John Lewis will still win the battle of the Christmas ads,

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
John Lewis will still win the battle of the Christmas ads, says Oxford academic

OXFORD, Nov. 28, 2014 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- via PRWEB - Professor Nancy Puccinelli predicts that the £7m John Lewis ad featuring Monty the penguin will attract customers to stores and, particularly if the actual shopping experience matches the mood of the ad, encourage them to spend money. However, Boots, Sainsbury's, Tesco, and even Waitrose (owned by John Lewis) may struggle to attract more customers via their adverts or encourage them to spend more.

"The number of story-based advertisements this year suggests that many agencies have been eyeing previous John Lewis ads and trying to emulate them, but they haven't understood that it's not just about tugging at viewers' heartstrings," said Professor Nancy Puccinelli, Associate Professor in Consumer Marketing at Saïd Business School, University of Oxford. "Our research shows that a powerful element in communicating with consumers is getting the right fit between marketing messages and what's driving their decision-making, whether it's minimising risk or maximising pleasure."

In a recent research paper, Puccinelli and her co-authors explained that "Back to School" campaigns often implicitly address the fear that children might be starting school without the right kit. People who base their decision-making on minimising risk are particularly susceptible to this sort of messaging. But at Christmas it is more profitable to appeal to consumers with a "promotion mindset" – those who respond to images of indulgence, and who will be open to switching to premium brands and to spending more to get the most out of their purchasing.

"With this in mind, I think that the John Lewis ad, which doesn't really focus on specific products but does present an idealised, rather up-market picture of a family Christmas, will do very well," said Puccinelli. "The current Sainsbury's 1914 and Boots Boxing day ads are interesting because, while they both feature heart-warming stories, I don't think they tap into the idea of indulgence, which is what will get consumers spending more in their stores – obviously the main aim of these promotions. The Boots 2011 TV ad spoke more directly to their consumers to optimize pleasure. With this year's adverts, people will enjoy watching, but won't necessarily feel the urge to buy much more than a chocolate bar, even if it is one in retro 1914 packaging."

Puccinelli also believes that the Tesco's ad, which centres on lighting up a large store car park, fails to create an indulgent feel.

She suggests that even the Waitrose ads could be improved upon. "The Waitrose ad contains a sweet story, but its message seems to be rather a utilitarian one, focusing on good customer service, or preventative one– worried about getting your Christmas baking wrong? Come to Waitrose and we'll help. More of a focus on the celebratory could help Waitrose convert our enjoyment of the advert into more sales."

According to Puccinelli's research, even small adjustments to marketing messages to improve the fit with consumers' prevailing states of mind can boost sales by up to 186%. Getting it wrong, such as emphasising cheapness (step forward Iceland) or price promotions when people are in the mood to spend money and buy the best, can even have a negative effect.

For further information or to speak with Professor Nancy Puccinelli, please contact the press office:

Kate Richards, PR Coordinator, Saïd Business School
Tel: +44 (0)1865 288879, Mob: +44 (0)7711000521
Email: kate.richards(at)sbs(dot)ox.ac.uk

Jonaid Jilani, Press Officer, Saïd Business School
Tel: +44 (0)1865 614678, Mob: +44 (0)786025996
Email: jonaid.jilani(at)sbs(dot)ox.ac.uk

Notes to Editors

1. About Nancy Puccinelli

http://www.sbs.ox.ac.uk/community/people/nancy-puccinelli

2. About Saïd Business School

Saïd Business School at the University of Oxford blends the best of new and old. We are a vibrant and innovative business school, but yet deeply embedded in an 800 year old world-class university. We create programmes and ideas that have global impact. We educate people for successful business careers, and as a community seek to tackle world-scale problems. We deliver cutting-edge programmes and ground-breaking research that transform individuals, organisations, business practice, and society. We seek to be a world-class business school community, embedded in a world-class University, tackling world-scale problems.

In the Financial Times European Business School ranking (Dec 2013) Saïd is ranked 12th. It is ranked 14th worldwide in the FT's combined ranking of Executive Education programmes (May 2014) and 23rd in the world in the FT ranking of MBA programmes (Jan 2014). The MBA is ranked 7th in Businessweek's full time MBA ranking outside the USA (Nov 2014) and is ranked 5th among the top non-US Business Schools by Forbes magazine (Sep 2013). The Executive MBA is ranked 21st worldwide in the FT's ranking of EMBAs (Oct 2014). The Oxford MSc in Financial Economics is ranked 7th in the world in the FT ranking of Masters in Finance programmes (Jun 2014). In the UK university league tables it is ranked first of all UK universities for undergraduate business and management in The Guardian (Jun 2014) and has ranked first in ten of the last eleven years in The Times (Sept 2014). For more information, see http://www.sbs.ox.ac.uk/

This article was originally distributed on PRWeb. For the original version including any supplementary images or video, visit http://uk.prweb.com/releases/2014/11/prweb12359815.htm

University of Oxford Josie Powell +44 1865288403

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Tronox Pushes Back on Creditor Restructuring Chatter Firmly

Updated Category News Views 115

A Creditor Rumor Is Not a Restructuring Plan Two creditor groups hiring law firms can make a stock chart look like it stepped on a rake, but it is not the same thing as a debt workout. That distinction is the whole point of Tronox Holdings' November 18 update. A November 17 Wall Street Journal report said two groups of creditors had retained firms described as...

Continue Reading
Schloss Johannisberg Leads 2026 Global Vineyard List

Updated Category News Views 106

A 1,200-year-old riesling estate just beat the world at being memorable. Schloss Johannisberg in Germany’s Rheingau has taken No. 1 in The 50 Best Vineyards 2026, moving up from No. 2 last year and also claiming Best Vineyard in Europe. For anyone watching the wine business from the outside, this is not really a story about one bottle edging out another. It is a...

Continue Reading
Frosty Animatronics Put Nostalgia on Lowe's Shelves

Updated Category News Views 127

A moving corncob pipe is not anybody's idea of a macroeconomic signal, yet holiday aisles are built on precisely these little jolts of recognition. Gemmy has teamed with Warner Bros. Discovery Global Consumer Products to place a new animated Frosty the Snowman collection exclusively at Lowe's for the 2026 holiday season. It is cheerful retail business, not earthshaking...

Continue Reading
BVM's Brookfield Headquarters Move Tests Growth Ambition

Updated Category News Views 119

A bigger office is rarely the exciting part of a growth story, yet it can reveal whether the machinery underneath is actually running hot. Best Version Media has moved its headquarters from Janacek Court to 15800 W. Bluemound Road, Suite 400, in Brookfield, Wisconsin, citing room for recent hires, future recruitment and closer collaboration across its print and digital...

Continue Reading
Roland DG's Brand Refresh Earns Three B2B Awards in 2026

Updated Category News Views 98

Three trophies for a printer-maker’s marketing overhaul will not move mountains by themselves, but they do tell us Roland DG has stopped treating its brand like an afterthought. The company’s global Make Your Mark refresh picked up two Silver awards and one Bronze at the 2026 Drum B2B Awards in Miami. For a business selling industrial-grade tools into crowded,...

Continue Reading
Trip.com Sets December 1 Date for Third-Quarter Results

Updated Category News Views 17

December’s first after-hours session will put Trip.com Group back under the market’s microscope, whether anybody is ready or not. The company says it will report results for the three months ended September 30, 2026 after the U.S. market closes on Tuesday, December 1. That is the whole hard-news payload for now: a reporting date, a call time, and no numbers to get...

Continue Reading
Tongwei's 846 MW Romania Deal Tests Solar Supply Scale

Updated Category News Views 5

Eight hundred forty-six megawatts of panels do not quietly roll out the factory gate. Tongwei’s supply agreement with Rezolv Energy for Romania’s Dama Solar project is a hefty piece of utility-scale solar business, and the first truckload has already left Tongwei’s Nantong facility. That matters more than another polished signing-ceremony photo: equipment is moving,...

Continue Reading
SHIFTAIon Puts Governance at Center of AI Migration

Updated Category News Views 69

Legacy code is where grand AI promises usually go to get mugged by reality. ACL Digital’s new SHIFTAIon platform is taking a sensible swing at that ugly problem: not merely generating code faster, but putting discovery, architecture decisions, testing, security checks, reviewer signoffs, and reporting into one controlled modernization process. That distinction matters....

Continue Reading
Banks Face a Choice: Retreat or Fund Climate Resilience

Updated Category News Views 26

A flooded field can turn a prudent loan book into a social retreat overnight. That is the uncomfortable nerve in the Global Alliance for Banking on Values paper unveiled at COP31 in Antalya on November 19, 2026. Banks have become very practiced at mapping physical climate exposure, raising prices, tightening standards and stepping away. Fine, risk discipline matters. But...

Continue Reading
Barcelona Housing Summit Puts Affordability on the Map

Updated Category News Views 12

A packed Barcelona hall cannot magically unjam a housing market, but it can force the grown-ups in the room to stare at the mess. Housing World Summit, known as HOWS Barcelona, closed its first edition with 1,530 attendees and a broad cast: city officials, governments, developers, investors, third-sector groups and academics. That mix matters because affordable housing is...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Understanding Share Buybacks and Voting Rights Dynamics

Updated Category News Views 130

Overview of Share Buybacks In recent financial news, Octopus AIM VCT plc has engaged in a strategic move by purchasing its own shares. This action is often a signal of confidence in the company's future and an investment in its own value. Details of the Transaction The company has recently announced the acquisition of 590,908 ordinary shares at a price of 47.27p each....

Continue Reading
Kojamo's Financial Report Highlights: Growth and Outlook

Updated Category News Views 186

Overview of Kojamo plc's Financial Performance Kojamo plc has recently published its financial report, highlighting significant changes and developments in their occupancy rates and revenues for the first half of the fiscal year. This report is particularly important for investors and stakeholders keen on understanding the company's financial health. Financial Highlights...

Continue Reading
Silicom Ltd. Partners with U.S. Firm for Edge Networking Growth

Updated Category News Views 167

Silicom Ltd. Partners with Provider for Edge Networking Solutions - $1 million annual run rate with potential for a significant multi-million-dollar scale-up - Silicom Ltd. (NASDAQ: SILC), a recognized leader in networking and data infrastructure solutions, has announced an exciting collaboration with a U.S.-based provider specializing in Edge networking solutions...

Continue Reading
Understanding the Ongoing Securities Case Against Five Below, Inc.

Updated Category News Views 120

Overview of the Class Action Lawsuit Against Five Below, Inc. As an investor, it's essential to stay informed about your rights, especially with ongoing legal matters. Currently, a notable class action lawsuit is underway involving Five Below, Inc. (NASDAQ: FIVE), which is particularly relevant for its shareholders. Class Period Details The allegations pertain to the time...

Continue Reading
Worthington Enterprises to Boost Portfolio with LSI Group Buyout

Updated Category News Views 169

Worthington Enterprises Expands Its Portfolio with Major Acquisition Worthington Enterprises Inc. (NYSE: WOR), renowned for its innovative designs and manufacturing prowess, has officially announced its intent to acquire LSI Group, LLC. This major acquisition positions Worthington Enterprises to enhance its offerings and market presence in the metal roofing sector....

Continue Reading