A graduated income tax could put Illinois in the

New Post Public Reply Private Reply Replies (1) Message Board

Aug 15, 2016 at 1:04 PM

Quote:

A graduated income tax could put Illinois in the clear

By Curtis Black | April 21, 2016

SPRINGFIELD, ILLINOIS, USA - SEPTEMBER 1; Ornate dome inside state capital building/Shutterstock

Instituting a progressive income tax in Illinois would destroy the economy and drive people to flee the state, according to Gov. Bruce Rauner and his supporters.

After the economic refugees got over the border, however, they’d have to keep running. That’s because income tax rates are higher in every bordering state, according to a recent study by the Illinois Economic Policy Institute.

Illinois currently has a flat 3.75 percent individual income tax. Indiana is the only neighboring state with a flat rate – it’s 3.3 percent. But Indiana permits counties to levy income taxes, and the average county rate is 1.5 percent.

The other states have progressive rates; the lowest is Missouri’s, which rises in steps from 1.5 percent to 6 percent – that’s for people earning less than $1,000 a year and those earning over $9,000 a year, respectively. Wisconsin’s top rate, which is for individuals earning over $69,000 a year, is 7.65 percent; Iowa’s is 8.9 percent for people earning over $60,000.

Looking at the combination of state and local taxes, all the states have regressive tax structures, with poor people paying a higher proportion of their income than the wealthy.

But Illinois is the worst. Here the bottom fifth of earners pay 13 percent of their income in state and local taxes, while the top 1 percent pays 4.6 percent, or about a third of what poor people pay.

Compare that to Wisconsin, where the bottom fifth pays about 9 percent of its income, and the top 1 percent pays a little over 6 percent.

Progressive taxation is fairer, since the people who pay more are those who can afford to, and it’s also more efficient and stable because it taxes the sector that has benefited from economic growth for the past several decades.

But perhaps the most interesting statistic – particularly with our accumulated budget deficit topping $9 billion and growing – is how the neighboring states bring in much more revenue than Illinois. That’s not just from a smarter income tax; it’s because unlike Illinois, they’ve all extended their sales taxes to cover services, and they all tax some retirement income.

Adopting Indiana’s tax structure would give Illinois $4.6 billion more each year. Using Iowa’s structure would bring in $7.3 billion more, and Wisconsin’s would yield $8.3 billion more.

That would put Illinois in the clear.

House Democrats have introduced a constitutional amendment to permit a progressive income tax; and if that’s passed, they will introduce legislation that would provide a tax cut to all but the wealthiest taxpayers in the state and raise an additional $1.9 billion a year.

Under that plan, introduced by Rep. Lou Lang, D-Skokie, the tax rate on incomes up to $100,000 (twice that for couples) would be reduced to 3.5 percent. It would rise to the current rate of 3.75 for income up to $500,000, to 8.75 for the next $500,000, and to 9.75 for income over $1 million ($1.5 million for couples).

According to Voices for Illinois Children, that means a couple earning $1 million would pay an additional $11,785 in income taxes.

That’s probably not enough to cover their costs of relocating -- especially when they’d end up paying higher taxes if they moved next door.

Lang’s proposal doesn’t put Illinois’ budget in the black, but it goes part of the way. According to the Center for Tax and Budget Accountability, the state could raise an additional $2 billion by extending the sales tax and another $1 billion by taxing retirement income over $50,000. And there are huge corporate tax loopholes that are ripe for the closing.

For decades, Springfield Democrats have shied away from these kinds of reforms, putting their political fortunes ahead of fiscal responsibility. Now Rauner has brought the state to the brink of disaster; maybe the legislature will muster the courage to act.

Newer

Older

Scroll down for more posts ▼

Top 10 Most Recent News Articles

Aranscia Joins Northside Hospital in Precision Oncology

Unifying Molecular Diagnostics for Better Cancer Care In the chaos of today’s healthcare, Aranscia is aiming to rewrite the book on how we handle cancer diagnostics by teaming up with Northside Hospital Cancer Institute. Now, instead of fumbling through disconnected systems, they plan to glue the pieces together with a blend of their own and borrowed tech. This...

TerraMaster 725 NAS Unveils AI-Era Storage Solutions

Tech Giants and Pioneers Rejoice Strap in, because TerraMaster just waved the green flag on their brand-new 725 Series Xeon Rackmount NAS, and it's high time the data storage world got a shake-up. Picture this: we're in the throes of an AI boom, and companies have data needs that gobble up yesterday's solutions with the hunger of a black hole. Well, enter TerraMaster's...

2026 Beauty Icon Awards: Honoring Black Beauty Excellence

When it comes to honoring legacy and future within the Black beauty industry, the 2026 Beauty Icon Awards seem ready to steal the spotlight. Set to take place on October 10th at Atlanta's Riverside EpiCenter, this gathering is more than just a fancy shindig – it's a tribute to Black beauty's massive influence on culture and commerce. Celebrating Pioneers and Innovators...

iFranchise Holds Top Spot in Consulting for 8 Years

iFranchise's Unyielding Dominance in Franchise Consulting Five seconds in the franchise game, and you'd know that staying on top is a grind. But when you're iFranchise Group, it seems like the eighth time is the charm—if there ever was a need for luck. These folks have secured the number one spot in Entrepreneur magazine's Top Franchise Suppliers ranking yet again....

ABnet Touts Anthropic's AI in Corporate Evolution

Changing the AI Game in Enterprise At the heart of Tel Aviv-Yafo, ABnet Communication Ltd. is spitting fire, and this ain't your average tech chatter. They're drilling right down to the marrow, stressing just how much Anthropic—kingpin of advanced AI for enterprises—is shaking up the corporate shell game. Today’s conversation leans heavily into autonomous AI, and...

Dr. Sarah Leary Leads CBTN's Growth in Pediatric Oncology

Pioneering Leadership for Children's Brain Tumor Network In a world where every advance in pediatric oncology can make a measurable difference, the Children's Brain Tumor Network (CBTN) has just unveiled quite the ace up its sleeve: Dr. Sarah Leary. She's stepping in as Co-Chair of its Executive Board, taking the reins alongside Brian Rood, MD. With extensive experience...

ScriptSafe Revolutionizes Pharmacy Payment & Ad Certification

Pharmacy Certification Made Easy When ScriptSafe rolled out its certification service for pharmacies, it felt like the industry's straitjacket was finally coming off. We’re talking about a process that traditionally took months, cost a small fortune, and made pharmacies fill out forms like they were honing a doctoral thesis. But now, you've got ScriptSafe offering a...

Partners International Launches CareerPath for Youth

A Fresh Start for Young Careers with CareerPath You remember the time in life when we thought just having a degree meant something? Well, the game’s changed, and now it’s a twisted jungle where young folks struggle to find their footing. Partners International, a name I’m no stranger to—known for their human capital wizardry—seems to have noticed this chaotic...

Matchi Debuts Protein-Packed Matcha Lattes in Cans

A New Twist on Protein Beverages Today, Matchi Global LLC is rolling out something new and bold: canned protein matcha lattes. It's not just another protein shake disguised in green robes. Oh no, this is a straight-up attempt to mesh pure ceremonial-grade matcha with a full 20 grams of complete filtered milk protein. And they’re delivering it all without any of those...

Saudi Arabia Unveils CEER's Flagship Electric Vehicles

CEER's Ambitious Leap in Automotive Innovation There's a new kid on the automotive block, and it's making some serious noise. Straight out of Jeddah, CEER has just taken the wraps off their flagship electric sedan and SUV, dubbed the EXOBOT. No small beans here—this is a full-throttle, Saudi-driven pitch into the global automotive circus. And why not? There's oil in...