The Health Care Bill Could Be A Job-Killer For GOP

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

May 4, 2017 at 4:36 PM 287

Quote:

The Health Care Bill Could Be A Job-Killer For GOP Incumbents

May 4, 2017 at 3:29 PM

By Nate Silver

Republicans in the House of Representatives voted today to approve a version of the American Health Care Act, their bill to repeal and replace Obamacare. The biggest effects of the bill will be on the millions of additional Americans who would go without health insurance if a similar bill is passed by the Senate.

But it could also endanger the job prospects of the Republican members of Congress who voted for it and make a Democratic takeover of the House substantially more likely in 2018.

The previous version of the AHCA — which died in the House in March before it came to a floor vote — was an exceptionally unpopular bill. Polls in mid-March had opposition outweighing support for the bill by an average of almost 15 percentage points, and the numbers were getting worse; most notoriously in a Quinnipiac poll that showed just 17 percent of Americans supporting the bill and 56 percent opposed.

The various amendments to the AHCA since then — which were mostly made to placate the Freedom Caucus and have pushed the bill further to the right — aren’t likely to make it any more popular.

Some of the amendments could even affect people who receive insurance from their employers in addition to those who receive Medicaid or buy insurance on the Obamacare exchanges.

Republicans are also playing with political fire to pass such a bill before the Congressional Budget Office has scored the amendments and estimated how many additional people might gain or lose coverage. well now isn't that just nitpicky shit? LOL!

In 2010, Democrats who voted for Obamacare paid a huge price in the midterms. Just how big a price? A 2011 study by FiveThirtyEight contributor Seth Masket and another political scientist, Steven Greene, found that Democrats who voted for Obamacare lost 6.6 to 7.6 percentage points of the vote, depending on which model they used.

Note, however, that these totals refer to the share of the vote the Democrat lost and not to the margin that the Democrat had against the Republican. Since third-party candidates are rarely major factors in House races, almost every vote the Democrat loses is one the Republican gains. Thus, the effect on the Democrat’s margin against the Republican was roughly twice that — 13 to 15 percentage points. That’s a huge effect; it means that a Democrat who was on track to cruise to re-election by 12 points would lose if they’d voted for Obamacare.

A later study by Masket, Greene and three other researchers found impacts of a similar magnitude, estimating a 5.8 percentage point Obamacare effect on the Democrat’s vote share using one technique, and an 8.5-point effect using another. Again, these are vote shares, not vote margins. (We usually think in terms of margins here at FiveThirtyEight). The margins would be roughly twice as high — in the range of 12- to 17-point penalty for a Democrat who voted for Obamacare.

If Republican members should suffer a similar penalty for voting for the AHCA — somewhere in the neighborhood of 15 points — it could put dozens of GOP-held seats in play. Some 33 Republicans won their seats by 14 percentage points or less in 20161

; of those, 27 voted for the AHCA.

Republicans in the next tier or two down could also be vulnerable, however, because the overall political climate is likely to be a lot worse for Republicans than it was in 2016.

In 2016, Republicans won the aggregate popular vote for the U.S. House by about 1 percentage point. Democrats currently have a 5- to 6-point lead in polls of the 2018 House vote, however.

Moreover, the numbers for the president’s party usually get worse over the course of the midterm cycle as more voters tune into the political process. There could easily be an overall partisan swing of 5 to 10 percentage points against Republicans, therefore. It’s not quite clear how this partisan swing would interact with the AHCA penalty — whether you’d add them together or whether that’s double-counting — but it should be enough to make a lot of Republican incumbents nervous. There are 58 Republicans who won by less than 20 points in 20162

and who voted for the AHCA.

There are some mitigating factors for Republicans, however. Unlike Obamacare, the AHCA is somewhat unlikely to become law, at least in its present form: It faces considerable opposition in the Senate, which would likely pass a more moderate bill if it passed one at all.

The Republican process for negotiating the AHCA also hasn’t been as drawn out as the one Democrats had for Obamacare. And President Trump makes a lot of news that could compete with the health care vote for attention. If the bill quietly dies in the Senate this summer, for instance, it’s not clear that a vote taken in May 2017 will be at the top of voters’ minds in November 2018.

Then again, in 2010, Democrats engaged in a lot of wishful thinking around Obamacare, hoping they could avoid the effects from passing a substantially unpopular piece of legislation that affected one-sixth of the U.S. economy. They were wrong; they got their health care bill but not without a big electoral price.

There’s even a chance that Republicans could suffer a bigger penalty than Democrats did. As unpopular as Obamacare was as it was being debated by Congress in 2009 and 2010, the AHCA is more unpopular still.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

BMO's Strategic Exit: Transportation Finance Sale

A Major Shift in BMO’s Strategic Direction When it comes to banking, BMO ain't playing small ball. They've just doubled down on their decision to part ways with their Transportation Finance and Vendor Finance operations, selling off a hefty part of these portfolios to Stonepeak. Now, that might sound like a mouthful, but hang tight, the nitty-gritty's where it gets...

IANS Enhances Cybersecurity with Microsoft Copilot Integration

Cybersecurity Intelligence Meets Convenience Imagine the chaos of a Monday morning without your go-to coffee: that's your security team trying to make informed decisions without robust data. But now, with a dash of innovation, IANS has amped up the stakes by integrating its wealth of cybersecurity intelligence with Microsoft Copilot. It's no small beans, folks. The...

ZYNLONTA's Japanese Push: ADC Therapeutics Gains Traction

ADC Therapeutics Eyes Japan with ZYNLONTA Bet These days, everyone seems to have their eyes on the Far East, and ADC Therapeutics is no exception. They're making a strategic leap by letting their budding blockbuster ZYNLONTA make waves in Japan. With the fresh file submitted for approval, it looks like they're hoping to capture market ground that could pay off big time...

Abel Leads PRSA Maryland Chesapeake as New Chapter President

New Leadership and Opportunities in the PR Landscape Amid all the hustle and bustle of the corporate world, something big's brewing in Baltimore's public relations sphere. Greg Abel, the go-getting mastermind behind Abel Communications, has taken the helm of the newly formed PRSA Maryland Chesapeake chapter. This isn't just about shifting chairs or fancy titles—this...

Webull Faces Class Action: Investor Impact Deep Dive

What's Going On with Webull? Ah, Webull Corporation, you're in the hot seat now. If you blinked on October 7th, you might have missed a monumental 19.09% cliff dive in Webull's stock, tumbling down to a humble $5.89. The roar wasn't just the market reacting; it was the sonic boom of a class action lawsuit on their heels, alleging some slick legal sledding with misleading...

Victory Gala Honors Heroes, Raises Over $500K

A Night Celebrating Service and Sacrifice You know, in times like these, it’s refreshing to see events that focus on giving back rather than taking everything to the bank. Victory Home Remodeling, along with its nonprofit arm, the Victory Foundation, recently hosted their second annual gala in Woodland Park, New Jersey to give some much-needed limelight to those who put...

SKE Invigorates IRONWORKS London's Music Vibe With E-Cigs

Bringing SKE's Flair to London's Music Scene Well, folks, hold onto your hats—SKE's thrown its weight behind IRONWORKS London, extending its reach deeper into the UK's electronic music scene. This ain't just another gig; we're talking about the second time SKE is flexing its sponsorship muscles in the UK music arena, officially angling for the vape category spotlight....

TIOmarkets App Unveils Enhanced Trading Features

Trading on the Go Takes a Leap Forward Pretty slick development from TIOmarkets, if I do say so myself. They've rolled out a major expansion of their mobile trading app, now packing some hefty features like Depth of Market and more granular order controls right from those little devices in our pockets. Quite the leap if you're one of those folks who can't keep your eyes...

Rockford Fosgate Elevates Marketing Maverick to Lead Role

Changing the Guard in High-Performance Audio Marketing Out of Arizona, we get a shake-up that feels like a no-brainer for anyone in the high-performance audio market. Rockford Fosgate decided to elevate Tammy Lowe to the Vice President of Marketing role, effective immediately. With nearly four decades under her belt at the sunny Tempe-based HQ, it's hard to argue with the...

Concurrence Expands Reach With Microsoft Marketplace

Concurrence's Big Move into Microsoft's Court From the bustling streets of New York to the mighty tech avenues of Seattle, Concurrence is making waves that could leave a whale-sized impact on the healthcare sector. As of today, their Health World Model and snazzy AI agents have entered the Microsoft Marketplace, marking a significant leap forward. For the uninitiated,...