DC Circuit Orders Supplemental Briefing in Federal

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
CherylShuman

DC Circuit Orders Supplemental Briefing in Federal Landmark Medical Marijuana Case

October 17th, 2012 
Posted by Joe Elford

Just hours after the U.S. Court of Appeal for the D.C. Circuit heard  oral arguments in the federal landmark case  Americans for Safe Access v. Drug Enforcement Administration ,  the court ordered supplemental briefing on the issue of “standing.” In a rare move for a case that has been covered by the Associated Press ,  Reuters ,  CNN ,  Bloomberg News ,  Los Angeles Times ,  San Francisco Chronicle ,  Huffington Post , and others, the request for additional briefing indicates that the court is taking the issue of medical marijuana very seriously.

Yesterday’s  order asks the petitioners to provide the court with details about how plaintiff Michael Krawitz, a U.S. Air Force veteran, sustained harm as a result of the federal government’s refusal to recognize the therapeutic value of marijuana. During yesterday’s oral arguments, Americans for Safe Access (ASA) Chief Counsel Joe Elford argued that Krawitz had been denied medical services and treatment from Veterans Administration physicians because of his status as a medical marijuana patient.

Specifically, the court ordered ASA to file a brief not to exceed five pages in order to “clarify and amplify the assertions made [by] Michael Krawitz regarding his individual standing,” and “more fully explain precisely the nature of the injury that gives him standing.” The brief is due by Monday.

If ASA can reasonably show that Krawitz has been harmed by a federal policy that holds marijuana has no medical value, the country’s largest medical marijuana advocacy group may also get the court to rule on the merits of the case — whether the scientific evidence of medical efficacy is ample enough to reclassify marijuana from its current status as a Schedule I substance.

We remain hopeful that the science on medical marijuana will prevail over politics in order to overcome the decades-long effort by the federal government to keep marijuana out of the reach of millions of Americans who would benefit from its use.

ShareThis

10 Responses to “DC Circuit Orders Supplemental Briefing in Federal Landmark Medical Marijuana Case”

  1. Delightful Dabber Says: 

    Great job guys. I feel this would be a great time to bring up the federal government’s own medical pot program in Mississippi. The law and this federal program contradict. I feel the brief should have at least one sentence devoted to this matter.

  2. Mel mower Says: 

    SCIENCE OVER POLITICS! BAM

  3. jeanna prell Says: 

    This seems ominous to me. It seems they are demanding proof that, in their minds cannot be proved, ie a Vet who claims discrimination, but can’t be verified because of the rules. Look out for Catch 22, the Government(Corporate Lawyers) are excellent at this type of deception.

  4. Joe Says: 

    After the votes that come in on the 7th showing overwhelming support for anything to do with medical marijuana or even full llegalization in most states maybe they will start to understand.

  5. Charles Strout Says: 

    The DEA argues that medical marijuana is a drug of abuse. But the same is true for tobacco, alcohol, legal pharmaceutical shelved, and non-shelved drugs listed as Schedule 2 so they can be utilized in treatment by physicians as required. The DEA’s concern to override the legitimate need of millions of suffering patients for relief of their medical symptoms that marijuana can provide, described throughly in their own US Fed Gov’t Patent #6630507 is completelly specious, and without any validation of evidence. Millions of suffering medical patients are legally effectively benefiting therapeutically utilizing medical marijuana as their medicine. It appears the arguments of the DEA would rather prescribe a jail cell, and refer to those suffering patients as criminals, and prisoners instead, benefiting absoutely nobody, except the profiteers of the power structure, and the Big-Pharmaceutical Companies.

  6. claygooding Says: 

    Wouldn’t the 3000 year old Chinese medical scrolls give historical proof of medical applications and couldn’t the plaintiff use Judge Young’s ruling as a useful tool for proof of the DEA’s arbitrary refusal to re-schedule marijuana since 1988?

  7. ron Says: 

    How about the US Government patent on Cannabinoids? I would think this can be use in this case.

    Cannabinoids have been found to have antioxidant properties, unrelated to NMDA receptor antagonism. This new found property makes cannabinoids useful in the treatment and prophylaxis of wide variety of oxidation associated diseases, such as ischemic, age-related, inflammatory and autoimmune diseases. The cannabinoids are found to have particular application as neuroprotectants, for example in limiting neurological damage following ischemic insults, such as stroke and trauma, or in the treatment of neurodegenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer’s disease, Parkinson’s disease and HIV dementia. Nonpsychoactive cannabinoids, such as cannabidoil, are particularly advantageous to use because they avoid toxicity that is encountered with psychoactive cannabinoids at high doses useful in the method of the present invention. A particular disclosed class of cannabinoids useful as neuroprotective antioxidants.

  8. Correct Me If I'm Wrong Says: 

    I’m re-posting this from an earlier story…glad to hear that this may actually be getting fair consideration. I just want to make sure I understand exactly what this means…I can be rather dense sometimes <img src= " /> This case is an “appeal” to have the courts force the DEA to take another look at their classifying MMJ in Schedule I, right? Does this mean that the DEA can simply find another way (i.e. word differently) yet another rejection? What exactly can these 3 judges do, in terms of actual, measurable change? It concerned me a bit when one of the judges asked whether or not THEY needed to listen to the “agency”…citing the fact that they were scientists and the judges were not. Help me out here. Where can a favorable ruling actually go??

  9. Rick Steeb Says: 

    In order to have “standing” we must describe the nature of our injury– How about starting with the constant low-grade terror that comes with the knowledge that the feds can legally come and take us away? How about the atrocities perpetrated against our providers? The black market prices of our medicine? The denial of “Equal Protection” with Elvy and Irvin?

    I have to commit a “federal crime” to maintain my intraoccular pressures at safe levels, even with my use of two prescription eye drops. That adds insult to injury. That is utterly unacceptable.

  10. claygooding Says: 

    Rick,please add the terror of being locked up in a jail,where medical treatment is non-existent for inmates.

    Example:

    Wash. inmate with dairy allergy dies after eating oatmeal

    http://www.katu.com/news/local/174446621.html

Rapid Fire Marketing, Inc. (RFMK) Stock Research Links

RFMK Board Company Profile Buy Rating Time & Sales News Filings Financials
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Stanford Forum Puts Industrial AI in the Real World

Updated Category News Views 166

Factory Data Is Not a Free Lunch A factory dataset is worth precisely nothing if its owner cannot control it. That was the hard-nosed thread running through the ASI City Forum at Stanford on November 17: industrial AI is not just about smarter models or splashy chip announcements. It is about whether manufacturers will trust a system with proprietary operating data,...

Continue Reading
Rox Taps Dynamics 365 Without Forcing a CRM Reset Yet

Updated Category News Views 129

Enterprise software buyers hate renovations when a useful extension will do. Rox’s new integration with Microsoft Dynamics 365 Sales, announced November 19, 2026, is built around that unglamorous but very real fact. The company is not asking a Global 2000 sales organization to rip out its customer system, retrain everybody, and pray an AI layer somehow pays for the...

Continue Reading
Carbonization Furnaces Turn Waste Rules Into Demand

Updated Category News Views 112

Smoke has become an expensive habit for farmers, mills, and municipalities. That is the real commercial backdrop for carbonization furnaces, not some glossy green-tech slogan. MarketsandMarkets estimates this small global equipment market at $310 million in 2026 and projects $510 million by 2031, a 10.2% compound annual growth rate. For a capital-equipment niche, that is...

Continue Reading
Software-Defined Cars Put $310 Billion in Play by 2035

Updated Category News Views 111

Cars are becoming rolling computers, and that changes who gets paid. Market Growth Reports projects the software-defined vehicle market will rise from $56.94 billion to $310.46 billion by 2035, a 20.74% compound annual growth rate. That is a loud number, no question. Still, investors ought to treat any long-range market forecast like a map, not a mortgage deed. The...

Continue Reading
NYSE Message Record Puts Market Plumbing Into Focus

Updated Category News Views 120

A trillion messages is not a cute little exchange statistic; it is the sort of number that tells you whether the market’s pipes can keep working when everybody starts shouting at once. NYSE says it handled a record 1.166 trillion messages in one day on November 5, roughly 4% above the prior high set amid April 2025 volatility. Better yet, according to the exchange,...

Continue Reading
Minno Bets on Listener Kids to Build Premium Growth

Updated Category News Views 131

Children’s media rarely gets a clean strategic move, but this one comes pretty close. Minno has signed a worldwide, multi-year agreement making it the exclusive faith-based streaming home for Listener Kids’ video library, while commissioning 66 new episodes for its own service. For a company trying to build a serious Christian family-media business, that is more than...

Continue Reading
Blast Doubles Athabasca Ground, but Drills Still Matter

Updated Category News Views 75

More ground in Athabasca can wake up a uranium junior fast, and Blast Resources has certainly grabbed investors’ attention with this one. The company has optioned eight additional uranium claims beside its Wales Lake property in northern Saskatchewan, taking its regional footprint from 12,150 hectares across 16 claims to 30,732 hectares across 24 claims. That is more...

Continue Reading
Ajman Media Forum Puts Trust Ahead of AI Speed in 2026

Updated Category News Views 199

Algorithms may manufacture a flood of words, but they cannot inherit accountability. That was the sensible nerve running through Ajman Media Forum 2026, “The Signal,” inaugurated on November 19 by His Highness Sheikh Ammar bin Humaid Al Nuaimi, Crown Prince of Ajman and Chairman of the Executive Council. For all the fanfare that usually surrounds artificial...

Continue Reading
Trip.com Sets December 1 Date for Third-Quarter Results

Updated Category News Views 122

December’s first after-hours session will put Trip.com Group back under the market’s microscope, whether anybody is ready or not. The company says it will report results for the three months ended September 30, 2026 after the U.S. market closes on Tuesday, December 1. That is the whole hard-news payload for now: a reporting date, a call time, and no numbers to get...

Continue Reading
Live Nation Tests Creator Content With Morgan Jay Series

Updated Category News Views 157

A comedian turning crowd work into songs is hardly a boardroom event, but this one has a useful wrinkle: Live Nation Studios put financing behind it. Morgan Jay and Austin-based agency Hello Party launched Music Therapy with Morgan Jay on YouTube on November 18, with Kam Patterson opening the season. The show pairs Jay and celebrity guests for loose conversation,...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Innovative AI Tools Revolutionizing Family Medicine Screening

Updated Category News Views 120

Innovative AI Tools Revolutionizing Family Medicine Screening Recent studies illustrate the integration of AI in detecting health issues within family medicine Research published in Annals of Family Medicine delves into how artificial intelligence and digital applications such as tablets are enhancing the detection of significant health conditions like dementia, heart...

Continue Reading
Infortar's Strategic Share Buyback on Nasdaq Tallinn

Updated Category News Views 168

Infortar's Share Buyback Strategy Aktsiaselts Infortar has taken a strategic step by acquiring its own shares on the Nasdaq Tallinn Stock Exchange during the early November period. This initiative reflects the company’s commitment to enhancing shareholder value and maintaining a robust market presence. Details of the Share Acquisition During the acquisition phase from...

Continue Reading
Garmin Ltd. Announces Upcoming Earnings Call for Investors

Updated Category News Views 41

Garmin Ltd. Schedules Third Quarter Earnings Call Garmin Ltd. (NYSE: GRMN) is preparing for its third quarter earnings conference call, inviting all shareholders and interested parties to join. The call is an important event where executives will discuss recent business performance and future strategies. It will take place on a Wednesday at 10:30 a.m. EDT, coinciding with...

Continue Reading
BMC Medical Co., Ltd. Celebrates New France Office Opening

Updated Category News Views 152

Exciting Times for BMC Medical Co., Ltd. with New Office Opening BMC Medical Co., Ltd. has recently marked an important milestone with the launch of its new office. This occasion not only establishes a foothold in the local area but also demonstrates the company's commitment to improving healthcare services throughout Europe. A Grand Opening Ceremony Celebrating Growth...

Continue Reading
TGH Burn Center Enhances Care Through TECO Partnership

Updated Category News Views 202

Transforming Burn Care at TGH Burn Center The TGH Burn Center, previously known as Tampa General Hospital's Burn Center, has entered into an exciting partnership with TECO that aims to significantly enhance patient care. This collaboration focuses on innovative treatment and state-of-the-art technology to ensure that those suffering from burn injuries receive the best...

Continue Reading