Yes, we are better off than we were 4 years ago By

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board
fitzkarz

Yes, we are better off than we were 4 years ago

"Are we better off than we were four years ago?" has become the GOP mantra in the last week.

  • President Obama

    2010 photo by Manuel Balce Ceneta, AP

    President Obama

2010 photo by Manuel Balce Ceneta, AP

President Obama

Sponsored Links

Apparently, they long for the halcyon days of the 2008-09 economic meltdown. After years of telling us that it's backward looking for President Obama to remind voters of the trash heap of an economy Republicans handed him, they have suddenly begun to wax nostalgic for one of the worst economic periods in American history and can't stop asking how people felt as they watched their retirement savings disappear into thin air.

Is there a single American who would honestly say they were better off in September 2008 than today? Weirdly, there are, at least according to multiple polls.But, as some wise person once said, feelings are not facts.

Let's take a little trip down memory lane. Here is a headline from CNN on Sept. 15, 2008 : "Lehman Brothers collapse stuns global markets." Oh, the good old days of the American banking system imploding. The end of 2008 brought us also the near collapse of Merrill Lynch , AIG , Goldman Sachs and other behemoths that had to be rescued by the U.S. government. Bush Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson titled his book about this period On the Brink , fairly summing up that terrifying time in our history.

Republicans are literally telling Americans that they were better off four years ago when our economy was on the verge of complete collapse. It was the Troubled Asset Relief Program — pushed by President Bush and implemented in the first six months of the Obama administration — that stabilized our economy. In case you forgot, TARP also enraged the GOP base, spawned the Tea Party movement and is now denounced by many Republicans who voted for it, including Paul Ryan , except when they are giving George W. Bush credit for saving the financial system by passing TARP.

In the GOP's misty-water colored memories of those grand times four years ago is also the near collapse of the American auto industry. The bailout was an unmitigated success, and one that Mitt Romney vigorously opposed, saying that if it were enacted, "you can kiss the American automotive industry goodbye." Compare that with the news Tuesday in The New York Times: "Major automakers reported … that sales grew 19.9% in August despite higher gas prices during the month."

Is it better to have the auto industry on the brink of collapse or to have one with growing sales?

Then there is the employment situation four years ago. In September 2008 we lost 159,000 jobs. The month that Obama took the oath of office, January 2009, the economy lost 800,000 jobs. Are we better off losing thousands of jobs in one month or adding private-sector jobs to the economy, as we have been doing for 29 months?

What about the stock market? Reuters reported last month , "At 1,400, the S&P 500 … was closing in on a four-year high and was up 74% since Jan. 20, 2009, the day Obama took office. Not since Dwight Eisenhower 's first term has a president had such a strong run for their first term."

Former Merrill Lynch strategist Richard Bernstein told Reuters, "The stock market is a barometer not of the absolute level of the economy but of improvement in the economy. There is no doubt the economy has improved in the last four years."

USATODAY OPINION

Columns

In addition to its own editorials, USA TODAY publishes a variety of opinions from outside writers. On political and policy matters, we publish opinions from across the political spectrum.

Roughly half of our columns come from our Board of Contributors, a group whose interests range from education to religion to sports to the economy. Their charge is to chronicle American culture by telling the stories, large and small, that collectively make us what we are.

We also publish weekly columns by Al Neuharth, USA TODAY's founder, and DeWayne Wickham, who writes primarily on matters of race but on other subjects as well. That leaves plenty of room for other views from across the nation by well-known and lesser-known names alike.

Busloads of economists have testified to the positive impact of Obama's stimulus, and yet the GOP continues to claim it was a complete failure. Mark Zandi , chief economist of Moody's Analytics and a former McCain adviser, has said that without the stimulus, unemployment would be much higher than it is. Harvard economist and former Reagan and Bush adviser Martin Feldstein supported the Obama stimulus, and his only criticism is that it wasn't large enough (thanks to the GOP).

None of this is to say that Obama has done things perfectly or that there aren't serious issues still facing the country, not the least of which is our out-of-control debt. But to suggest that we were better off four years ago is simply absurd.

Oh, and Osama bin Laden is dead.

Kirsten Powers is a columnist for The Daily Beast , a Fox News political analyst and a member of USA TODAY's Board of Contributors. She served in the Clinton administration from 1993 to 1998

I'm in it to win it!

NASDAQ DIP and RIP
Here is the best word that describes what i do here.
Intuitive;
means having the ability to understand or know something without any direct evidence or reasoning process.

I was born with it, I'm truly blessed!


Alway's searching for winners'
937206596_images.jpg
Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Oatly’s $4.13 Tender Offer Is a Legal Detour, Not a Sale

Updated Category News Views 100

A $4.13 cash offer trading against a $7.17 close is the sort of thing that makes investors squint hard, and Verlinvest is practically waving a flag telling them why. This is not a conventional attempt to buy Oatly Group AB. It is a technical tender offer built to satisfy Swedish takeover rules while Verlinvest buys out its joint-venture partner’s interest in Oatly’s...

Continue Reading
Chicago Kertész Show Puts Photography's Quiet Giant First

Updated Category News Views 112

A fork, a plate, and a sharp eye can outlast plenty of louder art. Leica Gallery Chicago is putting that proposition on the wall with André Kertész: The Master, opening December 4, 2026 and running through January 17, 2027. More than thirty signature works is not a sprawling museum survey, and frankly that may be the point. Kertész did not need grand scale to make his...

Continue Reading
Greenberg Traurig Adds Privacy Muscle in Denver Office

Updated Category News Views 139

Privacy work used to be the legal department's back-room plumbing; now it can jam an entire product launch. That is why Greenberg Traurig's decision to bring Amber Mednick in as of counsel in Denver deserves more attention than the usual law-firm hiring blurb. This is not a splashy deal, and nobody should pretend one lateral hire rewrites the competitive map. Still, it is...

Continue Reading
CVS Puts Youth Soccer Stories on Its Store Shelves

Updated Category News Views 76

Two kids with real community ties just got a megaphone most grown-ups never receive. CVS Pharmacy has named Caroline, 9, of Holmes Beach, Florida, and Zoe, 12, of Los Angeles, as the first grand-prize winners of its Home Team Heroes youth soccer contest. Each player’s selected nonprofit soccer organization will receive a $25,000 grant, while their stories will appear on...

Continue Reading
Duetti, CesiumAstro, and a Busy NYSE Capital Morning

Updated Category News Views 94

Three very different piles of money are jamming up the November 20 NYSE slate, and that contrast is the whole point. Private music catalogs, space-and-defense communications, and a new stock-and-bond ETF do not belong in the same bucket. Yet all three are competing for investor attention before the opening bell, alongside Danaos Corporation's 20th listing anniversary....

Continue Reading
AMP Pushes Debt Wall to 2029 With €1.3B Green Notes

Updated Category News Views 108

A Refinancing With Some Actual Breathing Room Metal cans may be boring, but a debt wall arriving in 2028 is not—and Ardagh Metal Packaging has moved that problem down the road. AMP priced €1.3 billion of senior secured floating-rate green notes on November 20, 2026. The proceeds are earmarked to redeem $600 million of senior secured green notes due in 2028 and €450...

Continue Reading
Teachstone’s Bronze Award Puts Classroom Quality in Focus

Updated Category News Views 36

Small Classroom Moments Finally Get Their Due A child’s hesitant question can disappear in the noise of a busy classroom, which is precisely why Teachstone’s latest recognition deserves more than the usual polite golf clap. The Charlottesville-based Certified B Corporation received a Bronze Anthem Award for its “From Measurement to Momentum” initiative, in the...

Continue Reading
Shenzhen’s 50-Year Message Carries Real Trade Weight

Updated Category News Views 68

A city once framed as a frontier fishing village is being presented as China’s sharpest recent economic before-and-after picture. At the welcome dinner for the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders’ Meeting in Shenzhen, President Xi Jinping gave guests a compact geographic guide to China’s past: Xi’an for thousands of years, Beijing for 500 years, Shanghai for 100 years, and...

Continue Reading
MTI Adds Aviation Veterans as Acorn Builds MRO Plan

Updated Category News Views 127

Two old hands entering a boardroom can matter more than another glossy growth slogan, especially in aircraft maintenance, where a delayed part can ground an airplane and turn a customer relationship sour in a hurry. MTI Aviation has added Tony DiSimone Sr. and Aviv Tzur to its board, a move announced November 20, 2026, after Acorn Capital Management took a majority...

Continue Reading
Sprocket’s GigaOm Leap Puts PTaaS Claims Under Scrutiny

Updated Category News Views 65

Security vendors love a shiny quadrant, but this one deserves more than the usual polite golf clap. Sprocket Security moved from Challenger and Outperformer in GigaOm’s 2025 Penetration Testing as a Service assessment to a Leader in the version 5 report released in 2026. That is a meaningful jump in a category where buyers are tired of annual testing reports that go...

Continue Reading

Top 5 Most Recently Viewed Articles

Aluminum Design Fumble: Geometry Over Wall Thickness

Updated Category News Views 420

A Misstep in Aluminum Design Practices Well, here's a nugget of wisdom for the metal enthusiasts out there—stop beefing up aluminum components with thicker walls and focus on smart geometry. This isn't a drill, folks. Mark Coyle, a seasoned mind over at American Custom Metals, has been waving the flag for smarter aluminum design methods right from Rochester, NY, and...

Continue Reading
BW LPG Limited Welcomes BW Chinook: A Significant Milestone

Updated Category News Views 180

Significant Acquisition by BW LPG Limited BW LPG Limited has recently taken a remarkable step in enhancing its fleet and operational capabilities. The company announced the acquisition of the vessel BW Chinook, marking an important milestone in its ongoing strategy to strengthen its position in the global LPG market. Details of the Vessel Delivery Following a stock...

Continue Reading
COMAC's Expansion: New Hong Kong Office and Maintenance Deal

Updated Category News Views 175

COMAC's Global Expansion Efforts Chinese planemaker COMAC has taken a significant step in its quest to enter the global passenger jet market by inaugurating its second international office in Hong Kong. This move aligns with their strategy to provide enhanced services and establish a stronger footprint outside mainland China. The opening not only symbolizes growth but...

Continue Reading
Torrid Holdings CEO Lisa Harper Makes Strategic Stock Move

Updated Category News Views 415

Lisa Harper's Recent Sale of Company Shares Lisa Harper, the CEO of Torrid Holdings Inc. (NYSE: CURV), has recently sold shares worth $283,909, according to a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission. In this transaction, she sold 74,713 shares at a price of $3.80 each. This sale is part of her exercise of the underwriters' option to purchase additional shares...

Continue Reading
Getty Images Plans Q3 2024 Financial Results Release Date

Updated Category News Views 102

Getty Images Announces Q3 2024 Financial Results Date Getty Images Holdings, Inc. (NYSE: GETY), a leader in the global visual content industry, is gearing up to share its financial results for the third quarter of 2024. The results will be unveiled right after market closing on November 7, 2024. This announcement signals an important moment for stakeholders keeping a...

Continue Reading