Can you imagine? Some folks insist this does not happen!

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
AlanC AlanC #4977
Can you imagine? Some folks insist this does not happen! lol

Third Circuit Sends 'Naked' Short Sale Case to State Court


By Charles Toutant Published: Nov 11, 2014


The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit has remanded to New Jersey state court a suit claiming Merrill Lynch, UBS Securities, E Trade Capital Markets and other financial institutions conspired to conduct abusive “naked” short sales of the stock of Escala Group Inc.

The appeals court found no federal jurisdiction over the plaintiffs’ state-law claims, which allege that the defendants manipulated the stock price. Although the short sales at issue in the case are subject to federal scrutiny under Regulation SHO, which has no analogous provision under New Jersey law, the question of whether the defendants’ acts violate New Jersey law need not be answered by reference to Regulation SHO, the appeals court said.

A group of individuals and business entities filed the suit in Morris County Superior Court, and Merrill Lynch removed it to federal court in Newark on federal question jurisdiction. When the plaintiffs moved to remand the case to state court, U.S. Magistrate Judge Michael Hammer recommended the motion be granted in December 2012. But U.S. District Judge Jose Linares overruled Hammer in March 2013 and denied the plaintiffs’ motion to remand.

On Nov. 10, Third Circuit Judges D. Brooks Smith, Thomas Vanaskie and Dolores Sloviter reversed Linares’ ruling and instructed that the case be remanded to the Superior Court of New Jersey.

The ruling is precedential because it marks the first time any federal appeals court has ruled on the interplay between state causes of action and federal claims rising out of a racketeering suit, according to Neil Flaster, the Florham Park, N.J., solo representing the plaintiffs.

The suit was brought by Greg Manning of Boonton, N.J., and Claes Arnrup of Sweden, as well as four holding companies. All held stock in Escala Group at the time of the alleged naked short selling in 2006 and 2007. Escala Group changed its name to Spectrum Group International in 2009. Located in Irvine, Calif., the company is a dealer and auctioneer of stamps, coins, military memorabilia and other collectibles.

Besides Merrill Lynch, UBS and E Trade, the suit names Knight Capital Americas, National Financial Services and Citadel Derivatives Group as defendants. The suit claims the defendants falsified documentation of trades and loans of Escala shares while conducting transactions on their own behalf and for others.

The suit claims the defendants’ actions caused an artificial increase in the number of shares in Escala by “manufacturing fictitious and unauthorized phantom shares,” which caused the value of the plaintiffs’ holdings to decline and diluted their voting rights. The suit brought claims under the New Jersey Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act based on predicate acts of New Jersey securities fraud and theft, and common-law claims for unjust enrichment, interference with economic advantage and contractual relations, breach of contract, breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing, and negligence.

The suit says that when the naked short sales began in March 2006, the price of Escala stock fell from $32 to $4 in the course of five days.

Smith wrote for the appeals court that in a typical short sale, the seller identifies a stock that is expected to drop in price; arranges to borrow shares of the stock from a broker; sells the borrowed securities; waits for the stock to decrease in value; purchases replacement securities; and returns them to the broker.

Typically, Smith wrote, a short sale is completed within three days, but in a “naked” short sale, the buyer fails to deliver securities to the buyer within the standard three-day settlement period, as part of a scheme to manipulate the price of a stock.

Naked short selling is not per se illegal under federal law, but some naked short selling schemes may violate federal antitrust laws, as well as Regulation SHO, he said.

The defendants argued that federal jurisdiction was conferred by 28 U.S.C. 1331 and by Section 27 of the Exchange Act. In support of their Sec. 1331 claim, the defendants cited D’Alessio v. New York Stock Exchange. In that 2001 case, the Second Circuit found federal jurisdiction under Sec. 1331 where a court was required to construe federal securities laws because the plaintiff claimed the New York Stock Exchange failed to perform its statutory duty, created under federal law, to enforce members’ compliance with those laws. But the present case “is distinguishable because plaintiffs’ claims could rise or fall entirely based on the construction of state law,” the panel said.

The panel also rejected the defendants’ claim of federal jurisdiction under Section 27, which relied on a line of cases from the Ninth Circuit. Those cases are at odds with the Supreme Court’s 1961 decision in Pam American Petroleum Corp. v. Superior Court of Delaware, the panel said.

Plaintiff lawyer Flaster said he was pleased with the decision, since his clients would have been held to a higher standard on a defense motion to dismiss in federal court.

A Merrill Lynch spokesman, Bill Halldin, said the company had no comment about the ruling. Lawyers for the other defendants either did not return calls from a reporter or had no comment. Sophie Sohn, a spokeswoman for KCG, a successor by merger to Knight Capital, said her company had no comment.


http://www.law.com/sites/articles/2014/11/11/...tate-court

Telvue Corp (TEVE) Stock Research Links

TEVE Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Cinmoore's Smart Camera: A Game Changer for Car Security

Updated Category News Views 96

Pioneering Car Security with Cinmoore's Smart Camera Ever left your car in the parking lot, heart pounding, wondering if it's safe while you run errands? Well, Cinmoore might just quell that parking paranoia with their new gizmo, the Smart Parking Camera DC1U. This device isn't just some fancily-packaged disappointment—it promises some serious peace of mind for those...

Continue Reading
A Teen's Opera Encounter Inspires Decades of Passion

Updated Category News Views 94

Unraveling a Lifelong Opera Obsession Back in the dog-eared days of 1970, a teenager waltzed into the Metropolitan Opera and stumbled onto a passion that'd pulse alongside him for over half a century. Now, David E. Lapin rolls out his personal chronicle, 'A Sound Obsession: Fifty-Five Years of Opera at the Met.' Folks, we’re diving into a cultural tapestry that’s...

Continue Reading
Shareholder Alert: Investigation Looms Over GDYN

Updated Category News Views 55

Grid Dynamics Under Legal Scrutiny There’s nothing quite like waking up to find your pick embroiled in an investigation. Grid Dynamics Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ: GDYN) is on the radar, with law firm Levi & Korsinsky diving headfirst into potential infractions of fiduciary duties by some of the company’s top brass. The Lowdown on the Investigation This whole circus was...

Continue Reading
WirelessCar Rebrands to Reinforce Connected Mobility Vision

Updated Category News Views 122

Evolving Identity for Changing Times Let’s dive right into it—WirelessCar, a name that’s struck chords in the automotive trenches for ages, is taking a bold step by unveiling a new brand identity. Now, don’t roll your eyes just yet. This isn’t another company tapping the rebranding siren for the heck of it. We’re talking about a company that’s been in the...

Continue Reading
Stark Future Amasses €150M, Revving Up Electric Bike Dominance

Updated Category News Views 142

Well, if you've been keeping your eye on electric vehicles, this is a story that might raise those eyebrows. Stark Future, a name perhaps not buzzing on every street just yet, has gone and done it—snagged over €150 million in fresh capital. Breaking Barriers with Record-breaking Numbers Stark Future didn't just make a ripple; they caused a tsunami. This buzzing...

Continue Reading
Surgical Tooth Extraction: When It’s Necessary

Updated Category News Views 98

Unpacking the Complexities of Tooth Extraction Ever wonder why some tooth extractions are a stroll in the park while others dive straight into surgical territory? It's all about positioning, condition, and what's lurking underneath. Thanks to Dr. Yadira Cardona-Rohena of Hamilton Mill Oral & Facial Surgery, we’ve got the lowdown. The Need for Skilled Surgical Techniques...

Continue Reading
Exploring Why Dead Outlets Stay Dead: Expert Insights

Updated Category News Views 86

The Mystery of Non-Responsive Outlets Ever found an electrical outlet refusing to cooperate when you need it most? Well, I know the frustration all too well. You'd think if the breaker ain't blown, the outlet should work like a charm. But dive into the guts of the story, and you find a series of surprises waiting to trip us up. Common Culprits: Tripped GFCIs and Loose...

Continue Reading
Teamsters Ratify Contract, Averting Waste Strike

Updated Category News Views 25

Big Win for Teamsters Local 350 You ever seen a strike averted by sheer willpower and unity? That’s what's happened here with the workers at South San Francisco Scavenger Company. These folks—drivers, mechanics, sorters, and utility workers—all banded together under the Teamsters Local 350 and showed management what's what by securing a contract they deserve. We're...

Continue Reading
Kinross Gold Fraud Lawsuit: What Shareholders Need to Know

Updated Category News Views 58

Kinross Gold's Legal Quagmire There's a fresh storm brewing for Kinross Gold Corporation (NYSE: KGC), and it ain't the kind investors enjoy riding. You see, the company is up to its neck in a class action lawsuit, courtesy of Schall, Brown & Schwartz LLP—a big-name shareholder rights litigation outfit. The gripe? Alleged securities fraud, violating §§10(b) and 20(a)...

Continue Reading
Palatin's Game-Changer: MC4R Agonist Hits the Stage

Updated Category News Views 73

Breaking New Ground in Obesity Treatment Palatin Technologies is stepping into the spotlight with some heavy ammunition in the fight against obesity. The company has just unveiled impressive preclinical data about their next-generation melanocortin-4 receptor (MC4R) agonists at the ObesityWeek® 2026 conference. This isn’t just your run-of-the-mill corporate...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Trump's Tariff Threats Spark Global Market Reactions

Updated Category News Views 163

Market Reactions to Tariff Developments As global markets navigate uncertain waters today, optimism and anxiety intertwine. The US dollar has taken a slight step higher, while gold has seen a dip, all stemming from ongoing trade tensions and recent tariff announcements by President Trump. With negotiations that are seen as promising but fraught with complexities, the...

Continue Reading
Sutro Biopharma's Upcoming Presentation at J.P. Morgan Event

Updated Category News Views 228

Sutro Biopharma's Upcoming Conference Presentation Sutro Biopharma, Inc. (NASDAQ: STRO), a trailblazer in oncology therapies based in South San Francisco, has some exciting news. The company announced that its Chief Executive Officer, Bill Newell, will be presenting at the prestigious J.P. Morgan Healthcare Conference. This annual event is a pivotal opportunity for...

Continue Reading
Nightly Launches Ambitious $25 Million Experience Initiative

Updated Category News Views 302

Nightly Introduces a $25 Million Initiative In a bold move to reshape the live entertainment landscape, Nightly has announced a substantial $25 million initiative aimed at expanding its dynamic experiences across the nation. Originating from Dallas, Nightly has quickly evolved into a cultural movement that seeks to redefine nightlife specifically for Gen Z audiences. This...

Continue Reading
Tecan Announces 2024 Results, Focuses on Growth and Innovation

Updated Category News Views 609

Tecan Reports 2024 Financial Results Amid Market Challenges Overview of Financial Highlights Tecan has unveiled its financial results for 2024, showcasing a robust commitment to enhancing operational resilience in a challenging market environment. Sales figures totaled CHF 934.3 million, marking a decline from the previous year's CHF 1,074.4 million. This 13.0% drop in...

Continue Reading
Auddia, Inc. (AUUD) Merger: Shareholder Alert and Investigation Insights

Updated Category News Views 227

Auddia, Inc. (NASDAQ: AUUD) is under the microscope after news broke about its proposed merger with McCarthy Finney, Inc., which sent shockwaves through trader desks and shareholder circles alike. The date was February 18, 2026, when class action attorney Juan Monteverde announced an investigation into the deal that’s left many scratching their heads about whether this...

Continue Reading