How Obamacare Raids the Assets of Low- Income Older

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
SaltyMutt
How Obamacare Raids the Assets of Low- Income Older Americans

By Yves Smith
February 11, 2014

One feature of Obamacare that Lambert has mentioned in passing in his posts is that individuals over 55 who are enrolled in Medicaid are subject to having expenses like being in a long-term care facility, home services, and related drugs and prescriptions clawed back from their estates. A must read post at Paul Craig Roberts details how pernicious and sneaky these provisions are.

The pilfering of assets of low-income Americans results from the interaction of several nasty features, and the article contends none of these were an accident (as in objections were made when the Affordable Care Act was being drafted and were ignored).

The estate recovery feature of Medicaid is pre-existing, from the Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1993. But it didn’t seem to have much practical effect when it was added because Medicaid had an assets test which meant that people with meaningful assets were not eligible. As the article explains:

OBRA 1993 requires all states that receive Medicaid funding to seek recovery from the estates of deceased Medicaid patients for medical services received in a nursing home or other long-term care institution, home- and community-based services and related hospital and prescription drug services regardless of age. It also allows, at state option, recovery for all services used in the Medicaid state plan at age 55 or older. At minimum, states must pursue recovery from the probate estate which includes property that passes to heirs under state probate law, but states can expand the definition of estate to allow recovery from property that bypasses probate. This means states can use procedures for direct recovery from bank accounts and other funds. The state keeps a running tally, and even if you have a will, your heirs are chopped liver. Estate recovery can be exempted or deferred in certain situations after your death, but the regulations for this are limited and complicated with multitudes of conditions.

Now consider the ACA changes. First is that Obamacare expanded Medicaid eligibility. The ACA ended the asset test.

Second is that enrollment in Medicaid is now mandatory. If you or your family make less that 138% of the Federal poverty level, which in the 48 states and Washington DC would be $16,105 for an individual and $32,913 for a family of four in 2014 you are enrolled unless you fit in a short list of categories, such as being in jail, being in a state that opted out of Medicaid expansion, or being a member of an Indian tribe. You cannot opt out of Medicaid because you object to the estate recovery. You have to pay the penalty if you want out. And there are many routes by which you can become enrolled: by applying on an exchange and having it determine your income is too low to qualify for private insurance; by being in the SNAP (food stamps) database; by having an Obamacare plan but having a fall in income that puts you in the Medicaid category.

So if you have low income (by virtue of unintended early retirement, or even bad performance on your investment portfolio) but a decent level of assets, you can be caught in these provisions and have assets you had hoped to leave to family members instead taken by the government. And before you try arguing that that’s somehow fair, consider that the estate tax exemption is now $5.34 million. As the article points out:

Some might think it fair that those who are enrolled in Medicaid pay back the benefits they received. However, under a mandate that requires all Americans to be covered by health insurance or pay a tax penalty to the IRS, estate recovery is unconscionable since Obamacare offers no other viable option for this income-segment of the population. It also discriminates by age since only Medicaid enrollees who use benefits in the state plan at age 55 and up are subject to estate recovery, but those who use benefits at age 54 or less are home free unless they receive long-term care. Under federal law , discrimination is not permitted on the basis of age, but, obviously, the U.S. government turns a blind eye to to its own law. Perhaps, when states need more money due to the Obamacare expansion of Medicaid, and as the jobless economy continues causing more people to be eligible, age discrimination will be broadened to 45 and up.

But one of the most troubling elements is the lack of adequate disclosure about the estate clawback. Again from the article:

In June 2013 a letter was sent to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services by a well-informed citizen pointing out that the Medicaid Manual prepared by CMS to provide guidance for states contains procedural rules intended to ensure that individuals are informed about estate recovery before they complete the application process.

There are variations in the ways in which states implement estate recovery, depending upon their Medicaid program and state laws . However, Federal law requires all states to incorporate the following protections for Medicaid recipients into the design of their estate recovery program:

— The State should notify Medicaid recipients about the estate recovery program during their initial application for Medicaid eligibility and annual re-determination process.

— The State must notify affected survivors about the initiation of estate recovery and give them an opportunity to claim an exemption based on hardship.

— The State must establish procedures and criteria to waive recovery if it would cause undue hardship.

The letter went on to say that the final CMS Health Insurance Marketplace application (healthcare.gov) notifies applicants about Medicaid’s right to pursue and recover any money from other health insurance, legal settlements or other third parties but does not disclose estate recovery. Since estate recovery is one of the terms of the Medicaid contract, it is deceptive to omit disclosure of this practice. CMS was asked to provide the reasons for this omission.

CMS responded evasively to the concerned citizen’s question. CMS claimed that the Health Insurance Marketplace application at healthcare.gov does not disclose Medicaid’s right to claim against the estate, because CMS wanted to provide flexibility to state Medicaid agencies as to how each one notifies applicants about estate recovery. Some states have developed pamphlets to address common estate recovery questions or devote a portion of a general Medicaid pamphlet to the subject. Some states also post their state plans, perhaps with additional explanatory text, on their web sites.

You can see the Catch-22 here. CMS puts the onus on states to make the notification, but people in the states that refused to set up exchanges apply through healthcare.gov. So consider this:

When you complete the application at healthcare.gov, it is assumed that when you submit it, you are fully informed and agree to all terms. Submission of the application is akin to signing a contract. Your signature not only means you have provided true answers to all the questions under penalty of perjury, but also that you understand and agree to all the rules and conditions. However, by not disclosing estate recovery CMS expunged your right to make an informed decision. Therefore, you may not realize that your estate can become government property because Obamacare forces you into Medicaid if your income is less than the threshold for a subsidized premium.

And here’s more state/Federal Catch-22:

Note that Obamacare applications contain a section titled Renewal of Coverage in Future Years. An applicant can agree to allow an exchange to use income data, including information from tax returns to automatically renew eligibility for 1, 2, 3, 4 or 5 years, or applicants can check “Do not use information from tax returns to renew my coverage.” Exchanges have access to the federal data hub which keeps track of your income and other personal data. If you gave unfettered access to your data by choosing auto-renewal, they have all the information needed to determine whether you are still eligible for your subsidized policy or should be moved into Medicaid.

The letter sent to CMS in June 2013 also asked about estate recovery disclosure in cases where coverage is auto-renewed during the annual redetermination process, when people are shifted from a subsidized plan to Medicaid due to a decrease in income or other change in circumstance, and when people are auto-enrolled on the presumption that they are eligible according to a database such as SNAP (food stamps) or by a hospital or health care center. A similar letter was sent to the Massachusetts Office of Medicaid.

The federal procedural rules on estate recovery say the state should notify Medicaid recipients about the estate recovery program during the annual redetermination process, but according to the Massachusetts Office of Medicaid, you don’t need to be informed about estate recovery during the redetermination process because you presumably read about this on the original application you filled out and submitted.

If you submitted an application that did not disclose estate recovery, it cannot be presumed that you are aware of estate recovery, because notification was not on the application. Thus, the redetermination procedure is one more example of the failure to disclose.

If you are bumped into Medicaid from a subsidized plan due to a change in your circumstances, the Massachusetts Office of Medicaid believes that you don’t need to be informed about estate recovery because you presumably read about this however many years ago when you filled out the original application. You will simply be sent a notice that you are now in Medicaid, and the notice will refer you to the Medicaid Member Booklet for information on the rules. If you obtain and read the booklet, you can learn that you may be subject to estate recovery. But don’t expect to receive a Medicaid Member Booklet with your notice, because “It would be cost prohibitive to include a Member Booklet with every notice. Instead, every notice includes information on how to contact Customer Service with any questions, including to request a copy of the Member Booklet.”

If these issues may be important to you or anyone in your family, I strongly urge you to read the post in full (
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

IT Tech Packaging's Going-Concern Warning Lands Hard

Updated Category News Views 55

A paper maker can survive plenty of ugly quarters; it cannot casually shrug off an auditor questioning whether it can keep operating. That is the cold part of IT Tech Packaging's Nov. 19 disclosure. Its newly filed Form 10-K for the year ended Dec. 31, 2025 carries a “Material Uncertainty Related to Going Concern” paragraph from Audit Alliance LLP. Nobody should dress...

Continue Reading
MemorialCare Adds AI Guardrails for Hidden Aneurysms

Updated Category News Views 73

A brain scan ordered for one reason can suddenly expose a risk nobody knew was sitting there. That is the sober promise behind MemorialCare Neuroscience Institute's rollout of Rapid Aneurysm, an artificial-intelligence tool embedded in qualifying CTA and MRA brain scans across its inpatient and outpatient network. MemorialCare says it is the first health system in Los...

Continue Reading
ATRenew's Q3 Profit Jump Meets a Cash Balance Test

Updated Category News Views 105

Used phones do not make for glamorous investing, but this quarter has some real muscle behind it. ATRenew turned a 25.3% revenue gain into a 57.9% jump in operating income for the three months ended September 30, and that is the sort of operating leverage I want to see before getting carried away with a circular-economy story. Margins Finally Move in the Right Direction...

Continue Reading
First Horizon Opens Its Charlotte Office in South End

Updated Category News Views 79

A Building Is Not a Balance Sheet Charlotte got a fresh First Horizon sign at 110 East Boulevard on Nov. 19, 2026, and that is a sensible move, not a magic trick. The bank has officially opened a corporate office in the city’s South End neighborhood, positioning the team to develop client relationships across the Charlotte area and broaden its regional footprint. That...

Continue Reading
PepsiCo Locks In Hyatt's 700-Property U.S. Supply Deal

Updated Category News Views 76

A hotel minibar is a lousy place to hunt for glamour, but it is a terrific place to spot durable distribution. PepsiCo has renewed its U.S. food and beverage relationship with Hyatt for 10 years, covering more than 700 properties. Nobody should pretend a hotel contract transforms a company with nearly $94 billion in 2025 revenue. Still, this is the sort of unflashy...

Continue Reading
PostalAnnex Adds Roseville Store as Owners Reach Three

Updated Category News Views 97

A third storefront from the same operators says more than a ribbon-cutting ever will. Aarondeep Hira and Manraj Sangha have opened a PostalAnnex in Roseville, California, their third Sacramento-area location after earlier operations in Sacramento and Antelope. For a franchise system, repeat ownership is the part worth noticing. It is not a guarantee of booming sales, and...

Continue Reading
Genome-Written XDP Mice Could Sharpen Drug Research

Updated Category News Views 60

Seventy-eight thousand DNA letters changed the pace of a cruel little-known disease story. NYU Langone researchers inserted a human disease-linked stretch of genetic material into mice and produced an accelerated model of X-linked dystonia-parkinsonism, or XDP. That is a serious laboratory accomplishment, not a cure announcement, and it deserves to be read with both...

Continue Reading
Makers Nutrition Backs Families Through Friends of Karen

Updated Category News Views 60

A thousand dollars in gift cards can look modest beside the noise of holiday marketing, but it lands differently when a family is carrying the weight of a child’s life-threatening illness. Makers Nutrition, a Hauppauge, New York-based private-label and custom supplement manufacturer, has donated $1,000 in gift cards to Friends of Karen for the nonprofit’s annual...

Continue Reading
Dario's WebMD Deal Opens a Vast, Unproven Channel Path

Updated Category News Views 122

One partnership can look like a gold mine from across the valley; getting the ore out is another matter entirely. DarioHealth has struck a strategic partnership with WebMD Health Services that could put its multi-condition care platform in front of an enormous commercial ecosystem: more than 3,500 employers and 65 million covered lives. That is a meaningful distribution...

Continue Reading
JDEnergy's RE+ Push Meets a Grid Hungry for Storage

Updated Category News Views 64

Certification Is Useful, Not a Victory Lap A battery box earning a safety certificate is not usually thrilling stuff, but the timing matters here. On Nov. 19, 2026, JDEnergy laid out its North American storage pitch at RE+ in Las Vegas while electricity demand is getting shoved higher by industrial buildout and AI data centers. Add more variable renewable generation to an...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Itaú Unibanco Financial Results and Upcoming Session Insights

Updated Category News Views 342

Itaú Unibanco's Q3 Financial Performance Overview Itaú Unibanco Holding S.A. has made a significant announcement regarding its financial performance for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2025. The condensed financial statements and management discussion analysis for the third quarter are now accessible for shareholders and the market, showcasing transparency and...

Continue Reading
XPLR Infrastructure Faces Class Action Lawsuit Amid Concerns

Updated Category News Views 186

Understanding the Class Action Against XPLR Infrastructure, LP Levi & Korsinsky, LLP has recently alerted investors of a pending class action lawsuit concerning XPLR Infrastructure, LP, formerly known as Nextera Energy Partners, LP. This significant legal action raises various concerns for investors affected by alleged securities fraud. Details of the Lawsuit The class...

Continue Reading
Elizabeth Warren Takes Stand on Sesame Street Funding Cuts

Updated Category News Views 213

Elizabeth Warren Takes a Stand Against Funding Cuts Recently, Senator Elizabeth Warren expressed deep concerns regarding a Republican initiative aimed at significantly cutting federal funding designated for public broadcasting. Her focus is primarily on programs cherished across America, such as Sesame Street and National Public Radio. Understanding the Proposal The...

Continue Reading
Generative AI: Paving the Future of Work in America

Updated Category News Views 195

The Impact of Generative AI on U.S. Workforce Management Enterprises in the United States are viewing the future of work with cautious optimism, largely influenced by the potential of generative AI (GenAI). A recent research report has shed light on how AI is transforming workplace strategies in the wake of ongoing economic fluctuations. Understanding Hybrid Work...

Continue Reading
Exploring Changes in Epilepsy Treatment Response Over Time

Updated Category News Views 145

Understanding Focal Epilepsy and Treatment Challenges Focal epilepsy is a prevalent form of epilepsy, where specific areas of the brain become excessively active, leading to a range of emotional and behavioral disturbances. Surprisingly, about one-third of patients diagnosed with this condition struggle with conventional treatment methods, often showing limited responses...

Continue Reading