The FCC’s OTT NPRM: Is Aereo cable by nature? OTT, yeah

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
chessmite
The FCC’s OTT NPRM: Is Aereo cable by nature? OTT, yeah MVPD - See more at: http://www.techpolicydaily.com/communications...HgCTv.dpuf


News broke late last month that the FCC is working on a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) that would classify some types of Internet-based video distributors as multichannel video programming distributors (MVPDs). This is a big deal. MVPD classification would place these Internet-based video distributors on similar regulatory footing as traditional MVPDs like cable and satellite, with both the benefits and obligations that such footing entails. At the same time, there are substantial limitations, both on the MVPD classification and on the types of Internet-based video distributors to which the classification would apply.

This is the first in a series of posts that will discuss the regulatory treatment of online video. Today, I’ll provide some background and look at what the NPRM likely would (or could) do, as well as the links between the NPRM and Aereo. In future posts I’ll get into more of the challenges about how specific rules may apply to OTT, the (statutory, if not logical) importance of “linear” vs. other video, and whether this is likely to be a step into the future or further tie the industry to the past.

What may be at stake in the NPRM: What’s an online MVPD, and what rules apply?

Most readers likely have some sense of what an NPRM is, thanks to the ongoing Open Internet rulemaking. The FCC’s OTT NPRM, however, is really a “proto-NPRM.” At this point, it is likely still a draft. And, while there may be some formal or informal guidance from the “8th floor” (where the Commissioners’ offices are), at this point, the process is probably being directed by FCC staff. Staff members are likely working through the intricacies of Title VI, trying to figure out what can and cannot be done under the statute and matching this with various visions of what should or should not be done.

That said, Commission staff have been thinking about these issues since at least 2010, when Sky Angel – a company that provides an Internet-based TV service – filed a complaint with the FCC that would require treating it as an MVPD. Indeed, Commission staff likely had these questions in mind even before then. Both Verizon’s FiOS service and AT&T’s U-Verse service have presented (unresolved) questions about the MVPD classification. And the Copyright Office has been considering similar issues – the treatment of Internet-delivered video – since at least 2000 in proceedings with which the FCC is certainly familiar.

These issues are complex. For instance, there are different, but overlapping, definitions of cable, satellite, and MVPD, with different rules for each definition. As a starting point, given concern over whether Aereo is a “cable system”: the Communications Act’s definition of “cable systems” requires that such systems make use of public rights-of-way. For the purposes of the Communications Act, therefore, Internet-delivered video probably cannot be treated as a “cable system.” If Internet-delivered video is not “cable,” this only leaves two options for how it can be classified under the Communications Act: it is either an MVPD, or it is nothing (meaning that it is subject to little, if any, regulatory treatment by the FCC).

What, then, is an MVPD? As the name suggests, the key feature of an MVPD is that it distributes “multiple channels of video programming.” The quirk here is that both “channels” and “video programming” are statutorily-defined terms, and they probably limit the MVPD classification to the distribution of pre-programmed linear channels; that is, content you “tune in” to – if you turn on your favorite show at 6:03, you miss the first three minutes.

This means that the “online MVPD” classification that the FCC is considering likely can only apply to companies that operate much like traditional cable companies, distributing pre-programmed channels of content. While there are some firms out there that distribute video in this way (e.g., Aereo, FilmOn, Ivi, Sky Angel, and some broadcasters), it would not apply to the YouTubes and Netflixes of the world – or, it could only apply to them to the extent that they are distributing broadcast-style channels. It may also apply to systems like Verizon FiOS, AT&T U-Verse, and any other colloquial “cable system” that uses IP or switched digital video. Some of these systems have informally consented to being regulated as MVPDs, despite implicitly or expressly resisting such classification. Formal classification by the Commission could resolve some lingering questions about the status of these systems.

Figuring out what regulations apply to which technologies isn’t always easy or logical. To give one example, both MVPDs and cable systems are subject to retransmission consent obligations. This means that they need to get permission from broadcasters before retransmitting their signals. However, only cable is subject to must-carry obligations, which allow local broadcasters to insist that local cable companies carry their programming free of charge. The fact that retransmission consent applies to MVPDs has important implications for firms like Aereo, while the fact that the must-carry obligation applies differently to different distribution technologies could have important consequences as firms transition to IP-based delivery technologies.

Why is this coming up now? Is it about Aereo?

It is worth considering why the Commission has turned to the NPRM now. Perhaps the time to address the issue has simply arrived. More likely, two specific incidents have drawn the Commission’s focus: the demise of Sky Angel and the Aereo case. The Commission never came to a decision following Sky Angel’s 2010 filing. It issued a public notice in 2012 and invited comments on the matter, but other than the modest number of comments the Commission received, the Sky Angel docket lay fallow. Over the summer, however, Sky Angel submitted a new filing in the docket, informing the FCC that it had decided to abandon its Internet-based video service. It attributed this decision to the FCC’s failure to act on its petition, saying that it still believed in the business model and had the resources to pursue it.

Shortly after Sky Angel informed the FCC that it was shuttering its operations, the Supreme Court decided the Aereo case, in which the Supreme Court rejected Aereo’s arguments that this business model did not violate copyright law. After its loss before the Supreme Court, Aereo now argues that it is a “cable system” for purposes of the Copyright Act. If this argument ultimately prevails, Aereo will legally be able to retransmit local television content over the Internet, subject to a modest statutory license. This is where the new NPRM comes in. Whether Aereo can make use of the Copyright Act’s statutory license is likely up to the Copyright Office (though the courts may have the final word). The Copyright Office has previously argued that Internet-delivered video does not qualify for the compulsory license – but it has implicitly suggested that it may classify Internet-delivered video as a “cable system” if the FCC also subjects it to regulation under the Communications Act.

This suggests two things. First, the FCC may be considering this issue now in response to questions raised by Aereo and the Copyright Office. And, second, this could (once again) spell “the end” for Aereo. At first blush, this may seem like a big win for Aereo: although it is not certain, if the FCC classifies Internet-delivered video services like Aereo as MVPDs, there is some likelihood that the Copyright Office will follow suit and classify Aereo as a “cable system.” This action will give Aereo access to the Copyright Act’s compulsory license, which is exactly what Aereo wants. But if the FCC classifies Aereo as an MVPD, it will also be subject to the Communications Act’s retransmission consent requirements. This would require Aereo to get consent from local broadcasters to retransmit their signals – and it is likely that such consent would come at a hefty price, if at all.
- See more at: http://www.techpolicydaily.com/communications...HgCTv.dpuf

Digital Uts Ventures (DUTV) Stock Research Links

DUTV Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Radiology Staffing Gap Deepens as Imaging Demand Rises

Updated Category News Views 112

An imaging order does not mean much if nobody is available to read it, and that plain operational fact sits at the center of Medicus Healthcare Solutions' 2026 report on the radiologist shortage. The report's projected gap of 2,450 full-time-equivalent radiologists in 2027 is troubling enough. Its estimate of a 4,130 FTE shortfall by 2032 is the part that should make...

Continue Reading
Shenzhen's Vertical Factories Put Robotics on Fast Track

Updated Category News Views 26

A truck climbing to a ninth-floor factory is the sort of detail that cuts through the usual innovation fog. Shenzhen's Honghualing industrial base in Nanshan is built around that odd-looking reality: keep engineers, component makers, automated lines and test customers stacked close together, then squeeze time out of the process. For anybody watching robotics, LiDAR and...

Continue Reading
Lummus-Versalis Deal Adds Nine Elastomer Technologies

Updated Category News Views 187

Nine elastomer technologies do not make a flashy headline, yet this is the sort of chemical-industry move that can matter long after the applause dies down. Lummus Technology and Versalis have expanded their partnership to cover nine elastomer technologies. That is the disclosed fact, and it is meaningful on its own. The release does not lay out contract value, duration,...

Continue Reading
Fox Hill Steel Marks a Long Public-Building Road Ahead

Updated Category News Views 70

A signed steel beam is a fine civic moment, but it is not the finish line. Burlington’s new Fox Hill Elementary School has reached its topping-off milestone, with the structural steel now in place for a 91,000-square-foot, two-story facility intended to serve roughly 325 kindergarten-through-fifth-grade students. That is tangible progress, the sort nobody can fake with...

Continue Reading
Texas Restaurants Get a New Read on Customer Demand

Updated Category News Views 195

Texas restaurant owners are being handed a sharper flashlight, and frankly it is overdue. HundredX and the Texas Restaurant Association have launched a pilot that gives TRA members access to the HundredX Restaurant Insights Platform, aiming to bring customer and market intelligence to the independent operators and regional chains that usually cannot pay big-company prices...

Continue Reading
ArchiPro Enters U.S. Design Market With Curated Bet

Updated Category News Views 56

Blue-chip furniture and glossy project photos are not a moat by themselves, no matter how hard a platform tries to make them look like one. But ArchiPro’s full U.S. launch deserves a closer look because it arrives with something many would-be marketplace operators lack: more than a decade of operating history in New Zealand and Australia. A Three-Sided Machine Meets...

Continue Reading
Another Nine's A9OS Puts Software at Center of Golf

Updated Category News Views 100

A golf simulator chain is trying to turn the boring plumbing into its sharpest club. Another Nine’s A9OS is not merely a booking widget dressed up for a franchise brochure; it is meant to run the whole 24/7 operation, from payments and door access to cameras, simulator support and guest help. That ambition deserves attention because this is exactly where a staff-free...

Continue Reading
Watson Motion Tests Military Pretrial Confinement Rules

Updated Category News Views 170

Military confinement fights are rarely neat, and this one comes with a short clock but plenty of unanswered questions. Defense lawyers for U.S. Air Force Maj. Jason Watson argued on Nov. 17 that he should be released from pretrial confinement while his case proceeds. A military judge is ordinarily expected to issue a ruling within 14 days of the hearing, under the court's...

Continue Reading
Leatt Sets Its Virtual 2026 Shareholder Meeting Date

Updated Category News Views 73

A calendar notice is not a catalyst, but ignoring the calendar is how shareholders miss the small moments that matter. Leatt Corporation has scheduled its 2026 virtual annual general meeting of stockholders for Friday, November 20, at 11:00 AM Eastern Time. For holders of OTCQB:LEAT, this is a basic corporate-governance event, not a new product launch or a financial...

Continue Reading
Esquire Spotlight Puts Trauma Cleanup Work in Focus

Updated Category News Views 96

A national magazine profile is an odd milestone for a business built around other people’s worst days. David Lesaffre, co-owner and operator of T.A.C.T. 48, T.A.C.T. AZ, and T.A.C.T. Fort Worth, has been featured by Esquire in a piece called “The Trauma Cleaners.” The attention is deserved, frankly, because biohazard remediation is one of those necessary services...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Insightful Update on Scully Royalty's Annual Meeting Plans

Updated Category News Views 129

Insightful Overview of Scully Royalty's Annual Meeting Scully Royalty Ltd. (NYSE: SRL) has recently provided valuable insights regarding its upcoming annual general meeting (AGM) scheduled for December 27, 2025. This update follows a noteworthy event involving MILFAM LLC, which filed a purported dissident proxy circular aimed at nominating five candidates for the...

Continue Reading
How a $1,000 Bitcoin Investment Shaped Financial Perspectives

Updated Category News Views 353

The Shift in Bitcoin's Investment Landscape Cryptocurrency has turned into a financial wild west, where fortunes are made and lost at lightning speed. At the center of this universe is Bitcoin, once brushed off by many traditional financiers. One such critic was Jamie Dimon, CEO of JPMorgan & Chase, who didn't hold back his disdain for the digital currency. Dimon’s...

Continue Reading
Netcompany's Share Buyback Program Progress Report

Updated Category News Views 162

Overview of Netcompany's Share Buyback Program In a strategic move to optimize its capital structure, Netcompany Group A/S has initiated a significant share buyback program aiming to repurchase up to DKK 250 million worth of shares. This action is accompanied by a target to acquire a maximum of 1,300,000 shares, reflecting Netcompany's commitment to fulfilling its...

Continue Reading
Ramaco Resources Partners with Goldman Sachs for Minerals Initiative

Updated Category News Views 133

Collaboration with Goldman Sachs Ramaco Resources, Inc. (NASDAQ: METC, METCB) has taken a significant step forward by teaming up with Goldman Sachs & Co. LLC. This partnership aims to establish a new initiative focused on creating a Strategic Critical Minerals Terminal (SCMT) at Ramaco's Brook Mine facility. Strategic Importance of the SCMT The SCMT initiative, approved...

Continue Reading
Understanding V2X's Upgrade to Buy: Key Insights Revealed

Updated Category News Views 96

Understanding V2X's Current Market Position V2X VVX has recently caught the eye of investors after being upgraded to a "Buy" rating. This upgrade marks a significant shift in earnings estimates, which are pivotal in determining stock valuations. The improved earnings outlook reflects a growing sense of optimism among analysts, boosting the overall attractiveness of the...

Continue Reading