety and Deployment on Display

Updated Category News Views 75

Fire-test footage is not usually the thing that grabs a room in Las Vegas, but Sungrow made it the centerpiece at RE+ 2026 for a reason. Energy storage has no shortage of glossy promises; what it needs is proof that equipment can handle the ugly stuff. Sungrow used the show to pitch a broader North American lineup, yet the PowerTitan 3.0 battery system and its large-scale...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

2026 Childcare Salary Guide Shows Shifts in Employment Trends

Updated Category News Views 311

Wage Trends in Childcare: A New Era Unfolds The landscape of childcare in America is morphing before our eyes, driven by economic forces and a changing workforce. With Crunch Care releasing its 2026 Childcare Salary Guide, we’re finally getting a clear picture of where wages and demand are headed, and it’s anything but static. Charting the Course of Childcare Wages...

Continue Reading
Sapiens Set to Reveal Q1 2025 Financial Insights Soon

Updated Category News Views 179

Sapiens International Corporation Announces Q1 2025 Financial Results Sapiens International Corporation (NASDAQ: SPNS) operates as a leading provider of software solutions specifically designed for the insurance sector. The company is preparing to unveil its financial outcomes for the first quarter of 2025. This significant announcement is scheduled for a date in early...

Continue Reading
Innovative Mobility Facility Unveiled at Kaweah Health

Updated Category News Views 225

Maison Law Launches Innovative Mobility Training Facility The "Maison Law Mobility Training Course at Kaweah Health" is a groundbreaking initiative that significantly improves the rehab journey for patients. This unique facility, the first of its kind in the area, is aimed at providing essential resources that empower patients to overcome their rehabilitation challenges...

Continue Reading
Aarki Unveils Encore: Revolutionizing Mobile Marketing Growth

Updated Category News Views 195

Aarki Unveils Encore: Revolutionizing Mobile Marketing Growth Encore is a groundbreaking platform that unifies User Acquisition and Retargeting through advanced machine learning, catering to the needs of mobile marketers grappling with strict privacy norms. By enhancing performance on both iOS and Android, Encore leverages deep neural network optimization to foster...

Continue Reading
BiomX's BX211 Shows Efficacy in Treating Diabetic Foot Issues

Updated Category News Views 235

Promising Phase 2 Trial Results for BX211 BiomX Inc. (NYSE American: PHGE), a pioneering clinical-stage company, recently revealed impressive topline results from its Phase 2 trial examining BX211 for diabetic foot osteomyelitis (DFO). This trial focused on individuals suffering from infections linked to Staphylococcus aureus, a bacteria known to complicate diabetic...

Continue Reading