Comments to EPA: Nuclear Energy Essential for Carbon

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
Comments to EPA: Nuclear Energy Essential for Carbon Compliance

WASHINGTON, Dec. 1, 2014 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's treatment of nuclear energy in its proposed carbon reduction regulations is fundamentally flawed and must be reworked, the Nuclear Energy Institute said in comments filed today with the agency.

The EPA has proposed new regulations under section 111(d) of the Clean Air Act to reduce carbon emissions from existing power plants. Nuclear energy produces about two-thirds of all carbon-free electricity in America—three times more than hydropower and nearly five times more than wind energy—and will be even more important to preserve a balanced energy portfolio that reliably produces electricity with a lower carbon footprint.

EPA's proposed rule (the Clean Power Plan ) recognizes the importance of nuclear energy in reducing electric sector carbon emissions and attempts to create an incentive for states to preserve existing nuclear generating capacity. As proposed, however, the rule does not achieve that objective. In addition, the proposed rule creates a significant, inappropriate and inequitable penalty for Georgia, South Carolina and Tennessee, where new reactors are being built.

"State government officials, policymakers, the industry and other stakeholders have told EPA that the nuclear energy-related provisions in the rule must be changed to maintain the benefits Americans receive from these large-scale, carbon-free facilities," said Marvin Fertel, president and chief executive officer at the Nuclear Energy Institute. "The agency must revise its proposal to ensure that states have a sufficient incentive to preserve existing nuclear power plants and to build the new nuclear energy facilities that will be required to achieve meaningful carbon reductions and meet the administration's goal."

EPA's proposed rule incorporates six percent of existing nuclear generating capacity when calculating states' target emission rates. This percentage is based on a U.S. Energy Information Administration forecast that six percent of U.S. nuclear capacity is at risk of premature shutdown. But there is no logical basis to assume that six percent of the nuclear capacity in every state with nuclear power plants is at risk. In fact, the at-risk capacity could be higher in states with competitive electricity markets.

Nuclear plants under construction in Tennessee (Watts Bar 2), Georgia (Vogtle 3-4) and South Carolina (Summer 2-3) will not begin producing electricity until between 2015-2018, yet EPA treats them in the proposed rule as though they are already operating at 90 percent capacity. There is no logical basis to include output from these plants in EPA's rate-setting formula.

Adding potential electricity output from these facilities in the agency's rate-setting formula reduces the state's carbon intensity target, thereby penalizing progressive states that are supporting nuclear plant construction. Although states would be able to receive credit for new nuclear plants—by counting the output from them in their compliance calculations—that credit is effectively nullified by including that output in the rate-setting formula.

For example, South Carolina's carbon intensity target is 22 percent more stringent than it otherwise would be because of EPA's treatment of two reactors under construction at the Summer facility near Columbia, S.C. This is a substantial and unjustified penalty levied on the states for no legitimate purpose. "There is only one justifiable approach to new nuclear generating capacity under construction: Remove it entirely from the target-setting calculation but credit the carbon-free electricity output to compliance," NEI said in its comments.

NEI believes that all carbon-free electricity sources should receive appropriate credit in a carbon-reduction program. While renewable energy, nuclear energy and hydro power receive vastly different treatment in the proposed rule, nuclear energy does not receive appropriate credit.

In revising the rule, NEI recommends that EPA:

  • Replace the "six percent factor" in the proposed rule and consider asking states to demonstrate in their State Plans assurance that they will preserve existing carbon-free generating capacity, particularly nuclear generating capacity. For operating nuclear power plants in regulated states, such assurance already exists because integrated utilities have a reasonable opportunity to recover costs, plus a reasonable return. In competitive states with commercial reactors potentially at risk, this assurance could involve a commitment to policy changes through legislation or regulation, or other market-based mechanisms, or a combination that would create incentives for continued reactor operation.
  • EPA should consider ways to provide at least some compliance value for existing nuclear energy capacity as an additional incentive to states to preserve that capacity. For example, a state could be allowed compliance credit for carbon-free electricity produced above a historical average capacity factor for that state's reactors.
  • Remove nuclear generating capacity under construction from the rate-setting formula, and allow states to include "new" nuclear generating capacity, when it is operating, in their compliance calculations, thereby providing an incentive to expand carbon-free nuclear generating capacity. "New" nuclear capacity should include those plants currently under construction or others that might be built between now and 2030 and beyond; as well as all power uprates and license renewals approved after 2012 at existing nuclear energy facilities.

"Nuclear power plants are unique—and uniquely valuable—among carbon-free sources of electricity," Fertel said. "Policymakers and regulators must enact rules that place clear, unambiguous value on low-carbon baseload generation that meets our 24/7 demand for power. Americans need reliable electricity, and they want clean air. With nuclear energy, they can have both."

All mainstream analyses(1) of this issue show that reducing carbon emissions will require a portfolio of energy options, that nuclear energy must be part of the portfolio, and that major expansion of nuclear energy is essential over the next 10 to 15 years.

(1) International Energy Agency 2013 World Energy Outlook, Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Working Group III report, and Energy Information Administration and Environmental Protection Agency analyses of various legislative proposals.

The Nuclear Energy Institute is the nuclear energy industry's policy organization. This news release and additional information about nuclear energy are available at www.nei.org .

Contact NEI's media relations staff at , 202.739.8000 during business hours or 703.644.8805 after hours and weekends.

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Fall Pest Risks Linger as Mild Weather Extends Threat

Updated Category News Views 104

A cold snap is not a magic off switch for mosquitoes, ticks, or rodents, and that is the sober point behind the National Pest Management Association's fall and winter 2026 Public Health Pest Index. The group is flagging conditions, not predicting that every household in a named city will face an infestation or illness. Still, mild temperatures, rain, flooding, and plenty...

Continue Reading
Commodity Rout Tests a Market Already Short on Nerve

Updated Category News Views 56

Some weeks the tape merely wobbles; this one started throwing furniture. By midday Wednesday, traders were staring at sharp declines in gold, silver, crude and copper while the major equity benchmarks remained underwater for the week. That is an unpleasant combination. When growth-sensitive commodities and the usual hard-asset hiding places are all getting sold,...

Continue Reading
CVRx Lawsuit Deadline Follows a Brutal 59.76% Plunge

Updated Category News Views 160

A 59.76% one-day wipeout has a way of stripping the varnish off every upbeat corporate story. For CVRx investors, the hard fact is that the shares fell $3.55 to close at $2.39 on August 7, 2026, after the company disclosed a U.S. Department of Justice civil investigative demand in its August 6 Form 10-Q. That kind of disclosure does not merely dent confidence; it forces...

Continue Reading
Hyster-Yale’s $135 Million Convert Carries Real Cost

Updated Category News Views 63

Forklift makers do not usually get to hide a 7.50% borrowing cost behind glossy financing jargon. Hyster-Yale has priced $135 million of convertible senior notes due in 2031, lifting the deal from the originally announced $125 million. There is also an option for initial purchasers to take another $20 million. For NYSE:HY shareholders, this is not a simple debt cleanup....

Continue Reading
Norfolk Southern's 200-Year Campaign Meets a Hard Market

Updated Category News Views 111

Two centuries of railroad history can stir the blood, but it does not move a single carload by itself. Norfolk Southern has opened its 200-year railroading celebration with the GeneratioNS campaign, a three-locomotive NS 200 commemorative series, and plans for public events across its network. For a railroad with deep roots and very modern operational pressures, this is...

Continue Reading
Why Lear’s PACE Award Matters Beyond Seat Warmers Today

Updated Category News Views 102

Seat foam and wiring seldom make investors sit upright, yet Lear has managed to turn that unglamorous corner of the vehicle into something worth watching. The company’s Modular Thermal Comfort Systems just won a 2026 Automotive News PACE Award, a respected supplier-industry nod for innovation and business performance. Awards alone do not pay anybody’s bills, and I...

Continue Reading
Common Tiger Bets $499 on Better Outdoor Seating Design

Updated Category News Views 59

A chair that refuses to slump into the camping aisle is Common Tiger's whole argument, and frankly it is a smarter argument than another flimsy fold-up contraption pretending comfort is optional. The Los Angeles, female-founded and women-owned brand is launching with one product, The Daymaker, after four years of development. That is a long runway for a debut chair, which...

Continue Reading
Breakthrough T1D Gala Puts Research Progress First

Updated Category News Views 49

One person living without insulin after a cell-therapy trial is the detail that cuts through all the ballroom polish tonight. Breakthrough T1D's 53rd Annual New York City Promise Gala lands at the Plaza Hotel during National Diabetes Awareness Month, and it carries a message worth handling carefully: research can produce extraordinary outcomes, but one participant's...

Continue Reading
Frosty Animatronics Put Nostalgia on Lowe's Shelves

Updated Category News Views 142

A moving corncob pipe is not anybody's idea of a macroeconomic signal, yet holiday aisles are built on precisely these little jolts of recognition. Gemmy has teamed with Warner Bros. Discovery Global Consumer Products to place a new animated Frosty the Snowman collection exclusively at Lowe's for the 2026 holiday season. It is cheerful retail business, not earthshaking...

Continue Reading
CHN Energy's Indonesia Record Deserves a Hard Look

Updated Category News Views 50

Twenty years of boots sinking into swamp mud tells a sturdier story than a polished anniversary slogan. CHN Energy says it entered Indonesia's energy market two decades ago and has since built an operating presence around reliable electricity, local training and community work. In a country scattered across thousands of islands, dependable power is not some decorative...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Great American Media to Broadcast 2025 National Christmas Tree Lighting

Updated Category News Views 281

Great American Media to Broadcast 2025 National Christmas Tree Lighting Great American Media is proud to announce that it will serve as the exclusive broadcast home of the 2025 National Christmas Tree Lighting, a cherished event that creates a beautiful sense of community across the nation. This unique celebration, themed "Christmas as It's Meant to Be," is an opportunity...

Continue Reading
Lucent Health Data Breach: Critical Steps for Affected Individuals

Updated Category News Views 241

Overview of the Lucent Health Data Breach In the wake of a significant data breach, many individuals are left uncertain about the status of their personal information. Lucent Health Solutions, a provider in the healthcare industry, faced a considerable security incident that compromised sensitive data, affecting numerous individuals. It is essential to understand the...

Continue Reading
BofA's Optimistic Forecast for Uber Stock Sets New Target

Updated Category News Views 186

BofA's Optimistic Forecast for Uber Stock Sets New Target BofA Securities has recently provided a positive outlook for Uber Inc. (NYSE: UBER), increasing its price target for the company’s stock from $88 to $96. With a Buy rating in place, analysts highlight the upcoming earnings report slated for release on October 31, anticipating results that could slightly exceed...

Continue Reading
Endries International Welcomes New CEO Dan Crociata

Updated Category News Views 420

Endries International Welcomes New CEO Dan Crociata Endries International Inc., a renowned name in the fastener and supply chain solutions industry, has made a significant transition in its leadership. Dan Crociata, who has played a vital role within the company as Chief Financial Officer, has been appointed the Chief Executive Officer. This change marks a new chapter in...

Continue Reading
CIWA's New Internship Initiative: Building Insurance Leaders

Updated Category News Views 142

CIWA Launches Internship Program The California Insurance Wholesalers Association (CIWA) has unveiled an exciting new initiative aimed at cultivating the next generation of insurance professionals. This Internship Program is crafted to provide college students with hands-on experience in the dynamic world of excess and surplus lines insurance. Purpose of the Internship...

Continue Reading