Dr. David Carlson Appointed as President and CEO at Physicians Insurance
Seattle, WA – Physicians Insurance A Mutual Company (PI), recognized for its expertise in medical professional liability, has named Dr. David Carlson, DO, as its new President and CEO, set to officially take on the role on November 1, 2025. Dr. Carlson succeeds William Cotter, who has decided to retire after a commendable 35-year tenure, including six years of devoted leadership at Physicians Insurance.
Background and Experience of Dr. Carlson
With a rich history of 25 years in various healthcare executive positions, Dr. Carlson brings a wealth of knowledge to this new role. Previously, he has excelled as the Chief Physician Officer at MultiCare Health System in Washington, Hospital Sisters Health System in Illinois, and at Conemaugh Health System in Pennsylvania. Most recently, he was the Chief Medical Officer and Vice President of Medical Operations for King County at Virginia Mason Franciscan Health.
Leadership Influence in Insurance
Dr. Carlson has been an integral member of the Physicians Insurance Board since 2018 and served as Board Chair from 2019 to 2023. His board contributions have been substantial, overseeing crucial aspects such as operations, governance, regulatory compliance, executive compensation, and investment strategies.
Transition in Leadership
Chairman of the Board, Dr. Shane Macaulay, expressed, "As Physicians Insurance enters its 45th year, it's fitting that a company founded by physicians will be led by one. Dr. Carlson understands the clinical and business hurdles our members encounter, and he ardently supports our mission to protect, defend, and support them. I look forward to our collaboration as we embark on this new chapter together. My sincere appreciation goes to Bill for his remarkable leadership and dedication to our members during his tenure."
Farewell to William Cotter
William Cotter, the outgoing President and CEO, has made significant contributions to the organization since 2019. Under his leadership, the organization has achieved notable advancements, such as enhancing underwriting capabilities, broadening the company's national presence, and integrating the Physicians Insurance RRG into the PI family. "It has been a privilege to serve our members and lead a dedicated team focused on protecting their interests," Mr. Cotter shared. "Dr. Carlson embodies our commitment to excellent healthcare and effective advocacy for physicians and medical practices. His leadership will be an invaluable resource for PI going forward."
Strategic Vision for the Future
Christina Galicia, COO of Physicians Insurance, noted Dr. Carlson's engagement in developing a multi-year strategic plan aimed at strengthening the organization's financial health while keeping the best interests of members at the forefront. "We are excited to welcome him to his new role," she said.
Commitment to Members
Dr. Carlson emphasized, "Physicians Insurance proudly dedicates itself to serving its members by providing robust legal defense support and ensuring timely claims payments. I am honored to step into this leadership position, continuing the legacy of protecting our members so they can focus on providing excellent medical care to their patients."
Professional Qualifications
An accomplished family practice physician, Dr. Carlson is board-certified and holds a special interest in geriatrics. He finished his undergraduate studies at Pennsylvania State University, achieved a medical degree from the Philadelphia College of Osteopathic Medicine, and completed an MBA at Alvernia University.
About Physicians Insurance
Physicians Insurance is a prominent national mutual insurance company committed to safeguarding, supporting, and defending its members. The organization specializes in medical malpractice and stop-loss insurance solutions backed by strong financial stability, offering exceptional and personalized service.
Contact Information
If you are seeking assistance or further information, please reach out to Melissa Cunningham at (206) 757-6221.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Dr. David Carlson?
Dr. David Carlson is the newly appointed President and CEO of Physicians Insurance A Mutual Company, effective November 1, 2025.
What experience does Dr. Carlson bring to the role?
Dr. Carlson has 25 years of healthcare executive experience, having held key positions in several health systems across the United States.
What were William Cotter's accomplishments at Physicians Insurance?
William Cotter led significant advancements in underwriting, expanded the company's national presence, and integrated the Physicians Insurance RRG.
How will Dr. Carlson impact the organization?
Dr. Carlson is expected to support the organization’s mission to defend and support its members while guiding the strategic plan for financial strength.
What services does Physicians Insurance provide?
Physicians Insurance specializes in medical malpractice and stop-loss insurance, delivering personalized service to its members.
