$FNMA and $FMCC 2/21/2014 @ 12:09PM |1,827

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board
fitzkarz
$FNMA and $FMCC
2/21/2014 @ 12:09PM | 1,827 views

With Fannie and Freddie Debt Repaid to Taxpayers, Will Uncle Sam Turn Shareholders Into Zombie Investors?

Five years after the government bailed out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac by covering their combined $187.5 billion debt, taxpayers are poised to be made whole—and record profits are set to stream in as far as the eye can see. But in an odd twist, the government may be poised to commit what some critics say could result in the largest securities fraud in history.

Fannie Mae today reported an annual profit of $84 billion for $2013. Under the terms of the 2008 rescue, all of the profits will be sent to the Treasury. Fannie’s smaller rival, Freddie Mac is also set to confirm its astounding rebound next week It’s a surprising turn of events and a windfall for the government—but a looming potential disaster for shareholders who may lose billions for standing by the beleaguered organizations as the housing market seized during the Great Recession.FM-FM

The two government-sponsored entities (GSEs), which own or guarantee a massive proportion of all home loans in the United States, were on the verge of collapse when the housing market buckled at the height of the financial crisis, prompting the government to put them into conservatorship, an alternative to liquidation that was supposed to protect both taxpayers and shareholders. Now, with the Treasury set to recoup its entire investment and then some, one would expect that the firms would be ready to exit government control and begin repaying their beleaguered investors—more than 21,000 of them. But in a bizarre turn in the Fannie and Freddie saga, the near record windfall is for now mostly symbolic. The government reengineered the original agreement to require the GSEs to send all their profits to the Treasury in perpetuity, meaning they can never exit government control.

Even stranger, an explosive government document has emerged that suggests that the Obama Administration appears determined to liquidate most or all of their investments, and Congress stands by with proposals that only codify the Administration’s derelict —committing what an ‘odd fellows’ coalition of über-liberals, shareholder activists and hedge fund managers say could be the largest securities fraud in the history of the United States.

What’s the story behind the government’s apparent securities fraud?

The burgeoning scandal swirls around what appear to be backroom policy decisions made in 2010, just as the housing market showed signs of recovery and the ink turned from black to red on Fannie and Freddie’s books.

While the government was publicly encouraging shareholders to hang on, officials at Treasury, backed by the Administration, quietly changed policy, hatching a plan to bankrupt them, including new investors who came on board after the crash at the Government’s wooing. According to an internal memo addressed to the Treasury secretary from Jeffrey A. Goldstein, then the under secretary for domestic finance, “the administration’s commitment to ensure existing common equity holders will not have access to any positive earnings from the GSEs in the future.”

The memo, which was produced in a lawsuit filed by Fannie and Freddie shareholders, was dated Dec. 20, 2010 and was made public at a shareholder’s rights forum held earlier this month in Washington. It puts controversial meat on the bone of a more ambiguous statement in Fannie Mae’s annual report: “[W]e are no longer managed with a strategy to maximize shareholder returns” and “every dollar of earnings that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac generate will be used to benefit taxpayers for their investment in those firms.”

As New York Times ’ business columnist Gretchen Morgensen summarized in a scathing piece last Sunday, two GSEs were not made aware of the new policy that essentially deprived them of future earnings. That appears to be in conflict with securities laws that require the disclosure of any “material” information that might affect an investor’s view of a company. In other words, federal officials were conspiring—that’s a word pregnant with implications but fair in this context—to treat shareholders more like characters in “Night of the Living Dead” than investors helping to keep a fragile agency afloat.

Did the government commit securities fraud? According to James Cummins, a leading securities lawyer who has litigated against Fannie and Freddie since 2004 on various issues, such a sharp switch in policy is “material information because it was going to tell people who might want to buy stock, ‘Hey, by the way, you’re not going to get any dividends and all of the earnings of the company are going to U.S. Treasury.’”

Who are these investors? They include hedge funds like Perry Capital and Pershing Square, but also thousands of other shareholders, including employees, pensioners, 401K funds, mutual funds and small banks, as well as individual shareholders. Among them are shareholder rights groups, including well-known consumer activist Ralph Nader.

Some of these shareholders are long term investors, who saw the stock plummet to pennies on the dollar, while others are funds that took recent but highly risky positions in hopes of benefiting from Fannie’s and Freddie’s recovery. Billions of dollars is at stake.

Fannie Mae's Stock Chart; $69.49 2007 high

Fannie Mae’s Stock Chart; $69.49 2007 high

The litigants, including Nader, point to the government’s guarantee that it would “preserve and conserve the assets and property” of each entity. But the internal government document suggests that federal officials were doing anything but. Over the past two years they’ve siphoned off the profits of the GSEs and sent the money to the general treasury instead of repaying Treasury and taxpayers

The litigants seek no damages nor do they want to short the government’s appropriate windfall for the unanticipated market rebound. “Shareholders are not arguing that taxpayers should not be repaid,” writes Nader in a letter sent earlier this week to Treasury Secretary Jacob Lew. “This is not at issue. Taxpayers should recoup their investment in the GSEs; but the Administration does not have to wipe out shareholders for this to happen.” Nader and other shareholders are asking the government to bide by the 2008 law, rather than what appears to be an internally hatched 2010 policy shift –another quiet form of regulatory overreach

Will potential homeowners become collateral damage in Fannie/Freddie wrangle?

I'm in it to win it!

NASDAQ DIP and RIP
Here is the best word that describes what i do here.
Intuitive;
means having the ability to understand or know something without any direct evidence or reasoning process.

I was born with it, I'm truly blessed!


Alway's searching for winners'
937206596_images.jpg
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Knotch Bets Brands Need Answers, Not More Web Pages

Updated Category News Views 184

Pages are starting to look like expensive filing cabinets A website that cannot answer an agent may soon be expensive wallpaper. That is the blunt premise behind Knotch's Ace for Agents, launched Nov. 17, 2026, and frankly it lands because plenty of big companies have spent years piling pages atop pages until nobody can tell which claim is current. Knotch is pitching an...

Continue Reading
Voranigo Follow-Up Deepens the Glioma Care Debate Today

Updated Category News Views 159

Brain-tumor progress rarely arrives with a clean victory lap, but the longer INDIGO readout gives clinicians and sector watchers something sturdier than a one-time headline. Servier presented extended Phase 3 results for VORANIGO, or vorasidenib, at the Society for Neuro-Oncology meeting in Philadelphia on November 14 and 15, 2026. The central message is durable benefit...

Continue Reading
Airtel Money Upgrade Raises the Stakes in East Africa

Updated Category News Views 0

Mobile money lives or dies in the irritating little moments: a transfer that hangs, a menu that makes people punch five buttons too many, a merchant payment that simply will not clear. Airtel Money is attacking that friction in Malawi and Tanzania with an enhanced platform from Comviva, and this is more consequential than the usual software-refresh chest thumping. In...

Continue Reading
Caracal’s $200K VMI Pledge Targets Cadet Affordability

Updated Category News Views 197

A tuition award can still leave a brutal hole in the budget. That is the plain fact sitting underneath Caracal Products & Services’ $200,000 commitment to Virginia Military Institute. Federal ROTC scholarships can cover tuition, but VMI says room, board and quartermaster fees average about $15,000 annually. For a student who has done everything right—earned the ROTC...

Continue Reading
Max y Noelia Explore Trade at 9th CIIE in Shanghai

Updated Category News Views 126

Influencers at the Heart of Global Trade Exploration Makin' their debut on the big stage of the 9th China International Import Expo (CIIE), Mexican influencers Max y Noelia found themselves caught in a whirlwind of trade and cultural exchanges over in Shanghai. These digital mavens aren't just snapping selfies. Nope, they're capturing the very essence of international...

Continue Reading
Vusion's 2030 Plan Puts Recurring Revenue First At Scale

Updated Category News Views 20

Shelf labels are not exactly romance, yet Vusion has turned them into a serious growth machine. The 2030 plan is not really about hanging more electronic displays in aisles; it is about making those displays, sensors and store connections produce software and service revenue for years. That is the part of this story worth watching. The Hardware Base Is Becoming the Hook...

Continue Reading
Tim Hortons Bets on ELF Cheer for U.S. Holiday Visits

Updated Category News Views 0

Nothing says holiday restaurant marketing quite like putting spaghetti-shaped whipped topping on hot chocolate and trusting a 2003 movie to do the selling. Tim Hortons is rolling out an ELF-inspired menu at participating U.S. locations starting November 18, 2026, pairing the chain with Warner Bros. Consumer Products and mining Buddy the Elf's sugar-fueled world for a...

Continue Reading
Unisys Opens Its 2027 Innovation Program Across India

Updated Category News Views 147

Talent pipelines rarely make the market’s pulse race, but they can expose whether a tech firm is still trying to build for the next turn. Unisys has opened registration for the 2027 Unisys Innovation Program, its eighteenth annual technical competition for engineering students in India. For a company selling cloud, AI, digital workplace, applications and enterprise...

Continue Reading
Sectra's RSNA AI Pitch Centers on Workflow, Not Hype

Updated Category News Views 95

Radiology has heard enough grand AI promises to fill a hospital basement, which makes Sectra's RSNA 2026 message refreshingly grounded. The Swedish imaging IT and cybersecurity company is putting its weight behind the unglamorous part of adoption: fitting AI into the daily diagnostic machinery without handing clinicians another awkward system to babysit. That is where...

Continue Reading
Markel Elevates War Risk Expertise in London Market

Updated Category News Views 67

A Specialty Desk Gets Its Own Weather Vane War and political violence underwriting is not a corner of insurance where a fancy title change can be shrugged off. The ground shifts under the policyholder, the broker and the carrier without much warning, and a bad call can sit on a book for years. Markel Insurance has named Chloe Gordge Director of War and Political Violence...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Aterian Prepares for Upcoming Earnings Call This Quarter

Updated Category News Views 141

Aterian's Upcoming Financial Results Announcement Aterian, Inc. (Nasdaq: ATER), a prominent player in the consumer products sector, is gearing up to reveal its financial performance for the second quarter. Scheduled for Wednesday in the coming week, this announcement will take place after market closure, providing investors with valuable insights into the company’s...

Continue Reading
Updated Disclosure Insights for Balanced Commercial Property Trust

Updated Category News Views 70

Understanding the Recent Disclosure from Rathbones Group Plc Regarding Balanced Commercial Property Trust Limited This article offers a crucial overview of the recent disclosure made by Rathbones Group Plc about its interests in Balanced Commercial Property Trust Limited. Grasping these disclosures is essential for investors who want to effectively maneuver through the...

Continue Reading
TerraVolta Resources Secures Major Funding for Lithium Project

Updated Category News Views 219

TerraVolta Resources Lands Major Funding for Lithium Initiative Exciting developments are unfolding in the critical minerals sector as TerraVolta Resources, LLC, a key player in this field, has been chosen to negotiate a substantial $225 million funding award from the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE). This funding is set to support the establishment of a groundbreaking...

Continue Reading
Shining Moments of Natural Diamonds at the Golden Globes

Updated Category News Views 142

Shining Moments of Natural Diamonds at the Golden Globes This year's Golden Globes red carpet was captivating, showcasing natural diamonds that enchanted audiences and attendees alike. Rather than adhering to the conventional white diamond look, celebrities embraced a vibrant palette of colored diamonds. This trend was not just about sparkle but deeply reflected...

Continue Reading
iQIYI Plans Major Offering of Convertible Senior Notes

Updated Category News Views 122

iQIYI Plans a Significant Offering of Convertible Senior Notes iQIYI, Inc. (Nasdaq: IQ) is making headlines with its recent announcement regarding a substantial offering. The company plans to issue $300 million in convertible senior notes, reflecting its ongoing commitment to strengthen its financial position and enhance shareholder value. Details of the Convertible...

Continue Reading