Historic Settlement Reached for Philadelphia's Tun Tavern
Historic Reproduction to Proceed
The two organizations involved in the endeavor to recreate the renowned Tun Tavern in Philadelphia have come to a settlement regarding their legal dispute. This historic tavern, built in 1686, served as a pivotal gathering place for colonial America. It was frequented by the Framers of the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution, and many significant organizations began within its walls.
The Tun Tavern holds a special place in history, being the first recruiting station for the U.S. Marine Corps and the first Grand Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons in North America. Notably, John Adams crafted the Articles of War there, which laid the groundwork for the U.S. Navy. In June 1775, George Washington was honored at a banquet there to celebrate his appointment as the commander of the Continental Army. Charitable societies like St. Andrew's, St. Patrick, and St. George were founded at The Tun in the 18th century and continue to serve the Philadelphia community today. Despite its demolition in the late 18th century, various efforts have been made to revive this essential piece of American history.
Aljess LLC, run by former Marine Montgomery Dahm, has held the federal rights to the "Tun Tavern" trademark and has been operating a brewpub under that name in Atlantic City since 1998. Recently, The Tun Legacy Foundation, a charitable organization recognized as a 501(c)(3), revealed its plans to construct a historically accurate reproduction of The Tun in Old City Philadelphia, very close to its original location. This venture aims to generate profit that will be donated to veterans' charities, the Pennsylvania Freemasons, and the three charitable societies founded at The Tun. The Legacy Foundation has secured federal trademark rights to the name "The Tun," purchased a piece of land on South 2nd Street, and commenced fundraising for the construction. Architectural plans have been approved, and building permits are in place. So far, the Foundation has raised approximately $11 million out of a projected construction budget of $21 million.
In May 2024, Aljess filed a lawsuit against the Legacy Foundation in federal court, asserting that the Foundation's attempt to open its version of The Tun would infringe on its trademark rights and create confusion for patrons. Later, in November 2025, Aljess opened a new Tun Tavern restaurant on Chestnut Street in Old City as part of their expansion.
The recent settlement marks a resolution to the conflict over their competing visions for The Tun in Philadelphia. While the specifics of the settlement remain confidential, it is public knowledge that the lawsuit has been dismissed, and the Legacy Foundation is permitted to use the "Tun Tavern" name within its historic reproduction. Conversely, Aljess will maintain its rights to open Tun Tavern locations elsewhere in the country.
Mr. Dahm expressed his contentment with the outcome, stating, "As a Marine, the history of the Tun Tavern is more than just a business interest—it is a matter of honor, heritage, and patriotism. For nearly three decades, I have been proud to uphold this historic legacy. I always envisioned a project of this magnitude moving forward in Philadelphia, the cradle of our nation's independence, and I am confident that The Tun Legacy Foundation will achieve this goal. I feel we have reached a harmonious agreement that honors the birthplace of the Marine Corps and those who have defended our country while preserving the deep historical significance of The Tun. This resolution allows Aljess to pursue its future growth while ensuring the story of the Tun Tavern is told with the reverence it deserves."
Craig Mills, a Marine combat veteran and lead attorney for The Tun Legacy Foundation, mentioned, "I am grateful that my law firm, Buchanan Ingersoll, supported my colleague Erin Napoleon and me in serving the Legacy Foundation pro bono throughout this case. Along with the Foundation's Board and our many donors nationwide, I am eager to complete the fundraising necessary to rebuild The Tun. We aim to restore this remarkable part of American history to Philadelphia and to all the distinguished organizations established there, enriching every visitor's experience in our historic district."
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Tun Tavern?
The Tun Tavern was a historic establishment built in 1686 in Philadelphia, known for being a hub for significant colonial activities and was frequented by the Framers of U.S. foundational documents.
Who are the parties involved in the Tun Tavern lawsuit?
The lawsuit was primarily between Aljess LLC, which operates a brewpub under the name Tun Tavern, and The Tun Legacy Foundation, which aims to build a historical reproduction of the original Tun Tavern.
What was the outcome of the lawsuit settlement?
The settlement included a dismissal of the lawsuit, allowing the Legacy Foundation to use the "Tun Tavern" name while permitting Aljess to open establishments in other locations outside Philadelphia.
Why is the Tun Tavern historically significant?
The Tun Tavern is significant for its integral role in early American history, including being the birthplace of the Marine Corps and a meeting place for influential figures during founding events.
How much funding has the Legacy Foundation raised for the project?
The Legacy Foundation has successfully raised approximately $11 million towards the total estimated construction budget of $21 million for the Tun Tavern reproduction.
