I'm Pete's sister, never post but follow CTIX every day!  I just had to comment on your question to my brother...

Ty Cobb RF

Mike Schmidt 3b

Lou Gehrig 1b

Babe Ruth DH (I needed a outfield spot for Ty Cobb)

Willie Mays CF

Ted Williams LF

Honus Wagner SS

Roger Hornsby 2B

Johnny Bench C (Pudge Rodrguez backup)

SP  Walter Johnson, Christy Mathewson, Bob Gibson, Sandy Koufax, Nolan Ryan

RP  Rivera, Fingers, Eckersly,