I don't quite understand your post. Facts about what the SP will most likely do with BTD based on history and data is not FUD, even if it's not what you want to hear.

And if anyone is right about anything 15 times in a row based on history, well, those who don't learn from history...

One good thing may wipe the shorts out, or one more bad thing (after 15 in a row) can sink a company. Smart longs and shorts know when to get out or when to reduce their positions based on history and facts. Emotion? No place here.