Financial Advice With Zero Return Many people rely on

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
NITE


Financial Advice With Zero Return
Many people rely on financial advisors, either independent ones or those employed at banks. The good ones will at least ensure that you have a sensibly diversified portfolio and that it stays that way. However, a recent study indicates that many advisors do not increase the actual investment returns on an ongoing basis.

What Advisors Do and Don't
An investigation conducted at the University of Frankfurt in Germany reveals that neither portfolios advised by banks nor independent advisors, do any better than those for which no advice was given. Finance professor Andreas Hackethal explains that the main problem is the failure of advisors "to correct systematic investment errors sufficiently, while at the same time, they generate additional costs." (For related reading, see Diversifying Your Portfolio.)

Furthermore, this work almost certainly applies to the United States. According to Hackethal, an investigation by Bergstresser et. al in the U.S., demonstrated that mutual funds sold through U.S. broker channels underperform other mutual funds. They take this as indirect evidence that brokers or advisors do not add value for clients.



The Frankfurt-based study used client data from a large German bank and from an online broker that specializes in providing independent advice. The survey sample that was given advice, performed no better than the execution-only group.

The researchers also confirm that banks (and certain other advisors) have the wrong incentive structures, so that the advisory process all too often helps only the seller and not the investor. (To learn more, read Paying Your Investment Advisor - Fees Or Commissions?)

Investor Reluctance to Obtain and Follow Good Advice
Good advisors are clearly hard to find, but they are indeed out there. However, Hackethal found a widespread client reluctance to use good, skilled advice, "preferring to rely on their own generally mediocre investment skills." A staggering 95% of those questioned were not even interested in free independent advice from an advisor with no incentive, at all, to recommend specific products.

Equally amazing is the fact that of the remaining 5%, only half actually followed the advice that they were given. Of this tiny group, half again followed the advice only half-heartedly, even though the recommendations would have led to substantially better returns.

It seems to be mainly wealthy, experienced investors who really appreciate the value of good advice from the right people. Yet, almost anyone would benefit from a second, objective opinion on what to do with their hard-earned savings.

The Solutions
The Frankfurt researchers do not believe that more governmental regulation is the answer either. In particular, given the above consumer attitudes to advice, purely seller-side regulation seems doomed to fail. For instance, Hackethal doubts that simply providing more information in the form of brochures, for example, will help much. It will take a lot more "to achieve the necessary transparency and learning effects … with respect to investment risks and opportunities."

Clearly, somehow, investor attitudes towards advice need to change and the incentive structures in the industry as well. In addition, investment selling processes at banks may need to be overhauled in a more general sense. There is a compelling need to establish just why, in so many instances, the advisory process fails to work for the investor.

There are undoubtedly independent and bank advisors who can and will help people get more "bang (and bank) for their buck." What is lacking is an understanding of the difference between good, mediocre and really bad advice. Above all, far greater market transparency is essential, so that people are able to draw the appropriate distinctions between a fine investment, a rip-off and the various shades of gray between the two extremes. At present, too many investors just do not know who they are dealing with. As Hackethal puts it "the person sitting opposite them could be excellent or an outright crook. The clients just don't know." (Learn more on how to Find The Right Financial Advisor.)

An Important Benefit Remains - with Genuinely Independent Advisors
Independent financial advice can, however, at least prevent excessively risky, undiversified portfolios. That is, even if an advisor does not lead to better returns, if they can prevent you from having a high risk portfolio that rockets in a boom and plummets in a bear market, that can be worth a lot. This is a separate issue and needs to be kept in mind. The above research dealt with better investment performance, not with avoiding disastrous losses in a crash.

The Bottom Line
Financial advice can be pretty ineffectual for two main reasons. Firstly, when the incentive structures are wrong, the advice benefits mainly or only the bank or broker. Secondly, investors are remarkably reluctant either to seek out or follow objective advice from a third party. Overcoming this highly unsatisfactory situation entails a combination of changed structures and attitudes on both the buyer and seller sides of the market. This is not easy to achieve, and regulation alone will certainly not do it. The industry needs to take a long, hard look at what it is doing, both wrong and right.
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Colon Cleanse Advice Deserves a Careful Read First

Updated Category News Views 93

Wellness copy can sound harmless right up until it blurs comfort guidance with health guidance. HelloNation’s feature on what to expect after a colon cleanse, drawing on Suzanne Childre of Gentle Wellness Center in Santa Monica, lays out a fairly familiar recovery script: drink water, rest, eat lightly, expect some bowel changes, and do not panic over a little fatigue....

Continue Reading
Refund Delays Are Becoming an E-Commerce Sales Risk

Updated Category News Views 176

A returned jacket can turn into a household cash-flow problem faster than retailers seem willing to admit. Seel's new survey lands at an awkward moment for online merchants: shoppers are not merely annoyed by slow refunds; many are budgeting around them. Among 1,921 U.S. adults who had shopped online in the prior six months, 63% said waiting for a retailer to receive a...

Continue Reading
First Grade Literacy Push Deserves a Harder Look Now

Updated Category News Views 130

A reading gap can become a concrete wall before anyone bothers measuring it. That is the uncomfortable point behind Ignite Reading's First Grade Promise, and it deserves more attention than another polished education announcement usually gets. At a Nov. 5 Convene 2026 gathering in Boston, 56 district and literacy leaders from six states focused on getting children reading...

Continue Reading
PG&E's $456 Million Interim Hike Faces a New Test Soon

Updated Category News Views 51

A utility can call a charge interim, but households still see the bill arrive in full. That is why the California Public Utilities Commission's unanimous approval of $456 million in interim rate recovery for Pacific Gas & Electric has landed with such rotten timing. The money is set to begin flowing from customers on January 1, 2027, while major questions about PG&E's...

Continue Reading
Lecanemab's Alpha-Syn Signal Deserves a Cooler Head

Updated Category News Views 45

Mixed pathology is where Alzheimer's investing gets uncomfortably real, and this new lecanemab readout is a decent reminder that a drug can show promise without settling the argument. Eisai and Biogen presented a Clarity AD cerebrospinal-fluid substudy at CTAD 2026 examining people with early Alzheimer's disease who also tested positive for alpha-synuclein pathology. The...

Continue Reading
CATL Builds Türkiye Battery Service Muscle in Istanbul

Updated Category News Views 43

Battery warranties look mighty impressive until a pack needs work on a Tuesday morning and nobody nearby can touch it. CATL's new NING SERVICE Experience Center in Istanbul goes straight at that unglamorous problem. The facility, announced November 19, 2026, is described as Türkiye's first dedicated battery depot repair center and an integrated sales-and-service hub. It...

Continue Reading
Compounded Peptides Demand Clearer FDA Status Answers

Updated Category News Views 73

Peptide talk has gotten muddled enough to make plain English feel revolutionary. The central point in the HelloNation article featuring wellness expert Andres Giraldo is straightforward: a compounded peptide is not FDA approved in the same product-specific manner as a commercially manufactured drug. That is not a small semantic wrinkle, and it should not be buried beneath...

Continue Reading
Lowe's Dec. 9 Conference Puts Strategy on the Clock

Updated Category News Views 148

A Calendar Entry With Real Weight December 9 is not earnings day, but it is the sort of date shareholders ought to circle anyway. Lowe's plans to hold its 2026 Analyst and Investor Conference at 8 a.m. Eastern time in New York City, with a live webcast available for those not sitting in the room. For owners of NYSE:LOW, these gatherings can be more useful than the usual...

Continue Reading
IT Tech Packaging's Going-Concern Warning Lands Hard

Updated Category News Views 76

A paper maker can survive plenty of ugly quarters; it cannot casually shrug off an auditor questioning whether it can keep operating. That is the cold part of IT Tech Packaging's Nov. 19 disclosure. Its newly filed Form 10-K for the year ended Dec. 31, 2025 carries a “Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern” paragraph from Audit Alliance LLP. Nobody should dress...

Continue Reading
AIM Academy Accreditation Signals a Broader Quality Push

Updated Category News Views 50

Early-childhood education does not hand out many clean, easily comparable scorecards, which is precisely why AIM Academy’s new Cognia recognition deserves a closer look. The Alabama provider has earned Cognia Initial Accreditation, while its Pike Road center received Accreditation with Merit after its Initial Accreditation Review. That is not a revenue event, not a...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Alfa Laval Enhances Gulf Coast Support with La Porte Expansion

Updated Category News Views 183

Alfa Laval Strengthens Local Support with La Porte Service Center Alfa Laval, a world leader in heat transfer, separation, and fluid handling, is proud to announce the expansion of its Service Center in La Porte, Texas. This newly expanded facility is set to bolster the support for the Gulf Coast's industrial community, demonstrating the company’s commitment to local...

Continue Reading
AgEagle Aerial Systems Achieves Impressive Q1 Financial Gains

Updated Category News Views 209

AgEagle Aerial Systems Achieves Strong Financial Results A remarkable transformation is underway at AgEagle Aerial Systems Inc. (NYSE: UAVS), a key player in unmanned aerial systems (UAS) and sensor technology. The company has announced financial results for the first quarter of fiscal year 2025, showcasing a sharp recovery and robust performance in various financial...

Continue Reading
Empowering Future Leaders: The 6th Student Research Competition

Updated Category News Views 259

Empowering Future Leaders: The 6th Student Research Competition The Fixed Income Analysts Society (FIASI), in partnership with Fordham University's Center for Research in Contemporary Finance and the O'Shea Center for Credit Analysis and Investment, is excited to announce the launch of its highly anticipated 6th Annual FIASI – Gabelli School Student Research...

Continue Reading
LALO Tequila Unveils Unique 2025 High Proof Blanco Expression

Updated Category News Views 414

Introducing the 2025 High Proof Blanco Tequila LALO Tequila proudly presents its latest creation, the 2025 High Proof Blanco, marking a significant chapter in its celebrated line of limited-edition spirits. Scheduled just in time for Hispanic Heritage Month, this release embodies the brand’s strong cultural roots while embracing modern advancements in the tequila...

Continue Reading
TaskUs, Inc. to Reveal Q3 2024 Earnings on November 7

Updated Category News Views 95

TaskUs, Inc. to Reveal Financial Results for Q3 2024 TaskUs, Inc. (Nasdaq: TASK), a prominent leader in providing outsourced digital services and advanced customer experience, will disclose its third quarter 2024 financial results following the market's closure on November 7. Conference Call and Webcast Details Management will conduct a conference call and webcast at 5:00...

Continue Reading