Posted On: 06/04/2014 8:35:59 PM
Post# of 43065
Re: StockSpock #8689
They say "manufacture". Not procure, not fabricate. That implies to me it was an off-the-shelf item, not custom-made. Welding is a very exacting science. there are steps to test welds, like X-Ray. I would be highly suspicious if it was a custom item. After all is said and done, a weld is stronger than the original material. Welds just don't fail like that.
But if it was an off the shelf part (the condenser), it may have happened.
Also, from my research, a stitch weld is not what one would use on a pressure vessel. Then again, it is not my area of expertise. It is a hydrogen/ nitrogen thing..
I have not read the report yet..
But, it does not end there. JBI would have had to have a Commissioning step where each item is tested on it's own, it should not have passed that.
Further, JBI should be able to make a claim against the manufacturer for damages if the part is defective. And, it should have been resolved fairly easily. They are saying they have run out of money??? hmm ho hum.
But if it was an off the shelf part (the condenser), it may have happened.
Also, from my research, a stitch weld is not what one would use on a pressure vessel. Then again, it is not my area of expertise. It is a hydrogen/ nitrogen thing..
I have not read the report yet..
But, it does not end there. JBI would have had to have a Commissioning step where each item is tested on it's own, it should not have passed that.
Further, JBI should be able to make a claim against the manufacturer for damages if the part is defective. And, it should have been resolved fairly easily. They are saying they have run out of money??? hmm ho hum.
(0)
(0)
Scroll down for more posts ▼