New details on ambassador’s failed, fateful push for

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
Lmcat

New details on ambassador’s failed, fateful push for more security at Benghazi

A Libyan man walks past the closed U.S. consulate in Benghazi. (Abdullah  Doma/AFP/Getty Images)

Two journalists combed through the U.S. consulate building in Benghazi, Libya, over a month after it was attacked and turned up something significant : two unsigned draft letters expressing strong concern about security at the building. The letters are dated Sept. 11 – the day of the attack – and addressed to Libya’s foreign minister and Benghazi’s police chief. U.S. Ambassador Chris Stevens’s team had earlier requested additional security from the Libyans, according to the letters, and were not satisfied with the results.

The story make clear that there was a significant gap between the security that Stevens had in Benghazi and the security he felt the consulate badly needed. It originally appeared on pan-Arab network Al-Aan and is now in English on ForeignPolicy.com.

With all the rumors, conflicting accounts and confusingly contradictory narratives that have come out of Benghazi in the past month, it’s worth carefully parsing what we learn, and don’t, from this and other new pieces of information out today:

1) Ambassador Stevens and his staff clearly held significant, sustained concerns about security at the consulate. They cite a police officer taking very suspicious photos of the building. What they did with those concerns is a little murkier.

2) We now know that Stevens took his concerns to local and national Libyan authorities. It’s not clear whether or not the letters that Al-Aan found ever got mailed. But they clearly follow up on previous requests for significantly heightened security. It seems pretty clear that local and national Libyan authorities fell down on those requests.

3) Libyan officials have not been terribly successful at organizing basic state functions, including security services. This was well-publicized at the time, and Stevens had clearly bumped up against his own challenges in getting Libyan officials to take charge. This is where it gets tricky: Why did Stevens keep pushing the Libyans for security instead of giving up on them and going to U.S. sources?

4) We don’t know, from these letters, the degree to which Stevens did or did not seek U.S. help in alleviating the security problem. The doggedness with which he pursued Libyan security for the building, right up through the day of the attack, suggests he thought that was among his best courses. Fox News last night reported that the Benghazi consulate had drafted an Aug. 16 memo articulating its security concerns and announcing plans to “submit specific requests to US Embassy Tripoli for additional physical security upgrades and staffing needs by separate cover.” The obvious question: Did they follow through on this by Sept. 11 and request those “staffing needs” be filled by Americans? A  New York Times investigation this month, on the extent of U.S. security requests in Libya, would seem to suggest that they did not. It would be consistent with what we know so far if the Benghazi consulate had sought Tripoli’s permission for additional Libyan security, of the kind Stevens asked for in his letters.

5) Why was Stevens not devoting his full attention on the security problem toward securing American support, given the Libyans’ inability to follow through? Context: The U.S. has 294 physical embassy and consulate facilities around the world, which by necessity  depend on local security . The  New York Times investigation found that U.S. diplomats in Libya had requested greater U.S. security in Tripoli ( not in Benghazi, 400 miles away) and had their requests denied by “mid-level” State Department officials – the highest that those requests went.

6) There are a lof of pieces to this puzzle, and they fit together a few different ways. Here’s the worst-case, plausible scenario that I can put together , based on the available information: Stevens did not believe that the U.S. would meet his requests for additional security at Benghazi consulate, which is why he was pushing the Libyans. Maybe this was because the State Department had earlier denied the Tripoli embassy’s appeal, maybe they’d denied more recent appeals specific to Benghazi, or maybe some other reason. This would be the worst-case because Libya’s problems were not a secret at the time, and it’s alarming to imagine the State Department as institutionally unresponsive to those problems and to one of their ambassadors’ appeals.

7) Here’s the best-case that I can construct based on this information : Stevens earnestly wanted the Libyans to fill the security gap at Benghazi. Maybe, in this scenario, this was because he thought it was the host country’s responsibility, maybe because he thought it was protocol, or some other reason. “Best-case” (a relative phrase here, obviously) because it would boil down to one veteran ambassador making an informed decision that turned out to be costly. This is still obviously bad, but it is the least bad of what I can put together.

8) Here’s what neither of these scenarios suggests: a failure by anyone higher up than those mid-level State Department officials responsible for handling security requests from Libyan diplomatic outposts.

9) One piece of bad news in any scenario I can imagine: The FBI has still not secured the consulate grounds. The Al-Aan/Foreign Policy article sympathetically notes that the FBI is probably preoccupied with keeping the other Americans still in Libya safe. Still, with the amount of attention the Benghazi attack has received and the size of the FBI, it’s puzzling that it’s still so easy for reporters to roam around the consulate and pick through sensitive government documents.

10) Caveats: Like everyone else, I’m working with incomplete information, and it’s entirely possible that new revelations will alter or even contradict my already-hazy reading. And the weak security at the time of the attack is not the only issue here – David Ignatius raised questions about the U.S. response once the attack had begun, which is its own complicated and foggy story. But it’s worth trying to nail down what we know and don’t, what we can plausibly imagine based on this information and can’t.

What am I missing?

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldview...-benghazi/

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

CD Rates Offer Stillness as Stocks and Gold Wobble

Updated Category News Views 16

November has delivered the sort of tape that makes a supposedly diversified portfolio feel like a leaky boat. Stocks fell sharply, gold slid to a one-year low after record highs as recently as January, and Treasuries have not provided the dependable ballast many investors expected. When inflation worries and federal-debt concerns shove yields higher, bond prices can drop...

Continue Reading
Cracking Life Insurance Needs: John Dorsa's Insights

Updated Category News Views 150

Life Insurance: A Necessary Puzzle Life’s uncertainties have a way of putting a wrench in our plans, and nothing screams uncertainty like figuring out life insurance. But fret not! HelloNation’s got insights on this financial maze, and they’ve roped in insurance pro John Dorsa from Ridgeland to help out. Calculating Coverage Needs Forget the one-size-fits-all...

Continue Reading
CSMI Boosts CT's Cybersecurity for Defense Sector

Updated Category News Views 132

Paving the Way for Cybersecurity Excellence Out in chilly Connecticut, CSMI made a mark. The State's Office of Manufacturing picked them to join the advisory council for the Defense CyberSecure Program (CT-DCP). It ain’t just a pat on the back; it's a big deal for the region's defense and aerospace manufacturing gang. Connecticut's got its eyes set on beefing up its...

Continue Reading
Biotech Hit or Miss: Trials and Tribulations

Updated Category News Views 127

Biotech's Roller Coaster: Triumphs and Setbacks Ah, the biotech sector—it's a bit like jumping on a bull, ain't it? You barely hang on when the beast bucks. Monday's market action was downright wild. The S&P 500 didn't have a party, tumbling 1.92%, and the Nasdaq wasn't any friendlier, plummeting 2.49%. Yet, inside this storm, we see some biotech names either catching...

Continue Reading
NVCA Refreshes Key Venture Legal Documents for 2026

Updated Category News Views 115

Keeping Pace with Evolving Venture Norms Change never lets up in the fast-paced world of venture capital, does it? Just when you think you've got the rules figured out, the game shifts. This time, it's the National Venture Capital Association (NVCA) shaking things up. They've given a facelift to seven of their model legal documents, a move that reshapes the legal...

Continue Reading
GALC Launches Tender Offer on 2027 Notes Amid Debt Play

Updated Category News Views 91

Aviation Leasing Giant's Strategic Financial Move Well folks, we're staring down the barrel of a financial maneuver by Global Aircraft Leasing Co., Ltd. (GALC) that’s not just another day at the office. They've kicked off a cash tender offer for their 8.750% Senior Secured Notes due 2027, aiming to sweep up any and all outstanding ones. That's $932 million in principle...

Continue Reading
TYYY Liquidation Leaves Holders With a Tight Exit Window

Updated Category News Views 28

A fund can vanish faster than investors can read the fine print, and TYYY is doing exactly that. Exchange Traded Concepts has approved the closure and liquidation of the xETFs TSLA Daily Income ETF, with the fund expected to cease operations and distribute cash on or about November 20, 2026. This is not a debate about whether holders should love or hate Tesla. The product...

Continue Reading
Stellus PBDC's Q3: Solid Income but NAV Drops

Updated Category News Views 208

Stellus PBDC: Q3 Earnings and Strategic Moves Things are getting interesting in Houston where Stellus Private Credit BDC just laid out its financial cards for the third quarter of 2026. Now, I’ve seen my fair share of quarterly reports, but Stellus seems to have stitched a quilt of mixed results this time around. Investment Income and Portfolio Shifts First off, net...

Continue Reading
PawnMate Boosts Inventory Efficiency for Pawnshops

Updated Category News Views 213

RFID Technology: Breathing New Life into Pawnshops Let's get things rolling with the cold, hard truth that pawnshops aren't exactly what most folks expect when it comes to cutting-edge technology. But times are a-changin', and PawnMate’s RFID Inventory Module is the latest twist in this industry storyline. It's like swapping out a rusty toolbox for a brand-new set of...

Continue Reading
Fuel Cell Market Faces Uneven Growth Amid Revenue Shifts

Updated Category News Views 144

Fuel Cell Sector Eyes Mixed Results and Big Projections The fuel cell market, oh what a beast it's becoming—a story filled with ups and downs, and more forecasts than a weather station. As we stand, this sector is poised to balloon to an $18.16 billion market by 2030. That's a growth rate of 26.3% annually, folks. These projections are driving excitement, but the...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Soka Gakkai International's Commitment to Peace and Dialogue

Updated Category News Views 482

Soka Gakkai International Empowers Dialogue at Peace Forum Recently, Soka Gakkai International (SGI) announced its participation in a significant event dedicated to peace and dialogue. This forum will take place following a prestigious Nobel Peace Prize ceremony where the Association of Hibakusha will receive accolades for their enduring advocacy for world peace. A Forum...

Continue Reading
Harnessing AI for Effortless Image and Video Creation with Sisi

Updated Category News Views 369

Revolutionizing Visual Content Creation with AI In an age where digital visuals play a crucial role in communication, Fotor stands out as a pioneer in enhancing creativity with technological prowess. The company has recently introduced the Fotor AI Agent, affectionately known as Sisi, an innovative AI-powered assistant geared to simplify the process of creating images and...

Continue Reading
China Hour Expands Chinese Media Footprint in Africa

Updated Category News Views 51

An Ambitious Cross-Continental Media Play The airwaves are getting a new twist. This time, it's a blend of cultures, as China Hour makes an entrance in South Africa. That's right, folks—Jiangsu Broadcasting Corporation (JSBC) has set up camp alongside the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SABC), pushing a big media wave across the continent. If you've been...

Continue Reading
BlockFills Enhances Liquidity for Institutional Traders in Crypto

Updated Category News Views 209

BlockFills Partners with CoinDesk Indices for Enhanced Market Liquidity BlockFills, a prominent player in the digital assets sector, is making strides to improve liquidity in the cryptocurrency market. Its recent collaboration with CoinDesk Indices aims to establish an institutional-grade options market, particularly targeting the CoinDesk 20 Index. This initiative is...

Continue Reading
Understanding the Recent Options Trends with Airbnb (NASDAQ: ABNB)

Updated Category News Views 101

Airbnb's Options Activity Explained Investors are eyeing Airbnb (NASDAQ: ABNB) with a fair amount of skepticism lately. Notably, there has been a noteworthy increase in bearish options activity, a trend that could indicate potential shifts in market dynamics that traders should not take lightly. Our observations reveal significant insights into how savvy players are...

Continue Reading