Why would that make you question their motives (highlighting negative facts)? With investing, the main decision points are whether to buy more, sell some (or all) or just hold tight, right? Investors are concerned with making money, but also with preserving the cash that is invested, as much as possible. That means that everyone is deciding where this investment stands within their own risk tolerance and whether they should stay in or start to get out. Exploring the good and the bad is pretty essential for doing that. Searching for the most information possible is key in making that decision - and that includes finding positive facts and negative facts.