Fact-checking Donald Trump's misleading tweet about U.S.

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Aug 10, 2017 at 7:16 PM 342

Quote:

Fact-checking Donald Trump's misleading tweet about U.S. nuclear arsenal

Trump combines a lack of historical knowledge about the nation's nuclear arsenal together with his gnawing insecurity and buries the needle on the 'full of shit meter', yet again. LOL!

By Louis Jacobson on Wednesday, August 9th, 2017 at 4:02 p.m.

"My first order as president was to renovate and modernize our nuclear arsenal. It is now far stronger and more powerful than ever before."
— Donald Trump on Wednesday, August 9th, 2017 in a tweet

One day after threatening North Korea with "fire and fury like the world has never seen" if it menaces the United States, President Donald Trump tweeted about the strength of U.S. nuclear weapons and improvements made on his watch.

Trump wrote at 4:56 a.m: "My first order as president was to renovate and modernize our nuclear arsenal. It is now far stronger and more powerful than ever before."

This tweet is not accurate.

A week after taking office, Trump issued a presidential memorandum on "rebuilding the U.S. Armed Forces."

One sentence in this memo directs the defense secretary to "initiate a new Nuclear Posture Review to ensure that the United States nuclear deterrent is modern, robust, flexible, resilient, ready, and appropriately tailored to deter 21st-century threats and reassure our allies." The review effort kicked off in April 2017, according to news reports.

However, this wasn’t Trump’s first order as president — more than a dozen earlier executive orders and memoranda are listed on the White House website.

More importantly, asking for a Nuclear Posture Review is not unusual; it’s expected. The Defense Department’s web page for the Nuclear Posture Review describes it as "legislatively mandated."

Indeed, it’s common for new presidents to put their stamp on the nation’s nuclear capabilities by issuing a new review within two years after entering office.

Bill Clinton produced one in 1994. George W. Bush produced one in 2002. And Barack Obama produced one in 2010. (Apparently, the Trump administration hasn’t updated its Pentagon web page on the Nuclear Posture Review. When we accessed it on Aug. 9, it still had a photo and "notable quote" by Hillary Clinton on it.)

A larger issue with Trump’s assurance: Experts unanimously said the U.S. nuclear arsenal could not have improved to the extent Trump described in just over 200 days.

There have been incremental improvements, but they have been trickling out under a plan begun under Trump’s predecessor, Obama.

The United States is engaged in a multiyear program to modernize the nation’s nuclear arsenal, including the rebuilding of the Minuteman III system, which launches intercontinental ballistic missiles, and the Trident II submarine-launched missile systems, as well as the refurbishment of nuclear warheads and construction of new and upgraded facilities, such as a uranium processing facility in Oak Ridge, Tenn. (Here’s an updated rundown of the modernization plan published by the Arms Control Association.)

The modernization effort was estimated to cost roughly $35 billion a year over a decade, or 5 percent to 6 percent of planned national defense spending, according to Congressional Budget Office reports released in December 2013 and January 2015.

Its most recent estimate, released in February 2017, CBO said the modernization effort would cost $400 billion between 2017 and 2026, or $52 billion more than CBO’s 2015 estimate, "largely because modernization programs will be ramping up." Cumulatively, total costs could reach $1 trillion over the next 30 years.

Experts panned Trump's boast of rapid improvements.

"It would be a pretty fantastic claim under even Cold War standards given the size and scope of the arsenal," said Richard Nephew, a senior research scholar at Columbia University's Center on Global Energy Policy and a former State Department official under Obama. But given the restrictions under the New START treaty that went into force in 2011, it would be "pretty difficult, if not impossible, to achieve except in a crash, well-publicized effort."

Matthew Bunn, a nuclear-policy specialist who teaches at Harvard University's John F. Kennedy School of Government, called Trump’s claim "simply false."

"There is a total of nothing that has changed substantially about the U.S. nuclear arsenal over the few months that Trump has been in office," Bunn said. "We have the same missiles and bombers, with the same nuclear weapons, that we had before."

Bottom line: In the scale of decades, six months is a blink of the eye, experts said.

This is not the first time Trump has sought to paint a picture of weak stewardship of the U.S. nuclear arsenal under Obama. As early as June 2015, Trump said, "Even our nuclear arsenal doesn't work. It came out recently they have equipment that is 30 years old. They don't know if it worked." We rated that False.

Our ruling

Trump said, "My first order as president was to renovate and modernize our nuclear arsenal. It is now far stronger and more powerful than ever before."

What Trump did shortly after taking office was neither his first order nor a unique action; every new president in recent years has requested a Nuclear Posture Review.

In addition, the ongoing nuclear modernization plan -- which dates back to the Obama administration and will take decades to complete -- would not have notched achievements in six months sufficient to be characterized as "far stronger and more powerful than ever before."

We rate the statement False

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

RunVermont Revamps City Marathon, Adds Half for 2027

Straight outta Burlington, the M&T Bank Vermont City Marathon is giving its course a facelift and, get this, throwing a half marathon into the mix for 2027. It's about time they shook things up, considering how this race is supposed to be one of the most welcoming on the block. I mean, you're talking about a marathon that's practically been the crown jewel of Vermont's...

Foodsmart's Program Links Food Benefits to Health Gains

Navigating the healthcare maze isn't for the faint of heart, especially when it comes to making sure that dollars spent on food benefits actually translate to improved health. Enter Foodsmart, the foodcare powerhouse that just rolled out its Food-is-Medicine Benefits Management (FBM) program. Turning Meals into Measurable Metrics Health plans are under mounting pressure...

GoLive Streamers: A Social Media Wild Card

Stepping Boldly into the Livestreaming Arena There's a new kid in the chaotic neighborhood of social media, and it's called GoLive Streamers. Not just another aimless stroll down Content Highway, GoLive is weaving its own defining path by fostering genuine real-time interaction. Launched in April 2026, this plucky platform has quickly amassed a following of over 74,000...

Flux Expands AI Platform to Prove Engineering ROI

Navigating the AI Maze: Flux's New Pathways Ever feel like these engineering platforms speak a language of their own? Flux's latest expansion finally offers a translator that matters. It's all about decoding whether your AI investment is delivering the goods. Engineering leaders now have more than just fluffy metrics; Flux breaks down real code-based evidence to show if...

Infrared Imaging Expands with AI, SWIR: Tech Trends

Infrared Imaging: The Backbone of Future Tech Kinda wild how infrared imaging's become a hot topic in tech circles. With the market expected to jump from USD 9.2 billion in 2026 to a hefty USD 12.6 billion by 2031, averaging a 6.4% growth rate, there's plenty to chew on. Even if you ain't the analytical type, it ain't hard to spot where the money's flowing. Infrared's...

BlueCollar Backs SuiteWorld 2026 with Platinum Sponsorship

BlueCollar Cloud Aligns with SuiteWorld 2026 If you thought the construction ERP space was just a dusty office in a backlot, think again. BlueCollar Cloud is strapping on its boots and diving into the heart of SuiteWorld 2026 with a platinum sponsorship. This isn't just a walk in the park—it's a strategic power move, aligning themselves smack-dab in the middle of...

Riverside Theatre Appoints Seasoned CFO for Growth Phase

Change Is Afoot at Riverside Theatre Down in Vero Beach, amid the sun-drenched coziness of Florida’s Treasure Coast, something’s cooking that has nothing to do with sunshine: Riverside Theatre snagged itself a new Chief Financial Officer. As nonprofits go, this one’s not a backyard operation—it’s the largest independent professional theatre in the entire state....

Decision Logic Innovates with Vitals & ShiftFlow Tools

Restaurant Battlefields: The Need for Real-Time Response Running a restaurant is no walk in the park. One slip, and you're dealing with spoiled soup or crabby customers. Decision Logic reckons they've cracked the code to smoother operations with their new tools, Vitals and ShiftFlow. At heart, these products do one thing: put critical data into the hands of managers while...

Bay Crane's Bold Auction: A Strategic Fleet Update

Bay Crane's Big Move: Strategic Fleet Update through Auction Well, here's a twist that gets the pulse racing for industry folk and machinery buffs. Bay Crane Companies, a powerhouse in the crane and hauling sector, has decided to go all in on a strategic fleet update. And what better way to move that iron than with a live, no-reserve auction? They've tapped Jeff Martin...

Mattamy Homes Earns Spot as Top Workplace in Jacksonville

Jacksonville's Housing Scene Gets a Boost In a world where everyone seems bent on working down to the bone to climb some imaginary corporate ladder, here comes Jacksonville's own Mattamy Homes with a news flash—it's possible to work, live, and still smile at the end of the day. Recently, they earned themselves a coveted spot among the best workplaces in Jacksonville for...