Federal funds to sanctuary cities exceed the cost of

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (0) Message Board

Feb 5, 2017 at 8:51 AM 167

Federal funds to sanctuary cities exceed the cost of building the wall
By Joseph Smith
February 5, 2017

The federal government spends more every year funding sanctuary cities than it would cost to build a wall on our southern border.

The Washington Examiner highlights a new report that says the federal government spends nearly $27 billion annually on grants and payments to 106 American sanctuary cities – "money that President Trump has threatened to cut off if they continue to thwart federal immigration officials from seizing illegals in jail for local crimes."

The sanctuary city report posted at openthebooks.com notes further that there are "nearly 300 government jurisdictions of states, counties, cities and other governments claiming" sanctuary status.

In contrast, estimates to complete another 1,300 miles of the southern border wall – 670 miles of fencing have already been completed – range from $15 billion to $25 billion.

States such as Texas, Iowa, and Virginia are debating laws that would cut off state funding for sanctuary cities, defined in a proposed Virginia law as "localities adopting any procedure or policy that restricts the enforcement of federal immigration laws," while other states such as California and Oregon would "block police from enforcing federal immigration law."

Big-city mayors like New York's Bill de Blasio and Chicago's Rahm Emanuel have vowed to "use the courts to fight" the president's executive order blocking federal funds to sanctuary cities.

The federal funds involved in those two cities alone, as listed in the sanctuary cities report, are staggering: $7.6 billion for New York and $5.3 billion for Chicago.

The report provides a detailed breakout of the various grants and payments to New York City, with those funds amounting to almost 10 percent of New York's $82-billion annual budget. New York City has 585,000 "undocumented persons," according to the report.

Sanctuary cities receive federal funding for local police and fire departments, schools, housing, and city services, according to the report, with $16 billion of the total flowing into "just twelve major American cities – where 1 in 5 illegal entrants reside."

The report says the insubordinate cities are imposing a "defiance tax" on their citizens:

Mayors defending their sanctuary city status by refusing to comply with federal law are essentially imposing a defiance tax on local residents. On average, this tax amounts to $500 per man, woman and child.

The sanctuary cities funding numbers provide juicy headlines, but the reality of which funds, if any, would be blocked by the Trump executive order remains to be seen.

The most likely area for blocking federal funds may be law enforcement funds related to incarcerating illegal immigrants – funds that are in the millions, rather than billions. A Texas Republican has done some diligent groundwork in that regard.

Rep. John Culberson, a House appropriations subcommittee chairman, has used his control over Justice Department spending to act on a 1996 Immigration Act that includes a "section 8 U.S.C. 1373, which provided that no state or local entity can in any way restrict its law-enforcement officials from communicating with federal immigration authorities regarding an individual's citizenship or immigration status," according to an article in National Review last fall:

After Culberson met with officials within the Justice Department and made clear that their financial situation could become strained if they refused to cooperate, the department released guidance notifying all U.S. jurisdictions that they must comply with all federal law – including 8 U.S.C. 1373 – in order to receive federal grants.

"I've effectively created an off-switch that Attorney General Sessions and President Trump can throw at noon on January 20 to cut off all federal law-enforcement grants to these cities."

In an interview to air this Sunday, Culberson adds:

It's real easy, their money disappears. There's no fight, their money is gone.

... They are in violation of federal law because federal law requires state and local jurisdictions can't interfere in any way with sharing information about criminal illegal aliens in their custody; in any way means you must cooperate 100 percent of the time – 99 out of 100 of sharing information is not enough.

…These are law enforcement grants for the law enforcement of the country and state, the cost of incarcerating illegal aliens in custody, which is particularly galling that these sanctuary jurisdictions hide and protect criminal aliens in their jails from being deported, but they still have to ask for federal money for housing the criminal alien.

The openthebooks.com report concludes that the battle over withholding federal funds to sanctuary cities may ultimately be resolved by the United States Supreme Court.

Withholding federal funds as leverage to encourage states to comply with federal laws is not a new idea. In 1987, the Supreme Court "upheld a law that forced states to raise the drinking age to 21 or lose millions in highway dollars":

Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist said that while Congress' power to control federal money is not unlimited, it can be used in the pursuit of the "general welfare."

... While Congress may lack the power to directly impose a national drinking age, Rehnquist said, "we conclude that encouragement to state action ... is a valid use of the spending power."

Federal highway funds were also used as leverage to enforce a nationwide 55-mile-per-hour speed limit during the 1974 Arab oil embargo, and again in 1995 to restore state control over speed limits.

The battle royal over federal funds for largely Democrat-controlled sanctuary cities has just begun.

Featured stocks: Coffee Shoppe
For conservative debate: "Keeping it Real"
Game Changing stock $SHMP

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Black Friday Doubt Grows: Just 54% Trust Real Deals

Do Shoppers Believe in Black Friday Anymore? You'd think by now, retailers would have cracked the code on building trust with their customers. But guess what? A fresh survey from Boston Consulting Group reveals only 54% of consumers buy the whole Black Friday discount story. That's barely more than flipping a coin. Promotion Fatigue: The Trust Buster Funny thing,...

Young Storytellers Honored: Bridging Cultures Through Journalism

Leaders of Tomorrow: Campus News Awards 2026 It's no small feat to look at a room full of young journalists and see the future of how stories will be told. But that's exactly what happened at the Campus News Awards 2026 in Shenzhen. Here, kids from Hong Kong, Macao, Taiwan, and Southeast Asia stood proudly with their certificates, ready to tackle the changing landscape of...

TSX Surges Amid Earnings Wave and Market Momentum

TSX Soars, But What's Driving the Surge? Gotta say, when the TSX leaps over 2% in a single day, it sets the stage for two things: excitement and scrutiny. On a balmy Wednesday, Canada's stock market stood tall at 36,317.67, up 785.39 points. Wall Street joined the dance too, with the Dow kicking up by 1,543.75 points. Good vibes all around — but hang on a minute. You...

Marini SkinSolutions Wins with Night Zyme Complex

Shaking Up the Skincare Scene You don't often see a skincare product snag three prestigious awards in one year, but that's exactly what's unfolding for Marini SkinSolutions. This time, their Night Zyme® Overnight Glass Skin Resurfacing Complex grabbed the 2026 Shop TODAY Ageless Beauty Award. It’s turning heads and not just in beauty aisles but among investors eyeing a...

Defense Contractors Eye Larger Backlogs Amid Funding Uncertainty

Playing Chicken with Federal Deadlines We've got ourselves a situation where defense contractors are juggling bigger backlogs while the clock ticks down to a looming federal funding deadline on December 11. If this sounds like a high-stakes game of chicken, it's because it is. No one knows if Congress will stitch things up before the stopgap funding dries up. Hell, maybe...

MAURE's Three-Year Mark: Crafting Home Elegance

Brooklyn's Gem: MAURE Turns Three Over in Brooklyn, there's a brand bubbling with style called MAURE. Now, we're talking three years strong, surviving the wild bout of the retail scene with a firm two feet planted in home and gifting. The Vision Turned Reality When Maureen Cavalieri, a hospitality veteran since 2009, first tossed this spark into the wind in 2023, it...

Trimble's Q3 2026: Guidance Update and Record ARR

Trimble Smashes Through Q3 Expectations Trimble Inc. (NASDAQ:TRMB) tossed a bit of a curveball by posting Q3 2026 results that sailed past analyst forecasts. We’re talking revenue swelling to $966.8 million, a decent 7% bump from the previous year. Now, for a company riding its 'Connect & Scale' strategy, this serves as a validation of its aggressive scaling ambitions....

Duolingo Faces Class Action: Investors React Strongly

Duolingo's Rough Road: A Lawsuit in Motion Alright, fasten your seatbelts, because we've got a real rollercoaster here with Duolingo (NASDAQ: DUOL). You know, the language-learning app that's been pushing ads like it's going out of style? Well, investors are seeing red—not the kind you want, either. This class action lawsuit looming over them is like an unwelcome...

Natixis' $100M Student Challenge Mixes Real Stakes

Opportunity Knocks for Budding Portfolio Managers Picture this: You're a student, neck-deep in textbooks and theories, and then bam! You're handed the keys to manage a $100 million portfolio. That's the real-deal opportunity Natixis Investment Managers is dangling with its seventh Students Challenge. Diving Into the Nuts and Bolts Listen up, kids. Applications are open...

NACCO Navigates Strong 2026 Q3, Faces Solar Cost Hurdles

Rolling With NACCO's Financial Punches Well, folks, when it rains, it pours—numbers that is. NACCO Industries just laid out their Q3 results for all to gawk at, and it's a mixed bag of triumphs and tussles. You got a gross profit of $11.8 million, a sweet 18% jump on the same quarter last year. Now, you're talking about revenue muscle, and there it is. Income before...