RomneyCare vs. ObamaCare – which is better? Print |

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
fitzkarz

RomneyCare vs. ObamaCare – which is better?

Posted by John McDonough August 27, 2012 10:54 PM

Mitt Romney has ended his self-imposed silence on his signature achievement as Massachusetts Governor -- declaring himself "very proud" of his signing of the Massachusetts Health Reform law (aka: RomneyCare, Chapter 58) in April 2006.

Appearing on Fox News and other outlets, Romney also declared that the Massachusetts Health Reform law is "better" than the Affordable Care Act (aka: ObamaCare).

Reasonable question: which is better? Personally, I am delighted that the two presidential contenders might debate which government-engineered scheme to expand affordable health insurance is better. Let me try and offer my own answer.

There is no simple answer. On some things, RomneyCare wins, on others, it's hands-down ObamaCare. And on some, it's more complicated. Let's look at some details:

Ways that RomneyCare (RC) is better than ObamaCare (OC):

1. RC provides deeper premium support and cost sharing subsidies to make health insurance more affordable to those receiving public subsidies.

2. RC established an insurance exchange (Connector) with a directive to be an advocate to keep consumers' health insurance premiums more affordable.

Ways that ObamaCare is better than RomneyCare:

1. OC premium support and cost sharing subsidies help families with incomes up to 400% of the federal poverty line, vs. 300% FPL under RC.

2. OC bans lifetime and annual benefit caps and RC does not.

3. OC eliminates medical underwriting and pre-existing condition exclusions for all health insurance policies. Massachusetts did this in the 1990s and so there was no need for this to be addressed in RC.

4. OC requires health insurance companies to spend at least 80-85 cents of every premium dollar on medical costs as opposed to profits, marketing and overhead.  RC includes no such provisions.

5. OC allows young adults to stay on their parents' health insurance policies until they reach age 26. RC allows young adults to stay on their parents' plan for up to two years after they are no longer dependent, and no older than age 25.

6. OC requires that all health insurance policies cover preventive care services (ie: contraception) with no co-pays or other cost sharing. RC has no such protections.

7. OC requires that all Members of Congress and their staffs can receive federal health insurance coverage via the new state health insurance exchanges. RC did not make any similar requirement on Massachusetts state legislators.

8. OC improves Medicare for its beneficiaries by: closing the prescription drug "donut hole;" providing an annual wellness checkup with no cost sharing; lowering beneficiary premiums; and extending the life of the Hospital Insurance/Part A Trust Fund by about 8 years. RC does not address or improve Medicare at all.

9. OC instigates a significant effort to lower the health care system's administrative costs. RC has no such provisions at all.

10. OC instigates a series of reforms in the delivery of medical care services, including the establishment of accountable care organizations, medical homes, value-based insurance designs, penalties for excessive rates of hospital acquired infections and readmissions, and more. RC does not address delivery system improvements at all.

11. OC establishes a series of programs and initiatives to improve public health, prevention and wellness, including the creation of the first-ever national prevention strategy. RC provides funding for some existing public health programs, though no new public health or prevention initiatives.

12. OC requires every chain restaurant with at least 20 outlets to post on menus and menu boards the calories of every item on its menu. RC has no such public information requirement.

13. OC includes major new funding for community health centers and the National Health Service Corps to improve the nation's supply of primary care services. RC has no such provisions.

14. OC requires the establishment of a National Health Workforce Commission -- appointed, though blocked from convening by House Republicans. RC does not address health care workforce needs at all.

15. OC establishes major new provisions to combat health care fraud and abuse in Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurance. RC includes no provisions addressing fraud and abuse in any sector.

16. OC establishes new standards and a national framework to combat elder abuse, including violence, neglect, and financial exploitation. RC includes no such provisions.

17. OC requires that drug, medical device, and medical supply companies publicly report all gifts, honoraria, and other gratuities to physicians and other licensed medical professionals. RC includes no such provisions.

18. OC directs the Food & Drug Administration to create a pathway for the approval of so-called "bio-similars" or generic-like versions of biopharmaceutical drugs, provisions strongly supported by the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries. RC has no such provisions.

19. OC includes provisions to ensure that nursing patients and their families are able to obtain transparent information about the ownership and corporate responsibility of nursing homes. RC includes no such protections.

20. OC establishes a new 10% tax on indoor tanning services, which have been linked to the explosion in serious skin cancers, especially melanomas, among young women ages 15-35. RC does not address this epidemic.

OK -- 20 versus 2. You may have others which will add or subtract from either column. My verdict -- as a BIG fan of MA health reform -- ObamaCare wins easily.

Now, one other BIG difference: financing. Here's Mitt:

"My health care plan I put in place in my state has everyone insured, but we didn't go out and raise taxes on people and have a unelected board tell people what kind of health care they can have," Romney said in an interview with CBS' Denver affiliate, KCNC.

So which plan is better when it comes to financing? Again, fair question.

It's true, there were no tax increases (unless you count individual and employer tax penalties for non-coverage) associated with MA health reform. But there's a big difference -- Massachusetts got the federal government to pick up the lion's share of the cost. MA health reform would have been impossible without the Administration of President George W. Bush playing Sugar Daddy.

I would propose -- the appropriate comparison is how ObamaCare was financed in comparison with the major health achievement of Obama's predecessor, George W. Bush.

In 2003, with Bush's strong support, a Republican-controlled House and Senate approved the Medicare Modernization Act (MMA) that created the Medicare Part D prescription drug benefit, a big advance sought by senior citizen groups for many years. How was that law financed? 25% was financed by Medicare enrollee premiums and 75% was financed by lathering the costs onto the federal deficit. The Congressional Budget Office estimates that between 2010 and 2019, the MMA would increase the federal debt by about one trillion dollars.

In 2010, with Obama's strong support, a Democratic-controlled House and Senate approved the Affordable Care Act (ACA). White House and Congressional leaders decided that the law needed to be entirely self-financed so that it would not increase the federal debt at all. The CBO estimated in 2010 that the ACA would reduce the federal debt by about $140 billion 2010-2019.

Mitt Romney and the Republican Party support the Part D drug program and indicate no desire to eliminate it. They also indicate no desire, retrospectively, to develop a plan to pay for it beyond allowing the Chinese (and other purchasers of U.S. debt) to finance it. Barack Obama and the Democrats support the ACA and made the most difficult decision to pay for it. You can easily disagree with how they chose to pay for it -- and still respect their integrity in taking the political hits to pay for it.

Advantage -- Obama and ObamaCare.

I'm in it to win it!

NASDAQ DIP and RIP
Here is the best word that describes what i do here.
Intuitive;
means having the ability to understand or know something without any direct evidence or reasoning process.

I was born with it, I'm truly blessed!


Alway's searching for winners'
937206596_images.jpg
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Duke Energy Florida Plans Major Rate Cut for 2027

Updated Category News Views 113

Slashing Rates to Keep Customers Happy Staring down utility bills isn't anyone's favorite pastime, but there's some good news for folks under Duke Energy Florida's wings. Come January 2027, customers throughout the Sunshine State are in for a surprise on their electricity bills—lower numbers! A $33 slash in the typical residential power bill could be just around the...

Continue Reading
Tarte's Record-Breaking Collab: 60 Seconds to Sellout

Updated Category News Views 37

When Makeup Meets Pajamas: The Perfect Storm Picture this: a makeup brand and a lifestyle label dreaming up a collaboration that sends consumers into a full-blown frenzy. In a whirlwind that lasted just 60 seconds, tarte's latest partnership with Roller Rabbit blazed through stock, cementing its place as a record-breaking phenomenon. Maureen Kelly, tarte’s intrepid CEO,...

Continue Reading
Markets Split on Election Day: Dow Dips, Nasdaq Soars

Updated Category News Views 25

Election Day rolled in like a wild card, with markets doing their dance that makes seasoned traders either groan or grin. This time, Tuesday saw the Dow slipping while the Nasdaq climbed higher, reflecting a split personality kind of session. Ain't it funny how one day can hold such different tales depending on which index gets your focus? Indices' Dance: Dow Down, Nasdaq...

Continue Reading
Atlas-SSI Expands Grip in Water Control Space

Updated Category News Views 113

Atlas-SSI Makes Waves with Linita Acquisition Here's the kind of news that makes an old market hound sit up and take notice. Atlas-SSI, the big cheese in North America for water management solutions, has gone and snagged Linita Design & Manufacturing. Why's this worth talking about? Linita isn't just any player—they've been crafting custom-engineered hydro-mechanical...

Continue Reading
LULU Under Fire: Class Action Opportunities Await

Updated Category News Views 21

Lululemon Faces a Legal Storm If you're holding shares in Lululemon (NASDAQ: LULU), you might want to sit up and pay attention. Schall, Brown & Schwartz LLP, a national shareholder rights litigation firm, is gathering folks for a securities fraud class action lawsuit against Lululemon. They're pointing fingers at the company for cooking the books – or at least not being...

Continue Reading
Hidden Fences: A Smarter Choice for Pet Owners?

Updated Category News Views 61

The Case for Invisible Fences Man's best friend meets modern containment! Why are hidden fences gaining traction in households across Culpeper, VA, and beyond? Pet Containment Expert Lawrence Sowers spills some valuable insights into why so many are ditching traditional fences. Practical reasons abound, folks! Keeping the Yard Beautiful Who wants their landscaping ruined...

Continue Reading
Jon Gregoire Leads Parkview's Next Growth Phase

Updated Category News Views 151

Steering Parkview into New Waters Every now and then, a company gets a leader who feels like a tailor-made fit for its ambitions. Parkview Dental Partners just scored big with Jon Gregoire taking the helm as CEO. Gregoire, a seasoned DSO bigwig with a knack for M&A, is set to power up the gears for Parkview’s next growth spurt. We're talking about a guy who knows the...

Continue Reading
WuXi Biologics Racks Up Top Honors for ESG Excellence

Updated Category News Views 60

WuXi Strikes Gold with ESG Distinction Take a look under the hood, and you’ll find that WuXi Biologics (2269.HK) isn’t just playing the long game—they’re redefining it. They’ve clinched not one, but two prestigious honors from the Hong Kong ESG Reporting Awards (HERA). And with sustainability in the hot seat worldwide, these wins are no small potatoes. They...

Continue Reading
Baidu Faces Fraud Allegations: What Investors Should Know

Updated Category News Views 108

Trouble on the Horizon for Baidu Shareholders If you've got a pulse in the world of stock trading, you've likely caught wind of the storm brewing over at Baidu, Inc. (NASDAQ: BIDU). We're talking some heavy-duty allegations of securities fraud, and a class action lawsuit that's got investors scrutinizing their portfolios like never before. The lawsuit's been filed in the...

Continue Reading
Saudi Tourism Steals the Spotlight at WTM London 2026

Updated Category News Views 67

A Glimpse into Saudi's Ambitious Tourism Drive Ever feel like someone just decided to dominate the conversation at a global pow-wow? Well, that's the vibe Saudi Arabia brought to the World Travel Market (WTM) in London for 2026. With His Excellency Ahmed Al-Khateeb making headlines together with a mighty entourage of 37 tourism partners, the message was clear: Saudi...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Quimbaya Gold Elevates Financing Offer to $12.5 Million

Updated Category News Views 175

Quimbaya Gold's Strategic Financing Update Quimbaya Gold Inc. (CSE: QIM) has recently taken a bold step, amplifying its bought deal financing to a remarkable $12.5 million. This decision comes in response to significant investor demand, showcasing the market's confidence in Quimbaya's prospects. The company has partnered with Stifel Canada, which will serve as the sole...

Continue Reading
Doehler Dry Ingredient Solutions Issues Recall for Fruit Packs

Updated Category News Views 259

Doehler Dry Ingredient Solutions, LLC's Recall Announcement Doehler Dry Ingredient Solutions, LLC has announced the recall of the Member's Mark Freeze Dried Fruit Variety Pack. This recall involves the 15 count boxes, UPC 1 93968 50900 2, which were distributed to various retail locations, making them a concern for many consumers. This action is being taken due to...

Continue Reading
Archbishop Sample's Call to Embrace the Sanctity of Life

Updated Category News Views 263

Archbishop Sample's Pastoral Teaching on Life In a heartfelt response to recent proclamations regarding abortion, Archbishop Alexander K. Sample has issued a Pastoral Teaching that reverberates with compassion and commitment to the sanctity of life. His powerful message emerges against a backdrop of growing cultural acceptance of practices that he perceives as detrimental...

Continue Reading
Velo & McLaren Fuel Fan Passion Beyond the Pit

Updated Category News Views 28

Driving Fans Closer to the Fast Lane Right out of the gate, Velo and McLaren are pulling drama off the tarmac, turning F1 into a full-throttle affair of the heart. They've relaunched the 'Live Your Fandom' initiative, reminding us that being a fan isn't just about belting cheers from the bleachers. It's an art of living. They want supporters electrified, shouting their...

Continue Reading
Interra Copper Corp. Launches Drilling at RIP Project

Updated Category News Views 68

Interra Copper Begins Phase One Drilling Program Interra Copper Corp. has officially kicked off its Phase One drilling initiative at the RIP Copper Project, located in the Stikine region of British Columbia. This project signifies an exciting opportunity for the company, as it stands around 33 kilometers northeast of a previously operating copper-molybdenum mine. The...

Continue Reading