Changing the Patent Debate: Study Finds Potential Benefits

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
News Desk 2018
Changing the Patent Debate: Study Finds Potential Benefits To U.S. Economic Growth of Up to $200 Billion Annually. Frozen Licensing Central Economic Problem.

WASHINGTON, D.C., Nov. 12, 2014 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- via PRWEB - Economists Incorporated (EI) , one of the world's premier economic and public policy consulting firms, today released a new study, " Unlocking Patents: Costs of Failure, Benefits of Success ," finding that the biggest problem with the U.S. patent system is not the much-discussed assertion about abusive patent litigation. Rather, it's a patent licensing market so constricted by high transaction costs and legal risks it prevents literally 95 percent of patented discoveries from ever being put to use to create new products and services, new jobs, and new economic growth. Simply "unlocking" patent licensing from the constraints of those costs, the study finds, would enable tens of thousands of now-dormant inventions to be licensed and commercialized, adding up to $200 billion a year to the economy.

The study was prepared by two economists with a long track-record of ground-breaking public policy research. Dr. Robert Litan is currently a non-resident Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution and has directed economic research at Brookings, the Kaufman Foundation and at Bloomberg Government. His most recent book, Trillion Dollar Economists, has won praise in reviews in the Economist, the Wall Street Journal, and Fortune Magazine. Dr. Hal J. Singer is a Principal at Economists Incorporated as well as a Senior Fellow at Progressive Policy Institute and an Adjunct Professor at Georgetown University's McDonough School of Business.

In their study, the authors cite evidence showing that the vast majority of patent owners and businesses "cannot bear the costs or risks associated" with licensing patented inventions. The result is that "a substantial portion of the two million-plus patents granted, and thus the knowledge and technology they embody, is not commercialized or used to benefit others."

The economic value of these dormant patents , or "Rembrandts in the attic," is an estimated $1 trillion.

Previous research suggests that up to 80 percent of all new technical knowledge is contained in patents alone. Yet the study's authors point out that usually it is only the largest resource-rich companies that can afford the high costs and legal risks associated with using this patented knowledge to develop new products and services. For the overwhelming majority of mid-sized and smaller companies, patents represent not a treasure trove of new technical knowledge but a growing multi-million-dollar infringement risk and wasted investment.

Dr. Litan and Dr. Singer illustrate how this constricted patent licensing system harms the economy. "It is as if the economy were playing a game of baseball in which the only hits that counted were home runs by players on very well-financed teams. In such an economy, vast numbers of other valuable or "run-producing" innovations -- triples, doubles, [or] singles -- generated by many other firms, universities or individual inventors cannot be economically licensed given the potential risks or costs of litigation ."

Although a patent system so limited to "home runs" certainly leads to losses for inventors of more modest innovations -- as well as for businesses who might commercialize these into profitable new products -- the greatest loss is to society as a whole. Indeed, Dr. Litan and Dr. Singer cite previous economic research which demonstrates that the social benefits of innovation can exceed the private gains inventors and businesses derive from innovation by as much as 25 to 1.

Is there a way to expand the numbers of patents licensed and commercialized? Litan and Singer evaluate legislative and other proposals aimed at reducing abusive patent litigation, and conclude that it is impossible at present to determine if their net effects will be positive. In fact, none of these measures, they argue, will address the fundamental flaw in the patent system today -- "namely, its inability to 'scale' beyond the small portion of overall patents, the so-called 'home runs,' owned by large companies with [the] resources to participate in the system."

The authors also note: "…to the extent that high transactions costs and the risks of patent licensing are deterring innovators from even filing patents in the first place, or in the case of many businesses choosing to keep their innovations as trade secrets rather than public knowledge via patent disclosures, society loses from the failure to disseminate new knowledge that could be used by others to develop other innovations."

In contrast, the study suggests that private sector market solutions, which do not require any changes in law, provide the best opportunity to produce a more efficient and economically useful patent system. As stated in the report: "Various new for-profit initiatives are in their early stages, addressing different aspects of the system."

The study's authors estimate that if such emerging private sector solutions, including those found in companies such as the U.S. Patent Utility, RPX Corporation, and LOTNET, succeed in increasing the numbers of patents licensed by 20 percent to 40 percent, this would add as much as $200 billion a year in new growth to the U.S. economy.

The study was supported by The U.S. Patent Utility. The authors take sole responsibility for its contents.

Economists Incorporated is a premier economic consulting firm in the fields of law and economics, public policy, and business strategy. We offer expert consulting and testifying services in the context of litigation, arbitration, proposed mergers and acquisitions, regulatory hearings, and business planning. Our clients include legal counsel, businesses, trade associations, government agencies, and multilateral organizations.

This article was originally distributed on PRWeb. For the original version including any supplementary images or video, visit http://www.prweb.com/releases/2014/11/prweb12308070.htm

Economists Incorporated Dawn Higgins +1 (202) 223-4700

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Excel Treatment Center Adds ART Trauma Therapy Option

Updated Category News Views 101

Trauma rarely arrives at an addiction program wearing a name tag. Excel Treatment Center in Dover, New Jersey, is responding to that uncomfortable reality by adding Accelerated Resolution Therapy® (ART) to the individual, group, and family therapy already available to its clients. The center says its therapists have completed ART training, and the approach is now part of...

Continue Reading
Linkind's Best Buy Push Tests Smart Outdoor Demand

Updated Category News Views 160

Holiday lights have quietly become a year-round hardware category, and Linkind wants a louder seat at the table. The smart-lighting brand says three outdoor products have been in Best Buy stores across the United States since October 17, 2026: permanent exterior lights, decorative string lights, and solar pathway lights. That is a real distribution step, not some grand...

Continue Reading
Blue Diamond's $1 Billion Brand Meets Farm Realities

Updated Category News Views 56

A Ten-Cent Signal Carries Real Weight A ten-cent edge over the industry benchmark may not excite the cocktail-party crowd, but almond growers notice every penny when fertilizer, power and pest control keep gnawing at the farm gate. Blue Diamond Growers says it delivered payments roughly 10 cents above the benchmark in its latest year, alongside net profit that came in...

Continue Reading
Kendra Scott’s Dolly Tribute Tests Purposeful Luxury

Updated Category News Views 87

Butterflies, music notes, and a $70 pendant are carrying a surprisingly serious brand message this November. Kendra Scott’s new Dolly Parton Tribute Collection is plainly built to celebrate Dolly’s style, but it also shows how a consumer brand can make sentiment do some commercial heavy lifting without turning the whole thing into mush. The collection arrived November...

Continue Reading
Chaos Zero Nightmare's Award Is a Useful Signal for Games

Updated Category News Views 239

A story award can be easy to sneer at until a live-service game earns one across three markets. Smilegate's Chaos Zero Nightmare, a dark fantasy roguelike RPG developed by Super Creative, was named Best Story in Google Play's Best of 2026 awards for Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau. That is not a sales figure, not a profit disclosure, and certainly not proof that a hit has...

Continue Reading
Vector Adds Mesa Division 10 Veteran for Arizona Growth

Updated Category News Views 61

A toilet-partition deal rarely raises eyebrows, but this one has the sturdy logic investors ought to notice. Vector Building Products has acquired Mesa-based Partitions & Accessories Co., a Division 10 specialist that has served Arizona contractors since 1978. It is not glamorous work. It is, however, the sort of necessary, specification-driven business that gets embedded...

Continue Reading
Chemours Legal Succession Gets a Long Transition Runway

Updated Category News Views 0

A corporate-law handoff rarely sets pulses racing, but this one deserves a proper look. Chemours is replacing its long-serving general counsel while keeping the departing executive in the building for four additional months. That is not flashy, and thank goodness for that. In a global chemicals company, legal leadership touches regulation, compliance, governance,...

Continue Reading
Villa Group’s Punta Mita Bet Adds 305 Luxury Resort Keys

Updated Category News Views 102

A 12.6-acre slice of Riviera Nayarit coastline is about to get a very expensive makeover, assuming The Villa Group can turn a handsome plan into a functioning resort without the usual development headaches. The company says it has acquired a beachfront parcel in Litibú and intends to build Villa La Valencia Punta Mita, a 305-accommodation luxury property aimed squarely...

Continue Reading
Premier Energy's €850M Debt Bet on Evryo Nears Close

Updated Category News Views 27

A Bridge Loan Gives Way to a Real Commitment Eight hundred and fifty million euros is not the sort of number a company tosses around for decoration. Premier Energy has secured a five-year senior facilities agreement to fund its planned acquisition of Evryo Group, including electricity distribution subsidiary Distribu?ie Energie Oltenia S.A., and to refinance roughly...

Continue Reading
Sokin’s UAE License Turns Expansion Into Real Payments Plumbing

Updated Category News Views 106

Dubai expansion headlines are cheap; regulated local money movement is not. That is why Sokin’s newly approved Dubai Financial Services Authority license deserves more than the usual fintech applause line. The company has paired that approval with AED accounts, local payment rails, a One Za’abeel office and a plan to double its UAE staff over the next year. None of...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Latin Metals Gears Up for Drilling at Organullo Gold Project

Updated Category News Views 176

Latin Metals Achieves Drilling Milestone for Organullo Gold Project Latin Metals Inc. (TSXV: LMS) is excited to announce that it has successfully secured a crucial permit for exploration drilling at the Organullo Gold Project. This approval is a significant step forward in their commitment to mineral exploration in Argentina. What the Drill Permit Means for Latin Metals...

Continue Reading
TheSushiDragon Partners with StreamerDap to Empower Creators

Updated Category News Views 444

TheSushiDragon Joins StreamerDap as Co-Owner In a groundbreaking move for the live streaming community, TheSushiDragon, a prominent Twitch creator, has officially entered an equity partnership with StreamerDap, a leading platform revolutionizing the sponsorship landscape for creators. This innovative partnership aims to enhance the creator experience, making sponsorships...

Continue Reading
Tariffs, Inflation Insights: What Lies Ahead for Markets

Updated Category News Views 198

Market Trends: Understanding Recent Developments The market landscape has shown itself to be quite dynamic recently. As US President Donald Trump indicates the possibility of increased tariffs, there remains a juxtaposition of hope and uncertainty in the air. While discussions of a potential peace agreement between Russia and Ukraine seem to be gaining momentum, this has...

Continue Reading
Chaos Zero Nightmare's Award Is a Useful Signal for Games

Updated Category News Views 239

A story award can be easy to sneer at until a live-service game earns one across three markets. Smilegate's Chaos Zero Nightmare, a dark fantasy roguelike RPG developed by Super Creative, was named Best Story in Google Play's Best of 2026 awards for Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau. That is not a sales figure, not a profit disclosure, and certainly not proof that a hit has...

Continue Reading
Bloom Energy Partners with Oracle to Boost AI Infrastructure

Updated Category News Views 301

Bloom Energy and Oracle: A Strategic Collaboration Bloom Energy Corp (NYSE: BE) is experiencing a notable surge in its stock prices following a recent announcement that highlights a significant partnership with Oracle Corp (NYSE: ORCL). This new collaboration aims to utilize Bloom's innovative fuel cell technology to deliver onsite power solutions for selected Oracle...

Continue Reading